13 Top Eyeshadows for Older Women and Age-Defying Looks (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase.

We’ve all been there: standing in front of the makeup aisle, struggling to find the perfect eyeshadow for our mature skin.

As we age, our eyelids become more delicate, and finding the ideal eyeshadow to complement and enhance our eyes can feel like an impossible task.

But fear not! There is a world of beautiful and flattering eyeshadow options geared specifically toward mature ladies.

And we’re here to take the guesswork out of selecting the top eyeshadow for older women!

We’ve researched and compiled a comprehensive list of the top eyeshadows across various categories to suit all your needs and preferences.

So without further ado, here are the top eyeshadows for mature eyes that ensure you’ll walk away with newfound confidence in your eye makeup game!

Factors To Consider in Choosing Eyeshadow for Mature Women

Before you make your purchase, it’s important to ensure the product you choose highlights your best features, avoids highlighting fine lines and wrinkles, and fits your needs and preferences.

Here’s a brief guide to the factors you need to consider when picking an eyeshadow product:

Type

When you’re trying to select the top eyeshadow for older women, it’s essential to consider the type of eyeshadow itself.

There are three main types: cream, powder, and liquid eyeshadows.

For mature eyes, cream eyeshadow is often the most suitable option. They’re gentle on the delicate skin around the eyes, and they can provide long-lasting, crease-free results.

Most older women steer clear of powder eyeshadows because these tend to accentuate fine lines.

However, there are also plenty of powder products that don’t settle into wrinkles. Instead, they have a smooth, creamy texture that makes applying eyeshadow to mature hooded eyes effortless.

That means you can always opt for an easy-to-apply powder eyeshadow as long as it has a blendable formula.

Take note that you should avoid liquid eyeshadows altogether as they may be too difficult to apply on mature skin.

Color

Older women should choose eyeshadow colors that complement their skin tone and eye color.

For instance, shades of purple and mauve along with warm browns and golds can complement green eyes or deep skin. Those with hazel eyes or fair to medium skin may benefit from gold or copper.

As always, warm-toned eyeshadow colors will flatter skin with warm undertones, while cool-toned eyeshadows will look gorgeous on skin with cool undertones.

But older women can always go for neutral shades like browns, grays, and nudes as a safe choice for a sophisticated look and a subtle, natural-looking glow.

Finish

In general, matte eyeshadows are recognized as the top eyeshadows for older women as they are less likely to settle into creases and wrinkles and they create a smooth and even finish. They also help lift hooded eyes.

Another great option for older women is satin-finish eyeshadows. These have a slight sheen to them, which can help brighten the eyes.

On the other hand, it’s best to avoid highly metallic or glittery eyeshadows as they draw attention to creases and wrinkles.

Instead, go for eyeshadow colors with a slightly shimmery finish or layer matte and shimmery shadows together for a subtle sparkle.

Brand

The top eyeshadow brand for mature eyes should offer a range of shades specifically designed for older women, with formulations that cater to their unique skin concerns.

Although popular brands may be more expensive than lesser-known alternatives, investing in a high-quality eyeshadow will result in a smoother, long-lasting look that showcases your eyes in the best possible light.

13 Top Eyeshadows for Older Women

In this list, you’ll discover eyeshadows that are specifically tailored to enhance your mature skin and boost your self-confidence. So let’s dive in and find your new favorite eyeshadow!

One of the best things about this amazing eyeshadow palette from Urban Decay is its range of light and dark neutral colors, which bring out the beauty of your eyes.

And despite its powder form, it has a velvety texture that ensures it’s easy to blend and customize. The formula is also gentle on aging eyes, providing a long-lasting finish that lasts all day.

Older women will appreciate the understated appearance of this eyeshadow, making it suitable for everyday wear. So if you want a subtle, sophisticated look that flatters mature eyes, this palette is for you!

The Revlon Crème Eyeshadow Palette is designed for older women who want a safe and versatile makeup product.

You can create everyday makeup styles or more glamorous evening looks with this one. The formula has been tested by ophthalmologists, ensuring its suitability for sensitive eyes.

What makes this eyeshadow stand out is its highly pigmented and blendable formula. And aside from being easy to apply, it also offers a long-lasting and crease-free finish.

This flattering formula is also available in other flattering colors: Black Magic, Not Just Nudes, Precious Metals, and Wild Orchids.

With hydrolyzed collagen, silk, and peptides, the IT Cosmetics Naturally Pretty Essentials is specifically designed to provide anti-aging benefits for mature skin, making your eyes look brighter and your skin smoother.

Besides that, the matte finish and powder-based formula also ensure a smooth application without creasing, which is why we consider it the top eyeshadow for wrinkled eyelids.

It also comes with six beautiful shades in stunning, highly pigmented neutral colors. And it has one shade — the Hello Light shade — that transforms the matte shadows into satin for a velvety finish!

One user, a 59-year-old, expressed satisfaction with the sheerness of the palette, stating that it brightens the eyes without the need for intense pigmentation!

Featuring 12 stunning shades infused with beautiful rose gold pigments, this eyeshadow palette is enriched with colors that cater to different occasions and preferences.

Additionally, it works well with hooded eyes and wrinkled eyelids.

Its shades also come in matte and shimmer finishes, so you can choose to top your matte eyeshadow off with a little shimmer for a subtle shine.

Best of all, the double-ended sponge applicators make it convenient for application and touch-ups.

This formula is also available in two other shade combinations: The Nudes and 24k Nudes.

This eyeshadow palette offers a wide variety of blendable neutral shades ranging from light to dark, so it’s ideal for different skin tones and eye colors.

Each shade is designed to stand out, look vibrant, and last all day on mature skin, which is often more challenging to achieve due to the changes in skin texture and tone that aging causes.

Another great benefit is that this eyeshadow palette is made with clean ingredients. It’s free of harmful ingredients such as parabens, mineral oil, and silicones that can irritate mature skin.

The Laura Geller Blend Away Berry & Bright Eyeshadow Palette features a creamy, velvety smooth texture that makes it easy to blend and helps create a seamless finish.

It prevents the eyeshadow from settling into fine lines and wrinkles to avoid making the eyes look more aged.

Also, if you’re a mature woman with hazel eyes, this palette is perfect for you! The berry tones in the palette can complement the green and brown tones in hazel eyes, making them appear brighter.

The creamy formula of this eyeshadow stick glides smoothly over the eyelids without creasing or emphasizing the signs of aging. Instead, it creates a polished, revitalized appearance.

And with its long-lasting wear, you can be sure that your eye makeup will stay put throughout the day. Its stick applicator allows you to easily apply the eyeshadow precisely where you want it — no more mistakes or do-overs.

The 20 Heather Steel shade is an ideal choice for mature women as it defines the eyes and lifts hooded lids.

But those who want a bolder look can opt for 01 Vanila, 02 Violet Plum, 04 Golden Pink, 09 Golden Bronze, 23 Dusty Mauve, 38 Malted Pink, 42 Shore, and other wonderful shades.

The E.l.f. No Budge Matte Shadow Stick is not just any eyeshadow palette; it’s the top matte eyeshadow for older eyes!

Its finish is perfect for mature skin, helping minimize the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. The long-lasting formula won’t crease or fade either, so your eye makeup stays looking fresh all day.

Its twist-up design and smooth formula will allow you to apply it like a pro! It even comes with a sharpener that lets you sharpen the tip to ensure you a flawless look every time you use it.

For mature women who love vibrant colors, this shadow stick is also available in Lava Lamp, Stellar, Bombshell, Groovy, Out of Sight, and other shades.

The Clinique Touch Base for Eyes is great for mature skin because it stays in place all day long without smudging, fading, or creasing, so it doesn’t emphasize the fine lines around the eyes.

Another great feature of this eyeshadow is its versatile wearability. You can use it alone for a subtle touch of color or as a base to help secure other eyeshadows into place.

And with its mid-toned creamy yellow-nude shade, it’s perfect for creating a natural, understated look that women over 60 will love for daily wear.

Other subtle shades are also available: Canvas Light and Nude Rose.

According to plenty of user reviews, the L.A. COLORS 5 Color Matte Eyeshadow in Nude Suede is a hit with older women, and it’s easy to see why.

With its neutral hues and matte finish, this palette is perfect for everyday use and enhancing your eyes without overdoing it.

It allows you to achieve any look you want without accentuating wrinkles, making it the top eyeshadow for mature hooded eyes.

Top tip: Use the lighter shades in this palette to highlight the inner corners of your eyes and the darker shades to create depth and dimension on the outer corners. This will highlight your eyes’ best features!

Other shades are also available. You may opt for blues with Blue Denim, roses with Natural Linen, purples with Plum Pashmina, teals with Teal Argyle, or pink and browns with Tan Khaki.

Why should your age stop you from trying out new looks?

Whether you want to glam it up for a special occasion or mix up your everyday style, the CoverGirl TruNaked Eyeshadow Palette’s universally flattering shades can help you achieve a look that will turn heads.

What’s more, it enhances the natural beauty of aging skin with a formula that’s gentle and nourishing.

Its formula is infused with skin conditioners, making each shade easy to apply without causing irritation or dryness.

For those with different tastes in color, they may opt for Jewels, Queenship, Nudes, Desert Heat, Smoky, and Goldens, among others.

For a top-notch eyeshadow that won’t crease, smudge, or highlight wrinkles, look to the Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow in Au Naturel.

Its intense, buildable color allows you to create various looks that complement your eyes.

One of the top features of this eyeshadow stick is its long-lasting wear of up to 12 hours. This is beneficial for busy older women who don’t have time for constant touch-ups.

Plus, it glides smoothly across your eyelids, helping you reduce your makeup application time!

Other shades and finishes are available, such as Bed of Roses, Amethyst, Blossom, Cashmere, Ginger, Fog, Golden, Strapless, and more.

This eyeshadow stick makes your eyes pop with a beautiful taupe-pink hue without overpowering your look.

It’s also enriched with nourishing ingredients like vitamins C and E, which help hydrate and brighten the eye area. This benefits mature skin that’s often drier and more prone to wrinkles.

As one of the top eyeshadows for older women, it has a built-in smudger too, so it requires no brush for application.

Older women who find it difficult to apply eyeshadows with traditional brushes due to arthritis or other age-related issues will surely appreciate this.

This formula also comes in a wide range of shades, from greens to gold.

FAQs

How Do You Apply Eyeshadow as a Mature Woman?

Always start with a primer to create a smooth base for your eyeshadow.

Then apply the shadow to your lids and blend the colors gently, focusing on your crease and outer corners for a more lifted appearance.

What Type of Makeup Should Older Women Wear?

Beauty is timeless! So there are no hard-and-fast rules on what type of makeup we can wear based on our age.

Just wear what makes you feel confident and comfortable! Remember to choose creamy, hydrating products like cream eyeshadow or cream blush that won’t settle into wrinkles and fine lines.

Revamp Your Look With The Top Eyeshadows For Older Eyes

Eye makeup for older women need not be boring!

As you can see from our list above, the top eyeshadow sticks and palettes for women over 50, 60, 70, and beyond are beautiful and versatile, so you can easily find one that suits your needs.

From affordable to high-end options, from bright and bold to simple and elegant shades, these eyeshadow options will impress you and stun everyone around you!

So give our picks a try!

Remember, you deserve to feel beautiful and confident at any age. Don’t be afraid to get creative and play with different eyeshadows and techniques as this can help you discover your preferred style.

Find More Age-Defying Products Here!

• 10 Setting Powders for Mature Skin
• 10 Products for Crepey Skin + Tips To Reverse Signs of Aging
• 9 Korean Vitamin C Serums To Slow Down Skin Aging