Why choose between blonde and brunette?
By
Lindsey Metrus is the associate general manager at Byrdie and has been with the brand since 2015. Her work also appears in BuzzFeed, StyleCaster, and Yahoo.
Updated on 06/22/23 03:12PM
Reviewed by
Reviewed byJeremy Tardo
Jeremy Tardo is a bi-coastal hair colorist and a member of Byrdie's Beauty & Wellness Board.
Hair Colorist
Blonde or brunette? That tends to be the ongoing question we ask ourselves time and time again when seated at the salon. However, while it may seem like we have to pick one or the other, there is a color family that can give you the best of both worlds: caramel.
Caramel hair colors range from bronde and tortoiseshell to "money piece" highlights and varying shades of brown. Furthermore, caramel-colored hair often catches the light in ways that add natural dimension and brighten every complexion. In short, it's the perfect in-between and can be customized to flatter every skin tone and natural hair shade.
Meet the Expert
- Michael Canalé is a Hollywood-based colorist.
- George Papanikolas is a Los Angeles-based celebrity colorist and Matrix brand ambassador.
- Rita Hazan is a Manhattan-based celebrity colorist and salon owner.
To help inspire your next visit to your colorist, we've rounded up 40 of our favorite caramel hair colors, as seen on celebrities. From bronze balayage and ashy brown to pumpkin spice and caramel stripes, there's a look for everyone.
Caramel Hair Color
Choosing a Shade: "It's important, when trying to achieve that perfect caramel shade, to decide if you want to go lighter or richer," says celebrity colorist Rita Hazan."You can go one way or the other to achieve that perfect balance of lightness in the hair. "
Maintenance Level: Low to medium. Your maintenance level will depend on how far you stray from your natural shade and whether you opt for highlights or all-over color.
Goes Great With: Warm or neutral undertones, brown or hazel eyes, brunette hair
Similar Shades: Brown with blonde highlights, brown balayage, tortoiseshell, light brown
Price: Cost will vary depending on the techniques used
01of 40
Mocha Caramel
Camila Cabello's multidimensional brunette hair seamlessly blends in shades of chocolate for a warm effect.
02of 40
Strawberry Caramel
Take a cue from model Cara Delevingne and opt for a caramel shade that leans toward a pinkish-red shade. It's fresh, fun, and timeless.
03of 40
Reddish Caramel
For an even warmer take, follow Ashley Moore's lead. The red undertones make her caramel waves vivid and unforgettable.
04of 40
Caramel Bob
Short and sweet, Hailey Bieber's cool-toned caramel bob is the perfect year-round cut and color.
05of 40
Caramel Curls
Make your curls pop by adding caramel-hued highlights to your hair. The bright shade will bring more life to your face and brighten your complexion.
06of 40
Golden Caramel
Hailee Steinfeld's sunny caramel shade is perfect for the warm summer months. To make this shade pop even more, apply a glossing serum from mid-length to your tips.
07of 40
California Caramel
To replicate Jessica Alba's laid-back look, ask your colorist to weave in ashy blonde and brunette shades for a So-Cal vibe.
08of 40
Toasted Caramel
For a subtle caramel effect, take a note from EmRata. Her brunette remains as classic as ever, but there's a touch of warmth that brings more life to her rich, natural hair color.
09of 40
Multidimensional Caramel
J.Lo always gets it right, so it's no wonder that she absolutely nailed this ashy caramel hair color. It expertly weaves in highlighted tones to create a multidimensional effect perfect for Hollywood and beyond.
10of 40
Caramel Balayage
Halle Bailey's brunette locs showcase the perfect caramel balayage.
11of 40
Caramel Highlights
The subtle transition from dark brown to caramel color achieved via highlights is truly astonishing. "This is one of my most-requested looks in the salon," says hair colorist George Papanikolas. "The placement of the highlights is very strategic, focusing on the face frame, natural part, and ends. It's a great way for brunettes to add lightness and dimension to their hair, and it's universally flattering."
12of 40
Cool Caramel
These chestnut locks have a soft and subtle bronde balayage that's also highlighted lightly at the roots. "This is an ideal shade for clients who don't want to see any red or orange undertones," says Papanikolas. "It's very flattering on fair skin and olive tones. Keeping the highlights very delicate allows them to lighten past the warm tones."
13of 40
Light Golden Brown
While Queen Bey mainly sticks to light golden brown hues here (which pair well with her dark chestnut roots), you can still see where this darker caramel melds with lighter honey tones, creating a truly dynamic and rich color.
14of 40
Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin spice has infiltrated every aspect of our lives, including beauty. This look incorporates a blend of warm caramel, strawberry blonde, and honey blonde tones.
According to Papanikolas, pumpkin spice hair color is a great way for very dark hair to go lighter. To keep it from looking brassy, "you should be very strategic with a few highlights," he advises.
15of 40
Warm Honey
Ana de Armas positively glows with this light brown with honey accents created by Papanikolas. "These warm tones are a great complement to neutral and golden skin tones," he explains."If your hair tends to bleach out very late, you can ask for a warm golden gloss to give the hair a sheer finish."
16of 40
Caramel Coffee Balayage
Transitioning from a lighter dye job or looking to brighten up a darker 'do? Try creamy caramel ends and just a few subtle face-framing highlights for a look that's low-maintenance but high-impact.
17of 40
Butterscotch
Hazan describes Gigi Hadid's color as "a warm caramel shade, but not orangey." The overall look feels cooler but still finds warmth in tawny highlights throughout.
18of 40
Ash Ombré
Ciara looks stunning in this bold ash-caramel ombré. Her cascading waves start with a richer chestnut root, then transition through balayage to ash blonde on the ends.
19of 40
Sandy Blonde
If anyone knows sandy blonde color, it's the magical hands behind Jennifer Aniston's beige mane. This particular shade is great for someone who wantsa more ash hue instead of the warmer spectrum of caramel. Colorist Michael Canalé describes it as "medium blonde with a cool tone." This is a perfect example of balayage done expertly.
20of 40
Candied Caramel Curls
Apologies for the excessive alliteration, but we couldn't resist when it came to this bright, bouncy look. Janibell Rosanne's beautiful curls go from dark brunette to a sweet, candied caramel, with her ends painted a light honey blonde.
21of 40
Caramel Stripes
We love a subtle highlight, but there's something so chic about these alternating coffee and caramel streaks. The chunky highlights have us reminiscing about the early aughts.
22of 40
Honey Caramel
Caramel shading melts into honey-blonde tips on this gorgeous, full head of curls. Highlights, coupled with curly texture, lend dimension to this style.
23of 40
Gilded Dark Caramel
The lighter streaks in Sofia Vergara's luscious wavy hair give her darker caramel color a gilded, almost metallic touch. To get her glossy finish, invest in a shine spray.
24of 40
Caramel Swirl
Want an effortless look? This style keeps the crown of the head naturally dark, with warm, caramel blonde highlights through the mid-lengths. The addition of soft curls creates movement.
25of 40
Caramel Cream
Jillian Hervey's voluminous caramel curls resemble the mouth-watering shade of Werther's Original Hard Candy. Feel free to let your roots grow in with this low-maintenance look.
26of 40
Caramel Auburn
This dark interpretation of caramel gets a dose of mahogany thanks to auburn streaks that start around the crown of the head and fan out towards the ends. This is a popular color for fall but can be worn year-round.
27of 40
Sun-Kissed Brown
When Priyanka Chopra Jonas tried out caramel hair, she went for subtle highlights. They are the perfect inspiration if your natural color is on the darker side and you just want to brighten up a bit.
28of 40
Chunky Caramel Highlights
Balayage may still be all the rage these days, but there's also a place for chunky highlights. Case in point: Gina Rodriguez's asymmetrical bob. The thicker stripes brighten up her face while still creating a gradual ombré effect.
29of 40
Golden Caramel
Looking to change up your blonde hair color but don't want anything too dramatic? Then consider opting for this golden hue of blonde caramel that practically gleams in the light—enough said.
30of 40
Rich Brunette Melt
Naomie Harris's soft ombré transitions from deep mahogany brown to a lighter—but still rich—caramel shade without any harsh blonde highlights. Not only does it look natural, but it also enhances her natural color.
31of 40
Bright Caramel Coils
Reddish caramel highlights mix with a deep chocolate base for the ultimate candied color combination. Just keep in mind that red hues tend to fade quickly, so be sure to follow a hair care regimen that will keep your color bright.
32of 40
Salted Caramel
Schitt's Creek star Annie Murphy gives us a breezy take on caramel with a salted ombré that gives her hair a light, bouncy appearance. This color was meant for her loose waves.
33of 40
Caramel Babylights
Olivia Munn's delicate caramel-colored babylights give her hair just the right amount of dimension to highlight her face and skin tone. If you have thin hair, these highlights are a perfect way to make your hair reflect the light in a way that gives the illusion of thicker hair.
34of 40
Caramel Blonde Balayage
Gisele Bündchen's hair always looks effortless, shiny, and healthy. Her caramel blonde balayage is undoubtedly one of the most requested looks for beachy hair. It also grows out well and requires little maintenance—just saying.
35of 40
Bronze Caramel Highlights
Eva Mendes has found the perfect shade to flatter her skin tone: bronze caramel highlights. They frame her face perfectly while adding dimension to her hair. This would be a great choice for those with dark hair who want to keep their highlights on the warmer—versus the blonde—spectrum.
36of 40
Caramel Ginger
Chrissy Teigen's hair color leans more toward the red spectrum while still keeping with the warmth that defines caramel color. "Caramel is always a warm shade, so either way you go, it has to have that perfect balance of warmth," explains Hazan.
37of 40
Caramel Copper Highlights
The slightly copper hue of Nicole Ari Parker's caramel highlights works beautifully with her casual loose waves and the neutral undertones of her complexion.
38of 40
Grown-Out Caramel
Follow Lucy Hale's lead and skip your next root touch-up appointment. Her grown-out caramel color is visually effortless.
39of 40
Light Brown Caramel
Kaia Gerber's long hair provides the perfect canvas to show off her gradient color. Light brown roots seamlessly blend into caramel mids and ends—and we can't get enough.
40of 40
Mussy Caramel
Academy Award-winning actress Michelle Yeoh is always glamorous, even with her grown-out caramel color and subtle cool-girl side flip. To get her mussy finish, apply a texturizing spray.
FAQ
What skin tone looks best with caramel highlights?
In general, caramel highlights tend to complement neutral or warm skin tones that have a bit of olive or yellow. Those with cool skin tones should consider an ash blonde or champagne blonde. One quick way to determine your skin tone is to look at your eyes. Those with warm skin tones often have darker eyes or gold flecks in their eyes, while cool skin tones often have blue or green eyes.
Do you have to bleach your hair to get caramel highlights?
Depending on your natural hair color and what shade of caramel highlights you desire, you may need to bleach the hair you are wanting to highlight before the color is applied. If your hair is lighter and you want darker caramel lowlights, no bleaching is required. If bleaching is required, you should go to a professional stylist for best results.
Should I get balayage caramel highlights or foil caramel highlights?
It depends on what kind of look you're going for. Balayage is strategically hand-painted throughout your hair and will achieve subtle, natural-looking results. Meanwhile, foil highlights will give you a more uniform look and will start closer to the scalp.
LEARN MORE:Should You Get Balayage or Foil Highlights?