5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (2024)

Anyone who loves to thrift shop will tell you that Goodwill is the place to find unique clothing, accessories, and home goods at affordable prices. But did you know that you can also find rare and even highly valuable items when thrift shopping? It’s true!

Because Ohio Valley Goodwill receives so many donated items, you never know what hidden treasures you might come across in one of our retail stores from one day to the next!

The key is to shop frequently and know what to look for. If you see these items while thrift shopping at Goodwill, don’t pass them up!

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (1)

Books from Ohio Valley Goodwill

First Edition Books

When they’re brand new, hardcover books are usually priced higher than paperback books. If you find used hardcover books in good condition at a thrift store, it can be a great deal! Keep your eyes peeled for autographed copies of books from popular authors, which make wonderful gifts for book lovers. As you browse through classic books at a thrift store like Goodwill, check the edition number on the first few pages. If you see the words ” first edition” or ” first printing,” you could be holding a rare and valuable book! With a little online research, you can find out the value of the book.

Vintage and Retro Kitchenware

Goodwill always has a great selection of dishes, glassware, and other kitchen supplies. Be on the lookout for these rare and potentially valuable items in the glassware section:

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (2)

Glass Jars from Goodwill

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (3)

Porcelain teacup with white and pink flowers

  • Jadeite “” Mint green dishes, cups, and serving trays were popular after World War II and now carry a lot of value.
  • Pyrex “” These colorful, patterned mixing bowls, storage containers, and oven-safe dishes were all the rage in the 1950s through the 1980s. Look for collectible patterns and styles while thrifting!
  • China sets “” Teacups, saucers, and other china pieces are highly collectible, especially if you come across a vintage pattern. Even if you don’t find a complete set, it’s fun to mix-and-match china pieces to create your own collection.
  • Vintage canning jars “” The blue-tinted versions are sought after by collectors, but even the plain clear glass jars are always a functional way to decorate your home!
  • Retro cookie jars “” Cookie jars representing cartoons and other whimsical characters are fun and nostalgic collectibles. Not to mention, they’re a great place to store sweet treats!

Luggage and Trunks

A gently-used luggage set can be used for your own travel, but you can also get creative and repurpose luggage into stylish home décor! Look for vintage-style suitcases and trunks that you can cover with a new coat of paint or decoupage with fabric. Stack your collection of suitcases in a corner, use them as shelves, or turn them into easy storage for family photos, holiday decorations, craft supplies, and more.

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (4)

Basket from Goodwill

Designer-Label Clothes

Designer clothes aren’t necessarily rare at thrift stores “” you can usually find many well-known and popular brands at your local Goodwill store! But if you’re searching for vintage pieces, pay close attention to the labels. If you don’t recognize a brand name on the label, it could very well be vintage! Many times, vintage fashion will have a ” union tag,” which has the acronym ” ILGWU.” Clothing produced before the 1980s may also have labels with an American flag or ” Made in U.S.A.” Because vintage sizing is very different from today’s sizes, it’s important to keep an open mind and try to search through every section!

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (5)

Clothing racks at Mason Goodwill Store

Old-School Electronics

Retro stereos, walkmans, DVD and VHS players, video game consoles, cameras, and other old-school electronic accessories are always fun to find at thrift stores like Goodwill. Many people like to collect these gadgets to remind them of years past, whether the devices are in working condition or not. Turntables and vinyl records are also making a huge comeback, and you can often find great deals at a thrift store!

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (6)

Donated records at Goodwill

Ohio Valley Goodwill is a treasure trove for all sorts of clothing, accessories, and household goods, all at affordable prices. You can even shop Goodwill online from the comfort of home by visiting shopgoodwill.com.

But the best part of shopping at Goodwill isn’t our unique selection and amazing prices “” it’s the fact that YOU help us power our cycle of success!

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (7)

Goodwill’s Cycle of Success

The money raised by our retail stores helps to fund life-changing programs and services for individuals with disabilities right here in Cincinnati, helping them gain valuable job skills so they can obtain meaningful employment. By donating to and shopping at Goodwill, you’re helping us reinvest in the local community and make it a better, more inclusive place to live, work, and play!

Shop at Goodwill and be a job creator! Find an Ohio Valley Goodwill location near you and plan your next shopping trip today.

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill (2024)

FAQs

5 Rare Things to Look for When Thrift Shopping - Cincinnati Goodwill? ›

Check for Designer Labels or Tags

Valuable vintage items, like clothing, kitchenware or records, often come with a label indicating that it's valuable. With dishes, for instance, check the bottom for a brand name.

How do you find rare and valuable items at thrift stores? ›

Check for Designer Labels or Tags

Valuable vintage items, like clothing, kitchenware or records, often come with a label indicating that it's valuable. With dishes, for instance, check the bottom for a brand name.

What is the most valuable thing to look for in a thrift store? ›

Antony Charman, antique expert and founder of Vintage Cash Cow says, “There are specific types of items that will always be valuable, including rare coins, antique furniture, vintage toys and jewelry.

What is the best day to go thrifting at Goodwill? ›

While there's no “perfect” day to shop second hand stores, many regulars swear by shopping early on Monday and Tuesday. Homeowners tend to drop off garage sale leftovers on Sunday nights, making for new finds. Plus, the weekends are more crowded shopping days, so employees look to restock early in the week.

How to find valuable art at thrift stores? ›

Look for signatures on pieces, which can mean a work of art is either original or part of a limited series. A signature can also give you a sense of a piece's potential worth or provide you a breadcrumb for finding out more information about the artist.

What is the most valuable item to collect? ›

What Are the Most Valuable Types of Collectibles?
  1. Vintage Comic Books. Comic books are one of the most popular collectibles because of how much they can appreciate in value over time. ...
  2. Baseball Cards. ...
  3. Vintage Bakeware. ...
  4. Rare Coins. ...
  5. Vintage Toys. ...
  6. Stamps. ...
  7. Vintage Magazines. ...
  8. Antique Furniture.
Aug 21, 2023

How do you know if an item is rare? ›

Rarity. Rarity is arguably one of the most important factors in determining value. An item is rare if there are only a few available in circulation and it's even better if your object is entirely unique – say a Hummel figurine of which only 2000 were made, or the very last bottle of wine from a particular vintage.

Do thrift stores wash clothes before? ›

Most secondhand stores don't wash the clothes before selling them. Donations are typically washed before they're donated, but we still recommend giving them a good cleaning when you get home. Even if the clothes are washed before they hit the thrift store floor, people will have since touched them.

Does Goodwill wash clothes before reselling? ›

Does Goodwill clean items before placing them on the sales floor? The majority of our merchandise is secondhand. While our employees do not wash clothing items, we do wipe down household items before placing them on the sales floor. Goodwill complies with all laws in regard to the resale of secondhand items.

What time is best for Goodwill bins? ›

Tip Two: Go at the Right Time

Another reason thrifting may seem difficult to you is because you aren't going at the right time. Goodwill replaces their items in the morning, and some stores replace their items just before closing as well. The safest choice is to go in the morning, right when the store opens.

How do I find out if a picture is worth anything? ›

Consider finding an appraiser to determine the value of your artwork. Appraisers are trained specialists who work for a fee. They evaluate your piece and give you a written statement of its value.

How do you tell if you have a valuable painting? ›

Paintings that are well-preserved, with minimal damage or restoration work, tend to be more valuable than those with significant flaws or deterioration. The overall aesthetic appeal and quality of execution also contribute to its desirability and subsequent value.

How can I collect cheap art? ›

Start Small

Look out for recent graduates or artists just gaining recognition. If you're on a tight budget, you could start your collection by buying a small original painting from an emerging artist. Buying from emerging artists means you'll probably be one of their first collectors.

How do you find out if an item is worth anything? ›

Take the item to an antique store.

Appraisers should still be certified by a national appraisal board. They often offer insurance replacement valuations or fair-market valuations, but they also offer less-expensive services such as verbal-approximations. Prices for services vary based on location.

How do I find collectable items? ›

How To Find Rare Collectibles
  1. Search eBay regularly. ...
  2. Check out estate sales and garage sales. ...
  3. Make an offer to past buyers. ...
  4. Proactively search.

What items sell best in a thrift store? ›

Vintage clothing, designer pieces, collectibles such as toys or mugs often have high resale potential.

How can you tell if something is vintage at a thrift store? ›

But I do have some tried and true tips for helping you figure out if something is truly vintage, or merely vintage inspired.
  1. Look at the logo on the tag. ...
  2. Flip the label over to see where the garment was made. ...
  3. Check the fabric composition tag. ...
  4. Look for unique construction details and/or handmade sew jobs.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated:

Views: 5615

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.