A Hard-Hitting Investigative Report Into Amazon Shows That Workers’ Needs Were Neglected In Favor Of Getting Goods Delivered Quickly (2024)

When you are running a far-flung global enterprise, employing over one million people, it's understandable that issues will arise. When you start to see a continual pattern, it's time to consider if the mistakes are purposely overlooked or if there is something else happening. A New York Times investigative report delved into allegations that Amazon has been systematically shortchanging workers on their paychecks.

Sometimes, you only need one small voice to evoke change. Tara Jones is a mom with a baby. The Oklahoma Amazon warehouse worker wrote a heartfelt note to Jeff Bezos, the CEO of Amazon at the time, stating that she was being underpaid. Her check was $90 short of what she was supposed to receive for her month’s work. She wrote to the world's richest man, "I'm behind on bills, all because the pay team messed up." Jones emotionally pleaded, "I'm crying as I write this email."

In the investigative piece, inspired in part by Jones, the New York Times alleged, “For at least a year and a half—including during periods of record profit—Amazon had been shortchanging new parents, patients dealing with medical crises and other vulnerable workers on leave, according to a confidential report on the findings.”

The inquiry suggests, “Some of the pay calculations at her facility had been wrong since it opened its doors over a year before. As many as 179 of the company’s other warehouses had potentially been affected, too.”

There were heartbreaking stories of stopped disability payments, cars repossessed, the need to sell a wedding ring and mistaken firings due to the supposedly faulty programs. The investigative findings indicated that workers at facilities across the country had to contend with questionable payroll software that led to people with “medical problems and other life crises having been fired when the attendance software mistakenly marked them as no-shows.” It was reported, “Doctors’ notes vanished into black holes in Amazon’s databases. Employees struggled to even reach their case managers, wading through automated phone trees [that gave them the runaround].”

This isn’t the first time workers complained about how Amazon has mistreated them. A prior New York Times investigative piece reported on the difficult working conditions Amazon employees had to endure at a fulfillment warehouse in Staten Island, New York, during the Covid-19 pandemic.

The piece contended that Bezos “discovered what he thought was another inefficiency worth eliminating: hourly employees who spent years working for the same company.” Sources claim that Bezos held a theory that workers expect raises, but at the same time, they become complacent over time, and don’t work as hard. Consequently, wages increase, while productivity declines.

The solution was to replace workers before their productivity further deteriorated and pay increased. It's more efficient to hire fresh, new people. Amazon then basically encouraged workers to leave. The constant churning of workers helped keep efficiency high and wages fairly low. The prevailing wisdom was, “After three years on the job, hourly workers no longer received automatic raises, and the company offered bonuses to people who quit. It also offered limited upward mobility for hourly workers, preferring to hire managers from the outside.”

“Turnover at Amazon is much higher than at many other companies—with an annual rate of roughly 150% for warehouse workers,” according to the New York Times. There have been many complaints from employees at Amazon’s fulfillment centers. Workers alleged that they are given back-breaking tasks in the warehouses. They also vent their dismay over intrusive surveillance technologies, including automated tracking systems and cameras that monitor their every move. There is a palpable fear that if workers don’t meet specified quotas, they’ll be fired. This has led to workers calling for a union. A union drive in Alabama was attempted, but was thwarted and didn’t succeed.

In an effort to help the mental health and well-being of warehouse and fulfillment centers, the retailer launched “WorkingWell,” a comprehensive program providing employees with wellness exercises. The program was part of an initiative by the giant online-shopping empire to invest over $300 million into safety projects in 2021 for its workers.

Part of the wellness program includes AmaZen. It “guides employees through mindfulness practices” inside of interactive kiosks stationed at the worksites. Employees are encouraged to “visit AmaZen stations and watch short videos featuring easy-to-follow well-being activities, including guided meditations, positive affirmations, calming scenes with sounds and more.”

The rollout didn’t get the glowing reviews the company had hoped for. The online vitriol was brutal. It felt that the program brought out all of the pent-up anger simmering against the online behemoth.

This includes its treatment of employees and resentment of outgoing CEO, Bezos, who profited handsomely during the pandemic, reaping billions more to his already-staggering net worth, while millions of workers across the country suffered layoffs and a rapid decline in their financial and living standards.

Vice savagely reported, “In one of its most dystopian moves yet, Amazon is introducing tiny booths where its overworked warehouse employees can momentarily escape a job so grueling, many employees say they don't feel like they have enough time to even use the bathroom.” The piece pointed out, “What this looks like in reality is a coffin-sized booth in the middle of an Amazon warehouse where workers can use a computer to view ‘mental health and mindful practices.’"

An Amazon human resources professional, tasked with fixing the company's leave system, Bethany Reyes, told the New York Times that the online retailing giant was trying to rebalance its mantra of "optimizing" for the customer. Plain speaking, this translates into: with the focus on getting products to customers as quickly as possible, we may have neglected to pay attention to the needs of our own workers.

Kelly Nantel, an Amazon spokesperson, said, We’re disappointed when any of our employees experience an issue with their leave.” Nantel continued, “TheNew York Timesarticle suggests these issues are widespread and ongoing. They are not. In fact, the controls we’ve implemented over the last 18 months have resulted in less than 1 percent of people experiencing an issue while being on paid leave. Certainly the unprecedented nature of [Covid-19] did put a strain on our system’s ability to keep pace with demand, and we’ve been hard at work investing and inventing to do better every day.”

A Hard-Hitting Investigative Report Into Amazon Shows That Workers’ Needs Were Neglected In Favor Of Getting Goods Delivered Quickly (2024)

FAQs

What is the most common injury at Amazon? ›

Takakura's injury is the most common kind of workplace injury at Amazon warehouses. Called a musculoskeletal disorder, it encompasses many kinds of muscle and joint damage caused by repetitive motion and overuse. Tendonitis, back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, and hernias are all types of musculoskeletal disorders.

How do Amazon treat their workers? ›

The average Amazon warehouse worker leaves within just eight months – that's an unmistakable sign that Amazon's jobs are unpleasant, to put it kindly, and that many Amazon workers quickly realize they hate working there because of the stress, breakneck pace, constant monitoring and minimal rest breaks.

What are Amazon workers protesting? ›

Why are Amazon workers protesting? The campaign charges Amazon with “squeezing every last drop it can” from “workers, communities and the planet” in the face of the cost of living crisis. Workers across the world will participate in the protest action.

Why is Amazon problematic? ›

Amazon.com has drawn criticism from multiple sources, where the ethics of certain business practices and policies have been drawn into question. Amazon has faced numerous allegations of anti-competitive or monopolistic behavior, as well as criticisms of their treatment of workers and consumers.

What is the #1 cause of employee injury? ›

Liberty Mutual found that overexertion is the leading cause of workplace injuries, followed by injuries related to falling. Knowing the most common workplace injuries and how to prevent them can have a significant impact on the safety of your employees and the longevity of your business.

Does Amazon pay you for injury? ›

When Amazon workers are injured on the job, they are entitled to workers' compensation that can help with their medical expenses and lost income.

Why do so many Amazon workers quit? ›

Engadget reports that mobility concerns are the primary reason for managers quitting Amazon warehouses and the second-highest reason for other staff members who work the floor.

What unethical things has Amazon done? ›

Here are some of the key issues with the company and their practices:
  • Worker Exploitation. Amazon has been accused of exploiting their global, 650,000-strong workforce in many ways. ...
  • Tax Avoidance. Amazon use various loopholes to pay the lowest amount of tax possible. ...
  • Market Dominance. ...
  • Privacy Concerns.
Jan 4, 2022

Why does Amazon pay employees to quit? ›

Amazon instituted the program—known inside the company as Pay to Quit or simply The Offer—in 2014 to help the company quickly trim the size of its workforce, which expands significantly during the holiday season to keep up with a flood of online shopping.

How many employees is Amazon firing? ›

24, 2021. Amazon on Wednesday will begin a fresh round of job cuts in what's expected to become the largest workforce cuts in its 28-year history. Earlier this month, CEO Andy Jassy said the layoffs would affect more than 18,000 employees, primarily in its human resources and stores divisions.

Is Amazon running out of workers? ›

A leaked Amazon memo obtained by Recode says the company 'will deplete the available labor supply' for US warehouse workers by 2024 unless it makes changes to how it does business.

Are Amazon workers treated unfairly? ›

There have been many complaints from employees at Amazon's fulfillment centers. Workers alleged that they are given back-breaking tasks in the warehouses. They also vent their dismay over intrusive surveillance technologies, including automated tracking systems and cameras that monitor their every move.

What are some major issues in Amazon? ›

Here is a guide on the most common challenges merchants on the Amazon platform face and what they need to bring their fulfillment process in-house.
  • Compromised Cash Flow. ...
  • High Degree of Competition. ...
  • Packaging Restrictions. ...
  • Strict Inventory Expectations. ...
  • High Amazon Fees. ...
  • Way Forward.

What are some negative effects of Amazon? ›

Negative impact:
  • Low quality: With the increasing competition among sellers customers sometimes get inferior quality products.
  • Losing touch with traditional markets: With e-commerce websites, customers are losing touch with traditional markets with history and culture.

What are some problems with Amazon? ›

The 7 Amazon Problems No One is Talking About
  • Amazon Prime is not cheap. ...
  • Amazon doesn't always offer the best deal. ...
  • You can't personally inspect Amazon produce. ...
  • It's hard to identify counterfeit products. ...
  • Reviews are sometimes misleading. ...
  • It's not always the most convenient choice. ...
  • Online returns may be a hassle.
Nov 9, 2022

What is the most common cause of workers compensation? ›

Here are some of the most common injuries, based on EMPLOYERS® claim data:
  • Lacerations. Deep cuts or tears in skin or flesh. ...
  • Sprains and strains. Sprains are stretched or torn ligaments, while strains are stretched or torn muscles and tendons. ...
  • Contusions. ...
  • Burns. ...
  • Eye Injuries. ...
  • Fractures. ...
  • Cumulative or Continuous Trauma.

What are the 3 types of injury? ›

Did you know that most athletic injuries can be boiled down into three main categories? Acute, Overuse, and Chronic.

What is the most common workplace incident? ›

Slips and trips

The most commonly occurring non-fatal accident in every workplace is through a slip, trip or fall as it can occur anywhere at any time.

Will Amazon give compensation? ›

The compensation will differ depending on your status as a Prime member. For those who do not pay for an Amazon Prime membership, their compensation will come in the form of returned shipping fees to the original form of payment.

What percentage does Amazon pay for disability? ›

This plan provides a benefit during eligible periods of disability. The benefit is 60% of your monthly salary1 or a maximum of $1,200 per week. Your premium will be $0.254 per $10 weekly benefit. If you are receiving a short-term disability benefit, you will not have to pay the premium after 90 days.

Can you claim compensation from Amazon? ›

You can submit a claim up to 90 days after the order date. For purchases using Amazon Pay on a third party website, you must wait 15 days from the charge date to submit a claim.

Why do people leave Amazon so quickly? ›

One frequently cited reason for the high rate of departures is Amazon's unusual compensation structure. Unlike other tech companies, Amazon caps salaries at around $160,000 for its white-collar workers, then adds stock grants that gradually vest in steadily increasing chunks over a period of four years.

How long do most employees stay at Amazon? ›

The average tenure of a full-time Amazonian is roughly one year, while tenure at other tech places like Facebook, Apple, and Google tends to be roughly about two years.

Why is Amazon turnover rate so high? ›

An Amazon worker in Campbellsville, Kentucky, who is trying to organize a union at the warehouse, said “Amazon's hiring practices, productivity quotas, attendance policies, and unequal enforcement of rules are contributors to the lack of job security that drives Amazon's high turnover.”

What has Amazon been accused of? ›

Amazon has been accused by federal safety regulators of failing to keep warehouse workers safe from workplace hazards at three US facilities, in the latest example of government officials scrutinizing the e-commerce giant's labor practices.

What is Amazon's recent controversy? ›

Amazon India and Exotic India art quietly withdraw obscene paintings of Shri Krishna & Radha Ji. But this is not enough. Both Amazon & Exotic India must tender unconditional apology & pledge not to hurt the sentiments of Hindus ever again" tweeted Hindu Janajagruti Samiti.

What are Amazon ethical practices? ›

Amazon.com provides a clean, safe and healthy work environment. Each employee has responsibility for maintaining a safe and healthy workplace by following safety and health rules and practices and reporting accidents, injuries and unsafe conditions, procedures, or behaviors.

Do terminated Amazon employees receive severance packages? ›

In exchange for leaving the company, Amazon will provide employees with a "lump-sum" severance payment equal to three months of pay, plus one week of salary for every six months of tenure at the company, the documents said.

What happens to my PTO if I quit Amazon? ›

Vacation pay accrues (adds up) as it is earned, and cannot be forfeited, even upon termination of employment, regardless of the reason for the termination.

How much is Amazon severance package? ›

Those who took it up were offered a lump sum severance equivalent to 22 weeks base pay, one week base salary for every six months of services up to a maximum of 20 weeks, medical insurance for six months and notice period or pay in lieu of it.

What positions are Amazon laying off? ›

Amazon layoffs hit workers in robotics, grocery, health and AWS divisions. Amazon earlier this month began a fresh round of job cuts as part of widespread layoffs that are expected to total 18,000.

Is Amazon laying off workers 2022? ›

Things keep getting worse for people working in big tech. In November 2022, the news broke that Amazon intended to lay off 10,000 of its employees, the latest in a series of layoffs in the big tech space — but today, the news got even worse.

How many write ups before fired at Amazon? ›

How many final written warnings can you get at Amazon? Associates get verbal or written warnings for things such as low stowing rates, poor stowing quality and safety violations. Six writeups in a year results in automatic termination.

Is Amazon a stressful place to work? ›

High stress

Other critics say Amazon sets unreasonably high production quotas for its warehouse workers, creating constant stress. Amazon keeps track of how long it takes pickers to pull items from shelves and put them on a bin. Workers who fail to meet the rates set by the company to pull items risk losing their jobs.

Does Amazon underpay their workers? ›

A subsequent investigation found that Amazon was systematically underpaying some workers on leave. A spokesperson told The Times that Amazon was still identifying underpaid workers.

Are Amazon employees happy with their jobs? ›

Related, 91% of those surveyed feel encouraged to share their ideas, 74% feel confident that they can meet their career goals working at Amazon, and 91% report their manager creates an environment where they feel comfortable expressing their concerns.

What are Amazon's biggest weaknesses? ›

Weaknesses
  • Business model that can be imitated.
  • Seasonality of the business.
  • Weak competitive position of Amazon's Fire Phone.
  • Damage to the brand image due to tax avoidance controversies in USA, UK and Japan.
  • Working conditions for warehouse workers.
Mar 23, 2022

Why are people boycotting Amazon? ›

Amazon has been accused of illegally firing workers in Chicago, New York and Ohio, calling the police on workers in Kentucky and New York, and retaliating against workers in New York and Pennsylvania.

How does Amazon affect people's lives? ›

Amazon has created more jobs in the past decade than any U.S. company, and we have invested more than $530 billion in the U.S. over the last decade. Beyond our own workforce, Amazon's investments have supported nearly 1.6 million indirect jobs in fields like construction and hospitality.

What is Amazon negative feedback? ›

One and two-star ratings are considered negative feedback. Amazon states that having an ODR above 1% could result in losing your seller privileges, meaning that sellers who have more than 1% of orders with 1 or 2-star ratings could have their seller privileges removed. Neutral feedback on Amazon also hurts.

What are positives and negatives of working for Amazon? ›

Pros and Cons of Working for Amazon – Summary Table
Pros of Working for AmazonCons of Working for Amazon
1. Great Pay1. Big Box Mentality
2. Advancement Opportunities2. High Turnover
3. Premium Benefits3. Heavy Lifting is Commonplace
4. Lots of Locations4. Work is Repetitive
6 more rows
May 11, 2022

What are the common inventory issues faced by Amazon sellers? ›

Common inventory issues Amazon sellers face
  • Running out of inventory.
  • Overstocking inventory.
  • Stranded inventory.
  • Aged Inventory Surcharge (previously known as long term storage fees)
  • Keep a close relationship with your supplier.
  • Maintain around 60 days of supply.
  • Reduce excess inventory.
  • Plan for the unexpected.
Oct 18, 2022

What is the most common warehouse injury? ›

Crush injuries and machinery accidents

In a warehouse, the most common crush injuries result from operating forklift, pallet trucks and packaging machinery. Accidents caused by operating machinery in the warehouse can be severe, especially if workers become trapped in or underneath machinery.

What are the 2 most common injuries on the job? ›

Top 5 most common workplace injuries and how to avoid them.
  1. Trips, Slips And Falls. ...
  2. Being Struck By Or Caught In Moving Machinery. ...
  3. Vehicle Related Accidents. ...
  4. Fire And Explosions. ...
  5. Repetitive Stress and Overexertion Injuries.

What is the #1 workplace injury? ›

The three leading causes of work-related injuries treated in an emergency department were contact with objects and equipment, overexertion and bodily reaction, and falls, slips and trips without a fall.

Which is the leading cause of injury in the warehouse? ›

The most common warehouse injuries are caused by falls, slips, trips, falling objects, forklift collisions and exposure to harmful substances. These result to physical injuries ranging from mild to severe (and sometimes death). That's why companies and managers take extra steps in ensuring workplace safety.

What are the 3 most common workplace accidents? ›

Common Workplace Injuries & How to Prevent Them
  • Slips and Falls. Slips and falls are a large liability to a company. ...
  • Strains. One of the most common workplace injuries is employees straining their back or neck. ...
  • Repetitive Use Injuries. ...
  • Cuts. ...
  • Collisions and Crashes.

What are the 3 most common injuries? ›

The most common sports injuries are: Sprains and strains. Knee injuries. Swollen muscles.

What is the most common injury claim on workmans comp? ›

Here are some of the most common injuries, based on EMPLOYERS® claim data:
  • Lacerations. Deep cuts or tears in skin or flesh. ...
  • Sprains and strains. Sprains are stretched or torn ligaments, while strains are stretched or torn muscles and tendons. ...
  • Contusions. ...
  • Burns. ...
  • Eye Injuries. ...
  • Fractures. ...
  • Cumulative or Continuous Trauma.

What are the two 2 main causes of incidents in the workplace? ›

There are three basic causes of workplace accidents: chance occurrences, unsafe conditions, and employees' unsafe acts.

What are the 4 types of incident reports? ›

Common Types of Incident Reports
  • Workplace. Workplace incident reports detail physical events that happen at work and affect an employee's productivity. ...
  • Accident or First Aid. ...
  • Safety and Security. ...
  • Exposure Incident Report.
Oct 12, 2022

What are the 4 types of accidents? ›

The Top Five Classifications of Accidents
  • Accidents at Work. You may be at risk of serious personal injury depending on the type of job you have. ...
  • Car Accidents. This is perhaps the most common of the five classifications of accidents. ...
  • Medical Negligence Accidents. ...
  • Slip (Trip) and Fall Accidents. ...
  • Motorcycle Accidents.

How much do I get paid for injury on duty? ›

If you have a 100% disability you will get paid 75% (three-quarters) of your wages. If the disability is less serious, the Commissioner will work out the monthly payment. The monthly payment will be paid for the rest of your life. If the disability is less than a 30% disability, you'll get paid a lump sum.

What is a Class 1 injury? ›

Patient in class 1 is severely injured with serious neurological, respiratory and/or hemodynamic distress.

Which of these is most likely to cause an accident in a workspace? ›

As suspected, manual handling was one of the biggest cause of workplace injuries with over 120,000 people having reported an injury from carrying, lifting or handling items at work.

What is the most common cause of serious injury in the workplace? ›

Slips, trips, or falls on the same level

Accounting for one-third of all non-fatal injuries in the workplace, slips, trips and falls are by far the most recurring type of accidents.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5559

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.