Are Fresh Mozzarella and Regular Mozzarella the Same? (2024)

2 Shares

They’re both Mozzarella, so are Fresh Mozzarella and regular Mozzarella the same thing? Is regular mozzarella somehow less fresh?

Are Fresh Mozzarella and Regular Mozzarella the Same? (1)

The Short Answer:

Fresh Mozzarella and Regular Mozzarella are the same cheese but prepared differently.

The Long Answer:

As an Italian American, I love me some Mozzarella, but I’ve always been fascinated by the texture and taste of what is known as“fresh mozzarella.” As a child, once I learned that this was a thing, I started to think of regular mozzarella as dirty or somehow rotten since it wasn’t “fresh.”

I was both right and wrongin this regard.

Fresh mozzarella is a pillowy and moist white cheese that usually comes in the form of a ball. Fresh mozzarella is usually packed in water or hand wrapped in plastic wrap. It has a veryhigh moisture content and as suchcomes with a relatively short shelf life. Typically, it’s a good idea to eat fresh mozzarella within a week of its creation. Unlike the more common form of this cheese, it’s not as easily melted, and often turns into a soupy puddle when heated. This won’t do well in poutine or on nachos, but it goes great on Neapolitan pizza.

While this product was originally made from buffalo’s milk in Italy, it has since transitioned into being made from the far more common cow’s milk. However, there are many old Italians who still insist that all fresh mozzarella comes from buffalos.

What we’re calling “regular’ mozzarella is actually just a low moisture version of this cheese. It is made from souring fresh mozzarella for a longer period oftime and drying it out. It is because of its lower moisture count that fresh mozzarella tastes saltier than its fresh counterpart. It also has a longer shelf life, which is what makes it more appealing for mass production and consumption. This is the kind ofmozzarella found in mozzarella sticks and on pizza. The low moisture within the cheese makes it more susceptible to browning and stretching when heated.

Do you prefer fresh mozzarella or regular mozzarella? Is it a part of your keto diet? What is your favorite cheesy recipe? Sound off in the comment section below and let us know!

2 Shares

Are Fresh Mozzarella and Regular Mozzarella the Same? (2024)

FAQs

Can you substitute fresh mozzarella for regular mozzarella? ›

Spoiler alert: it doesn't matter if you choose fresh mozzarella or low-moisture mozzarella – both are tasty and a great addition to your recipes. We would top almost anything with grated low-moisture mozzarella.

Does fresh mozzarella melt the same as regular mozzarella? ›

Factory-made processed mozzarella is lower in moisture, has a longer shelf life, and is easily sliced, cubed, or grated. It is most often used in cooked dishes because it really does melt better than fresh mozzarella.

What is the difference between fresh mozzarella and pizza mozzarella? ›

The main difference between mozzarella cheese and pizza cheese is that pizza cheese uses low moisture content and has more shelf life compared to the other. It's also a blend of more than one cheese, more popularly mozzarella and provolone.

Does fresh mozzarella taste different? ›

Fresh mozzarella, handmade in smaller batches from whole milk, has a much softer, buttery texture and a delicate flavor.

What can I substitute for fresh mozzarella? ›

Feta cheese, Cotija cheese, paneer cheese, and halloumi cheese are all good substitutes for mozzarella that will not melt. Feta cheese can be eaten fresh, like mozzarella, and doesn't require any cooking to bring out the salty and tangy flavor of the cheese.

Is fresh mozzarella good for baking? ›

Use fresh mozzarella that is vacuum packed not water packed. If it is packed in water the final dish will be more watery. As the mozzarella cools, it will start to harden so try to use a dish that will keep the heat. Or simply pop back in the oven for a few minutes so that the cheese can melt again.

Is it OK to use fresh mozzarella on pizza? ›

Fresh mozzarella is the perfect cheese to use on pizzas. You can throw away the store bought shredded cheese, and start using this traditional cheese beloved by Italians worldwide. Not only will your pizzas taste good, but your homemade pizzas will look amazing too!

Should I use fresh mozzarella in lasagna? ›

Use Fresh Mozzarella

Mozzarella is a prime ingredient in just about any lasagna. But if you use shredded mozzarella out of a bag, you're sacrificing a lot of the taste that you could potentially get out of this cheese. Shredded pre-packaged mozzarella doesn't have much of a rich dairy flavor.

Should I shred fresh mozzarella for pizza? ›

Make sure you dry or drain fresh mozzarella for at least 15 minutes before using it on your pizza, and be sure to tear it into smaller pieces. It has a great fresh-milky flavor, but it needs that extra step of time and care to ensure your pizza retains its good structure and flavor!

Which mozzarella is best for melting? ›

For pure meltability, nothing beats low-moisture mozzarella. While fresh mozz exudes water as it melts and becomes more soupy than melty, The best low-moisture mozzarella should stretch and stretch, yet still remain dry enough that the pizza crust remains intact.

Is fresh mozzarella a good melting cheese? ›

Mozzarella: Capable of melting into a stringy, smooth texture, mozzarella possesses a mild flavor that blends well with other flavors in dishes. Low-moisture mozzarella and fresh mozzarella are among the most popular melting cheeses to use in recipes for pizza and pasta dishes.

Is BelGioioso fresh mozzarella good for pizza? ›

About the Cheese

BelGioioso's award-winning Fresh Mozzarella is now available in a lower moisture formula, perfect for traditional margherita pizza and other gourmet pizzas. This special formula for pizza is similar to the cheese used by Pizzaiuoli in Italy.

Why is my fresh mozzarella rubbery? ›

Squeaky mozzarella—and off textures in general—are almost always a result of overheating milk and/or curd. Take care to heat the milk and curd to the specified temps in your recipe. Do not let cut curd cook for extra time in hot, or heating, whey.

Why does fresh mozzarella get rubbery? ›

The room temperature milk didn't get absorbed into the cheese as easily, while the hot milk actually ended up cooking the mozzarella further, resulting in a tough, rubbery, squeaky texture around the exterior.

Which mozzarella cheese is best for pizza? ›

What type of mozzarella is best for pizza? In general, low-moisture mozzarella is our go-to for pizza. We recommend avoiding the pre-shredded stuff when you can. Pre-shredded mozzarella generally has additives like potato starch to give it a longer shelf life and to prevent pieces from clumping together.

Why is it called fresh mozzarella? ›

The term mozzarella derives from the procedure called mozzare which means "cutting by hand", separating from the curd, and serving in individual pieces, that is, the process of separation of the curd into small balls.

Why does fresh mozzarella not melt well? ›

The main reason that your mozzarella is not melting is probably due to the moisture content of the cheese. If it's too high, it will just leak liquid into the pizza and not actually melt. You also need to consider the fat content of the mozzarella. Higher fat levels will help the melting process.

Is whole-milk mozzarella the same as fresh mozzarella? ›

Fat and calories aside, the main difference between whole-milk and part-skim mozzarella is that the whole-milk version melts better, while part-skim browns faster. Neither is better; it really depends on what you want your cheese to do. As for fresh vs. aged, again, it's a matter of preference.

Will fresh mozzarella melt into sauce? ›

One thing to consider is the type of mozzarella you use. The softer and milkier your cheese is to begin with, the more it will melt and run, while firm varieties, usually those that have been salted, will retain more of their shape. Both types work well here.

Does fresh mozzarella melt in pasta? ›

Add cooked pasta, 1/2 ladle of pasta water and mozzarella, toss gently until completely combined on medium heat for 1-2 minutes until mozzarella starts to melt. Sprinkle with freshly grated Parmesan Cheese if desired. Serve immediately.

How do Italians eat fresh mozzarella? ›

When presented with mouth-watering fresh mozzarella, many Italians don't hesitate to eat it with their bare hands. Fresh mozzarella is delicious just as it is, or with a bit of salt and pepper, basil or fresh marjoram or oregano, and topped off with a good extra virgin olive oil.

Why does fresh mozzarella taste bitter? ›

Bitter cheese is normally caused by two things;

The cheese was not drained enough. Or the cheese was not salted enough.

Does fresh mozzarella melt in soup? ›

Choose the Right Cheese

Some creamy, mild cheeses also stretch into strings instead of melting which is why you rarely see a mozzarella-based soup. The best cheeses for soups are high in moisture and have a lower melting point, such as medium to sharp cheddar, fontina, Gruyere and Swiss.

Should I change the water in fresh mozzarella? ›

Emiko Davies, author of Florentine and our resident expert on all things Italian (mozzarella falls under her purview), agreed that there's no need to change the liquid right away: Simply keep it in the liquid it came in (if you want, you can transfer it to a lidded bowl or a small airtight container where it will be at ...

Can I cut mold off of mozzarella cheese and still use? ›

Most of the time, if you see some mold, you can just cut it off—about an inch around and below the mold spot, if you want to be really rigorous about it—especially if you're working with a harder cheese. Still grossed out? Throw it out.

What is the best way to shred fresh mozzarella? ›

Whenever you need to grate or slice a soft block of cheese, stick it in the freezer for 15 minutes before you go to use it. The texture will firm up and be so much easier to grate—and will save you from an intense arm workout!

What brand of mozzarella do pizzerias use? ›

“The dominant brands in most pizzerias are Galbani and Grande,” Tung confirmed. “Depending on style of pizza and what we're going for, we've used both for different things.” But it also comes down to personal preferences as well.

Why is my mozzarella not stretching in pizza? ›

Jerri's answer Acidity is the key for the stretch in mozzarella. Not enough or too much acid will result in hard curd floating or disintegrating in the water. The pH of your slab needs to be between 5.0 and 5.2 for it to stretch well when kneaded in hot water.

Does BelGioioso fresh mozzarella melt? ›

This unique cheese melts beautifully, with a delicious distinct, smoked flavor.

Does BelGioioso mozzarella cheese melt? ›

BelGioioso Fresh Mozzarella is also available in a slicing loaf. Made to order, our new Fresh Mozzarella loaf slices and melts beautifully for sandwiches, paninis, lasagnas and pizzas.

Can you shred fresh mozzarella? ›

Freezing mozzarella before grating means you can shred it evenly and also makes sure the cheese isn't "slipping and sliding all over the box grater and you run less of a risk of slipping up and accidentally grating yourself," points out Riley Wofford, Associate Food Editor.

Why is fresh mozzarella different? ›

Fresh mozzarella is typically sold in a liquid bath (brine, whey or water) which helps the cheese retain hydration and shape. It's mild and slightly sweet with a distinct milk flavor. The creamy texture is much softer than mass-processed mozzarella.

How do you make fresh mozzarella taste better? ›

Mozzarella is often served too cold, so you hardly taste anything. Put the slices of mozzarella on a plate, and put the plate on a bowl of hot water for a few minutes. This will soften the mozzarella and bring out the flavor. It will even work with cheap mozzarella.

Why is fresh mozzarella so good? ›

Mozzarella has a soft, silky, milky and mild flavour. It's considered one of the healthier cheeses, due to its high levels of calcium, protein and iron (and low portion of fat and sodium). That famous cheese stretch, when you pull a slice of pizza and the mozzarella is hanging off.

What is the best fresh mozzarella to buy? ›

Here are the best mozzarella cheese brands that you should reach for on your next grocery run.
  • The Most Flavorful Mozzarella: Good & Gather. Via target.com. ...
  • The Creamiest Mozzarella: Trader Joe's. Courtesy Trader Joe's. ...
  • The Best Mozzarella for Grating: Kraft. Via meijer.com.
Dec 22, 2022

What mozzarella does Papa John's use? ›

Papa John's uses a high-quality 100 percent Mozzarella proprietary blend and Dominos uses 100 percent Mozzarella (not a blend), according to spokespersons with Dominos and Papa John's. Why Mozzarella?

Does fresh mozzarella melt on pizza? ›

Fresh mozzarella only takes a few minutes to melt, and once it melts if it continues to sit on the pizza as it bakes, the cheese will start releasing moisture.

Can you melt fresh mozzarella balls? ›

This is it. Whenever I make pizza using fresh mozzarella as a topping I just shred it and it always melts in the oven (260ºC) in just a few minutes. As others said, it will be better if drained some of the water before using the cheese.

What is the best mozzarella to use for pizza? ›

What type of mozzarella is best for pizza? In general, low-moisture mozzarella is our go-to for pizza. We recommend avoiding the pre-shredded stuff when you can. Pre-shredded mozzarella generally has additives like potato starch to give it a longer shelf life and to prevent pieces from clumping together.

What type of mozzarella is best for melting? ›

For pure meltability, nothing beats low-moisture mozzarella. While fresh mozz exudes water as it melts and becomes more soupy than melty, The best low-moisture mozzarella should stretch and stretch, yet still remain dry enough that the pizza crust remains intact.

How do you make fresh mozzarella less watery? ›

All you need to do is to place the mozzarella cheese on a folded piece of paper towel. Add another folded piece of paper towel on top, and let it dry for at least 15-20 minutes. You can leave it longer, but then I recommend placing the cheese in the fridge until you're going to use it.

How long does fresh mozzarella take to melt in the oven? ›

Cook in preheated oven for 7-8 minutes or until mozzarella melts.

How do you cut fresh mozzarella for pizza? ›

To slice soft cheeses like mozzarella, try using unwaxed, unflavored dental floss. Slide the floss under the cheese, cross the ends at the top, then pull the floss tight to slice through the cheese.

Can fresh mozzarella be shredded? ›

Freezing mozzarella before grating means you can shred it evenly and also makes sure the cheese isn't "slipping and sliding all over the box grater and you run less of a risk of slipping up and accidentally grating yourself," points out Riley Wofford, Associate Food Editor.

Should you salt fresh mozzarella? ›

If you aren't going to eat your mozzarella right away, I recommend you buy it unsalted and put it in a bowl of water with a teaspoon of salt. (Salted mozzarella in water becomes mealy and mushy.) Cover the bowl to protect it from outside flavors and refrigerate it—it will last several days.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6374

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.