Open full sized image
Buy or borrow?
© Andrii Yalanskyi—iStock/Getty Images
In the dynamic world of finance, understanding the nuances between different types of investment accounts is important for your decision-making process. The two primary choices available to investors are margin accounts or regular cash accounts. Each offers unique advantages and disadvantages, but your choice may have more to do with your risk profile than any specific benefits.
Key Points
- Cash accounts appeal to conservative investors who wish to avoid trading with borrowed money.
- Margin accounts allow for more leverage, which can magnify both gains and losses.
- Your broker will calculate your margin requirement differently depending on the asset type, and perhaps the overall risk in your margin portfolio.
Cash accounts: The foundation of traditional investing
When you buy a stock or other security, do you always pay the full amount up front, without resorting to borrowed funds? If so, a cash account is all you need.
Paid in full. Cash accounts often appeal to more conservative investors. That’s because when you execute a trade in a cash account, you commit to paying the entire purchase price for the stocks or other securities in cash, ensuring you won’t accrue any debt or interest charges. This approach eliminates some of the inherent risks associated with investing using leveraged or borrowed funds.
Lock-up period. With cash accounts, there are limits on the availability of funds following a trade. For example, if you sell a stock, you must wait until the settlement period elapses before you access the proceeds.
This waiting period is known as “T+2,” meaning settlement occurs two business days after the day the trade was executed. So if you place a trade on Tuesday, settlement will commence on Thursday. During that settlement period, the money used for the transaction is locked up and can’t be withdrawn or used to place another trade.
Despite this seeming limitation, the settlement delay is often preferred by conservative or long-term investors because it helps to prevent overtrading.
Know your “trader DNA”
Do you overtrade, follow the herd, trade on impulse, or get stubborn about taking losses? Once you identify your trader DNA, you can choose whether to change it, tweak it, or make the best of it. Learn more about mastering trading emotions.
Margin accounts: Leveraging funds for greater opportunities
In contrast to cash accounts, margin accounts offer the ability to leverage your assets and increase your buying power. This financial maneuvering offers several advantages, but comes with its share of risks.
Access funds without liquidating current assets. Margin accounts let you borrow funds from your brokerage to supplement your investment capital. This leverage magnifies your buying power, enabling you to acquire more securities than you could with cash alone. This is enticing for those who are comfortable taking on larger positions sizes and increased risk.
A margin type for all traders
There are three categories of margin:
- Regulation T (Reg T) margin gives you up to double the buying power for stocks and other securities.
- Futures margin can offer a tenfold increase in buying power (or more) for futures contracts and other derivatives.
- Portfolio margin (PM) is a formulaic approach to margin. It’s popular with active traders, who often hold positions that offset or partially offset other positions from an overall risk standpoint. The PM formula will analyze an entire portfolio, “stress test” it under specific scenarios, and assign a margin amount accordingly.
Borrowing on margin provides flexibility because you can access additional funds without having to liquidate existing assets, potentially avoiding the need to sell securities at an inopportune moment.
Access to a credit line. Margin accounts often come with a built-in credit line that allows investors to tap into additional resources whenever necessary. This can be invaluable for seizing unexpected market opportunities or when managing unforeseen financial challenges.
Trading options, futures, and short selling. Margin accounts offer a broader spectrum of investment choices compared to cash accounts. Investors can engage in advanced trading strategies, such as futures and options trading. Margin accounts also allow for short selling, a strategy that lets investors profit from declining asset prices.
Immediate access to funds upon closing positions. One of the primary attractions of margin accounts is the prompt access to funds. When you decide to close a position, the trade is settled immediately, enabling quicker capital deployment into other investment opportunities.
Margin trading: A double-edged sword
Although margin accounts open the door to increased buying power and a broader range of investment options, they also expose you to significant risks. It’s important to grasp the potential downsides associated with margin trading to make sure it fits with your overall risk profile.
The double-edged sword of leverage. Leveraging borrowed funds in a margin account amplifies both gains and losses. Although it can lead to substantial profits in favorable market conditions, it can also magnify losses if a trade turns sour.
The costs of margin interest. Margin accounts come with a price: the cost of borrowing (i.e., interest). Margin loan rates typically fall somewhere between interest on your mortgage and credit card interest. Interest charges can erode profits and significantly impact the overall return on investment.
Risk of margin calls. Perhaps the most ominous risk associated with margin accounts is the possibility of a margin call. A margin call occurs when the value of an investor’s account falls below a certain threshold known as the maintenance margin. When this happens, the brokerage may demand that you deposit additional funds or liquidate assets to cover the shortfall.
Risk of forced liquidation. In the event of a margin call, if you cannot meet the requirements, the brokerage has the authority to forcibly liquidate assets in your account to cover the deficit—and may do so without warning. This can result in substantial losses and financial distress for the investor.
The bottom line
In the world of finance, the choice between a margin account and a cash account is not a binary decision, but rather a strategic one that depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and financial situation. Cash accounts provide stability and simplicity, while margin accounts offer the allure of increased opportunities and flexibility. You should approach margin trading with caution, fully understanding the mechanics and risks involved.
Ultimately, whether you opt for a cash account or a margin account, a thorough understanding of your financial objectives and the tools at your disposal is crucial for making sound investment decisions in an ever-evolving financial landscape.
