Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan: The Ultimate NYC Vacation Face-Off (2024)

By Dominic Horner

Here is a guide for the ultimate vacation in the two hottest NYC vacation spots, Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan: The Ultimate NYC Vacation Face-Off (1)

Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan

Quick Links

  • About Brooklyn
  • About Manhattan
  • Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan? Best Spots To Visit

New York City attracts millions of tourists yearly thanks to its trendy lifestyle, rich history, and boundary-pushing cuisine. Tourists can spend a day’s trip at the magnificent museums, beautiful botanic gardens, sky-high observation decks, and activity-filled parks.

Brooklyn and Manhattan top the list when it comes to vacationing in this major city with a vibrant atmosphere. However, visiting these boroughs is often overwhelming to tourists who don’t have friends and family who already know the best attractions. Here is a guide for the ultimate vacation in the two hottest NYC vacation spots.

About Brooklyn

Out of all the five boroughs of New York, Brooklyn is a favorite to many tourists. This captivating town is characterized by an urban touch to the music, culture, markets, and thrilling nightlife. It’s easy to be mesmerized by Brooklyn’s essence and atmosphere. The vast array of things to do is enough to last tourists a lifetime, let alone a vacation or weekend getaway. It’s a melting pot of cultures from all around the United States, featuring some streets designed into trendy hipster districts and other spots boasting vintage buildings and museums.

Related: History Of Brooklyn (Before Coney Island Made It Famous)

Every block in Brooklyn overflows with creativity and rich diversity, from an incredible LGBTQ+ history to the delectable cuisine in the city’s prestigious restaurant. In short, Brooklyn is home to almost everything tourists miss when they visit the other boroughs of New York. The main attractions in Brooklyn are Coney Bridge, the stunning Brooklyn Bridge, Brighton Beach, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Brooklyn Museum.

Even though the living standards gap is getting narrower, Brooklyn is a more budget-friendly city compared to Manhattan. This could mean some places in Brooklyn may have better vacation packages while maintaining the ultimate vacation experience. Great hotels in Brooklyn include The William Vale, Hotel le Bleu, Hotel Indigo, and Wythe Hotel.

About Manhattan

Manhattan is a city that moves fast due to the busy corporate atmosphere, but that doesn’t mean the borough doesn’t have the lion’s share of New York’s attractions and landmarks. However, Manhattan can be overwhelming for first-timers, as one would need more than two weeks to experience all of the town’s awe-inspiring attractions.

Manhattan is a New York City borough that attracts over 66 million annual tourists. This indicates just how thrilling this destination can be, boasting a mix of creativity, work, play, and world-class architecture, not to mention the trendy restaurants and chic bars. Manhattan has breathtaking sights, including towering skyscrapers where tourists can enjoy panoramic views of New York.

Related: NYC Trip: Here's What You Can Expect If You Take A Day To Visit Brooklyn

Manhattan is a better choice for tourists planning a short stay in New York than Brooklyn. This is because Manhattan has more tourist attractions coupled with thrilling nightlife. In addition, Manhattan features an extensive public transport system, lessening the burden of visitors driving to tourist destinations while beating the annoyingly expensive parking experiences. Uber and Lyft dominate the transport services in Manhattan, but tourists can also opt to use buses or the subway.

Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan? Best Spots To Visit

Although both boroughs have a lot in common, some stand-out visiting spots are unique to each destination. Here are the highlights of Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Brooklyn Attractions

Travelers who are culture enthusiasts consider the Brooklyn Museum a rite of passage while vacationing in Brooklyn, as the museum doesn’t fall short regarding worldwide collections and exhibitions. History buffs can have the time of their life exploring Egyptian history, featuring many Egyptian collections, including a section of the “Egyptian Book of The Dead.” In addition, the museum has five floors full of marvelous textiles, African art, and European paintings.

Alternatively, tourists feeling more outdoorsy can enjoy breathtaking views at the Brooklyn Bridge. This neo-Gothic passage is a literal piece of history, as it has seen different stages of civilization, from horse-drawn carriages in the 1800s to bikes and cars in modern times. Connecting Brooklyn and Manhattan, the bridge offers sweeping views of Manhattan’s skyline and the Empire State Building.

The food culture in Brooklyn is too iconic to be ignored. Nothing defines this borough like its pizza, where locals and tourists flock to have a slice of heaven at Brooklyn’s top pizzerias. Some of the best eateries foodies can engage their taste buds to include Juliana’s Pizza, Sottocasa, and Di Fara Pizza.

Manhattan Attractions

Manhattan is littered with museums, but The Metropolitan Museum of Art takes the crown. Arguably one of the best museums in the world, this tourist attraction is home to more than 2 million works of art, including sculptures of Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French. Moreover, history buffs can enjoy the rich history of all continents as they treat themselves to awe-inspiring paintings, jewelry, and textiles. Other museums in Manhattan worth visiting are The National September 11 Memorial & Museum, The National Jazz Museum in Harlem, and the Skyscraper Museum.

Tourists who love beautiful views can try the Sky Deck Empire State Building, a great spot in Williamsburg that offers panoramic views of Manhattan and New York City. Sitting at the heart of Midtown Manhattan, the observation wraps around the entire Empire State Building, delivering a 360˚ view from 1,454 feet above Manhattan. The observation deck is open from 8:00 AM to 2:00 AM, and guests can also enjoy an interactive museum and education center experience on their way to the top.

There are many more places in Brooklyn and Manhattan where visitors can have memorable experiences during a holiday. Overall, Manhattan has more destinations, whereas Brooklyn boasts a rich culture and history. However, both boroughs are worth discovering, thanks to their vacation-friendly atmosphere.

Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan: The Ultimate NYC Vacation Face-Off (2024)

FAQs

Brooklyn Vs. Manhattan: The Ultimate NYC Vacation Face-Off? ›

There are many more places in Brooklyn and Manhattan where visitors can have memorable experiences during a holiday. Overall, Manhattan has more destinations, whereas Brooklyn boasts a rich culture and history. However, both boroughs are worth discovering, thanks to their vacation-friendly atmosphere.

Is Brooklyn calmer than Manhattan? ›

For better or worse, Manhattan feels more hectic but conveniently walkable if you appreciate round-the-clock urban energy. Brooklyn offers a more relaxed vibe while retaining NYC vibrancy across historic districts filled with tree-lined streets of brownstones to newly built rental towers near the East River waterfront.

Should I stay in Brooklyn when visiting New York? ›

Yes you should. You'll save money. Depending on where you stay in Brooklyn, it will take you less time to get to attractions/neighbourhoods in lower Manhattan than if you stayed uptown. Most importantly, Brooklyn has some of the most interesting neighbourhoods, restaurants, bars and stores in the entire city.

Are hotels cheaper in Brooklyn than Manhattan? ›

Get Simon Calder's Travel email

And when it comes to accommodation, you certainly get more bang for your buck in Brooklyn, with hotel rooms generally larger and cheaper than their Manhattan counterparts.

How do I not look like a tourist in Manhattan? ›

Anything too slim or fitted (this includes skinny jeans) will mark you as not from here. Also, if you want to look really insider-y, she said, “throw your chunky oversize knit sweater over your coat instead of a scarf, and tuck your oversize tote under the arm, not on your shoulder.” Finally, don't be flashy.

Why do people prefer Brooklyn over Manhattan? ›

Manhattan's reputation for high rental prices for smaller square footage prompts people to move to Brooklyn, which offers more space for your money. Brooklyn is a larger borough area-wise, and the homes are more spacious, and buildings are lower, so you get more sunlight.

Is it better to go to Brooklyn or Manhattan? ›

Manhattan has breathtaking sights, including towering skyscrapers where tourists can enjoy panoramic views of New York. Manhattan is a better choice for tourists planning a short stay in New York than Brooklyn. This is because Manhattan has more tourist attractions coupled with thrilling nightlife.

Is Brooklyn a walkable city? ›

Brooklyn is a large and expansive borough, and some of the neighborhoods in the borough are not pedestrian-friendly. Fortunately, however, there are a number of great neighborhoods in Brooklyn that rank highly when it comes to finding "walkable" neighborhoods in New York City.

Is Brooklyn more expensive than Manhattan? ›

Even though the gap is getting smaller, Manhattan is still more expensive to live in overall. Read more about housing costs in New York City. While the average Brooklyn rent is quickly catching up to Manhattan, it likely will never be as high-priced as Manhattan.

Is it better to stay in Brooklyn or Queens? ›

If you prefer a more suburban community vibe, Queens may be a better fit, as it's the largest borough from a geographical standpoint but has a slightly smaller population than Brooklyn. It's a little more spread out and has room for woods, backyards, and other wonderful green spaces.

How much is the subway from Brooklyn to Manhattan? ›

The best way to get from Brooklyn to Lower Manhattan without a car is to subway which takes 16 min and costs $3. How long does it take to get from Brooklyn to Lower Manhattan? The subway from Prospect Park to Canal St takes 16 min including transfers and departs every 10 minutes.

Which part of NYC is the cheapest to stay in? ›

The Lower East Side of Manhattan

Some areas are of course more affordable than others though, and one of those is the Lower East Side. This historically working class area of NYC is very vibrant and jam packed with history.

Is Manhattan richer than Brooklyn? ›

As you might expect, most wealthy New Yorkers live in Manhattan. More than half of the city's 50 wealthiest neighborhoods are located in Manhattan, including the 15 most expensive. While Brooklyn has 19 of the most expensive neighborhoods, Queens has 5, and Staten Island has 1.

Can you walk Manhattan at night? ›

While Manhattan is generally safe for walking around at night, it's important to exercise caution and be aware of your surroundings. Stick to well-lit and busy areas, avoid certain neighborhoods with higher crime rates, and consider implementing the safety tips mentioned.

Are there any parts of Manhattan to avoid? ›

East Harlem, Manhattan: While crime has decreased in recent years, it still has a higher crime rate than the city average. Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn: Similar to Harlem, crime rates vary by area. Some areas have a higher crime rate than the city average.

What is the most touristy part of NYC? ›

Times Square is the hub of the Broadway theater district and a major cultural venue in Midtown Manhattan. The pedestrian intersection also has one of the highest annual attendance rates of any tourist attraction in the world, estimated at 60 million including daytrippers.

Is Manhattan or Brooklyn safer? ›

New York is known to be safer than most cities of a similar size, but visitors and residents should still remain cautious. Brooklyn has higher major crime rates than Queens or Staten Island but lower than the Bronx and much lower than Manhattan.

Is Brooklyn rougher than Queens? ›

Queens vs Other NYC Boroughs Crime Rates

Although Brooklyn and Manhattan tend to be feature pricier real estate, Queens has a rate of violent crime that is approximately than 40% lower than Brooklyn and 45% lower than Manhattan. In contrast, violent crime in the Bronx is more than 250% higher than in Queens.

Why do people love Brooklyn? ›

This picturesque community has cultural richness, architectural beauty, and a vibrant and serene lifestyle. With its stunning views, easy access to Manhattan, and diverse amenities, it's no wonder that Brooklyn Heights stands out as a top choice for those looking to make a new start in New York City.

Is Brooklyn richer than Manhattan? ›

More people live in Brooklyn than in Manhattan, and Brooklyn occupies more land area, but Manhattan's gross domestic product is many times Brooklyn's. It may be more expensive to live in wealthy Brooklyn neighborhoods than in modest Manhattan neighborhoods, but Brooklyn is generally more affordable.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 5771

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.