Here are some questions to use to help you analyze the readings.
Critical analysis of a theoretical paper in achievement motivation
- How is motivation defined by the author(s)?
- What are the main arguments? (e.g., What are the predictions and explanations for motivation?)
- What evidence is provided?
-- Supporting
-- Countering
-- What counts as evidence? - What definition of achievement is used? (What does "success" mean?)
- How does this theory relate to others, past and present, in and out of motivation? Complementary? Contradictory?
- What are the assumptions underlying the theory as presented in the paper? (What is/are the author(s) taking for granted?)
- What challenges do you have for this explanation of motivation?
- What questions arise for you as you think about this theory? How useful is it?
Critical analysis of a research report
- What is the theoretical framework for this study?
- What problem(s) does this research address?
- What are the research question(s)?
- What are the hypotheses or guiding questions?
- What support is provided for hypotheses & questions?
- What methods are used?
- Data sources (who participates, in what context)
- Measures/indicators:
- Definition of achievement used:
- Are they measuring/documenting motivation or a related variable?
- Design (experimental, correlational, ethnographic, case study...)
- Results
- If this was a test of hypotheses, were they supported?
- If qualitative, was the evidence sufficient to warrant the interpretation?
- Discussion/interpretation:
-- What are the answers to the research questions, according to the authors?
-- Does the evidence support the authors' conclusions? Is it consistent with the theoretical frame? What's new -does it contribute to what we know (does it test, challenge, expand a theory?) - -- Are there plausible alternative explanations for the results?
- -- Limitations of study (what are the holes, flaws, ambiguities?)
- How did the theoretical framework shape the research questions, evidence gathered, & interpretation? Are there other ways to approach the problem that might shed more light?
FAQs
Additional Questions To Consider
- How do you test to make sure that your solutions work correctly?
- Describe a time when you had to adjust your approach to solving a problem.
- What resources do you rely on when analysing data?
- How do you make sure that your analysis is accurate?
Good analytical questions have the potential to highlight relationships between different sources or phenomena: patterns, connections, contradictions, dilemmas, and problems. Good analytical questions can also ask about some implications or consequences of your analysis.
What questions to answer in an analysis? ›
“How” and “why” questions generally require more analysis and complex thinking than “who,” “what,” “when,” and “where” questions; they are thus generally better suited for essay writing.
What is the easiest way to solve analytical reasoning questions? ›
How to answer LSAT analytical questions
- Visualize the information in the prompt. ...
- Underline keywords in the question. ...
- Make an inference before answering. ...
- Answer the questions in reverse. ...
- Apply the process of elimination.
The four questions of data analysis are the questions of description, probability, inference, and hom*ogeneity.
How to write analytical answers? ›
Break an issue into its constituent parts. Look in depth at each part using supporting arguments and evidence for and against as well as how these inter relate to one another. You need not take any stand when the directive word is "analyze" you just have to summarize on the basis of your analysis.
What are the 7 questions of analysis? ›
The 7 Impact Analysis questions
- What is the problem you are trying to solve?
- Why is government action needed?
- What policy options are you considering?
- What is the likely net benefit of each option? ...
- Who did you consult and how did you incorporate their feedback?
- What is the best option from those you have considered?
They include Who, What, When Where, and Why. The 5 Ws are often mentioned in journalism (cf. news style), research, and police investigations. They constitute a formula for getting the complete story on a subject.
What are the six analysis questions? ›
Six Questions
- Whom do we serve?
- What do they want and need most?
- What do we provide to help them?
- What is the best way to provide this? ...
- How do we know we are succeeding?
- How should we organize to deliver?
- 1 Step 1: Define your purpose and scope. The first step is to define your purpose and scope for your analysis. ...
- 2 Step 2: Identify your variables and indicators. ...
- 3 Step 3: Formulate your question. ...
- 4 Step 4: Evaluate and refine your question. ...
- 5 Here's what else to consider.
Perhaps the most common analytical problem is a quantitative analysis, examples of which include the elemental analysis of a newly synthesized compound, measuring the concentration of glucose in blood, or determining the difference between the bulk and the surface concentrations of Cr in steel.
What type of questions are asked in analytical reasoning? ›
Answer: Analytical reasoning questions can be broken down into many subtopics, such as “statement and argument,” “statement and assumption,” “statement and conclusion,” “statement and course of action,” “syllogism,” “cause and effects,” etc.
What is analytical questioning? ›
A strong analytical question. speaks to a genuine dilemma presented by your sources. In other words, the question focuses on a real confusion, problem, ambiguity, or gray area, about which readers will conceivably have different reactions, opinions, or ideas. yields an answer that is not obvious.
What is an example of an analysis type question? ›
Here is an example of an analysis question: "How did the various causes of the French Revolution combine with one another to lead to an eventual collapse of the ancien regime?" Many analysis questions contain the word "analyze" in them, but this is not a prerequisite.
What is analytical and example? ›
Analytical people seek all the facts and information before coming to a conclusion. A smart researcher knows where to find those facts and who to ask for help to get more information. Examples of analytical research skills include: Conducting a reflective analysis to show the company's progress in the last five years.
What are some examples of questions under analysis? ›
Analysis Questions
- What is a typical value?
- What is the uncertainty for a typical value?
- What is a good distributional fit for a set of numbers?
- What is a percentile?
- Does an engineering modification have an effect?
- Does a factor have an effect?
- What are the most important factors?
