How can you identify the cause of a service failure in hospitality? (2024)

A service failure is any situation where a customer's expectations are not met by the service provider. This can include errors, delays, defects, inconveniences, misunderstandings, or even rude or indifferent behavior. Service failures can have negative impacts on customer satisfaction, loyalty, word-of-mouth, and profitability.

Service failures can be classified into four types according to the service recovery paradox (SRP) model. This model suggests that customers can become more satisfied and loyal after a service failure if the service recovery is effective and surpasses their expectations. Core service failures, such as a wrong order, a faulty product, or a missed deadline, require high levels of service recovery, such as compensation, replacement, or apology. Service process failures, like a long wait, a confusing procedure, or a lack of communication, need moderate levels of service recovery like explanation, reassurance, or empathy. Customer needs failures necessitate low levels of service recovery such as acknowledgement, adjustment, or courtesy. Uncontrollable failures caused by external factors like weather, traffic, or power outage only require minimal levels of service recovery like information, apology, or assistance.

The 5 whys technique is a problem-solving method that can be used to identify the cause of a service failure. This method involves asking "why" five times to get to the root cause of a problem. For instance, if a customer complains that their hotel room was dirty, you can ask why the housekeeping staff did not clean it properly, which might reveal that they were understaffed and rushed due to high turnover and low morale. Digging deeper, you might find that the management did not invest enough in their development and recognition. By asking these questions, you can uncover the underlying cause of the service failure and address it accordingly.

Once you have identified the cause of the service failure, you can apply service recovery strategies to restore customer satisfaction and loyalty. The justice theory suggests that customers evaluate service recovery based on three dimensions of justice: distributive, procedural, and interactional. These can be grouped into four categories: outcome strategies, such as refunds or discounts; process strategies, such as simplifying or speeding up the service recovery process; communication strategies, such as listening or apologizing; and recovery culture strategies, like training or rewarding employees to deliver service recovery. These strategies focus on the fairness of the outcome, process, communication, and culture that the customer receives after a service failure.

To measure the effectiveness of your service recovery efforts, you can use various methods and metrics to assess the impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction and loyalty. For example, customer feedback can be collected through surveys, reviews, ratings, or testimonials to gauge their level of satisfaction and loyalty after a service failure and recovery. Additionally, tools like the net promoter score (NPS) or the customer effort score (CES) can be used to measure how likely customers are to recommend your service or how easy it was to resolve their issue. Furthermore, customer behavior can be tracked through data, analytics, or observation to measure their level of retention, repurchase, referral, or advocacy after a service failure and recovery. Additionally, tools like the customer lifetime value (CLV) or the customer loyalty index (CLI) can be used to measure how valuable customers are to your business or how loyal they are to your brand. Moreover, customer emotions can be analyzed through sentiment analysis, facial recognition, or biometrics to measure their level of happiness, anger, frustration, or satisfaction after a service failure and recovery. In addition, tools like the emotion score (ES) or the customer satisfaction index (CSI) can be used to measure how positive or negative customers feel about your service.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Hospitality Management

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.