How To: Complete Guide to Eating Salt Water Taffy (2024)

August 3, 2018 Matt Frand

We received the best phone call the other day.... Some random guy (Taffy Shop's new best friend) called in and said he was having a debate with a friend that needed settling right away so he called the Taffy Shop to settle it once and for all. He had us intrigued! Jed, our "Ambassador of Quan" when it comes to salt water taffy tasting,.....we can hear him now, "Show me the taffy!" (Go watchJerry Maguireif that just went over your head. We recommend the edited version if you can find it) ;o) .....anyway, where were we? Oh yeah, Jed answered that phone call and lets just say the stars aligned when he was the one that picked it up.... this call was made just for him!

So Jed replied to our answer seeker, "How do YOU eat salt water taffy?" The guys response was, "I think you chew it and leave it in your mouth to dissolve, which could take up to 30 minutes. But my friend thinks that you just chew the taffy and then just swallow it. So? How do you really eat it?"

Jed's response was classic! He said, "Well, it all comes down to self control. If you're like me, you pound it down until you realize you're at the bottom of the bag and then you start savoring every piece. So in a way, you're both right. But ultimately, you need to understand your own way of eating it so you can buy it according to your needs."

His response reminded me of this meme:

How To: Complete Guide to Eating Salt Water Taffy (1)

Ain't that the TRUTH!!

Our new friend thought that was awesome and laughed at the thought. Then Jed said that we may just have to write a blog about this phone call. Our friend asked if we could give him a shout-out when we do. So andrewcool24 and foxy.fawn ..... here's your shout-out!

How To: Complete Guide to Eating Salt Water Taffy (2)

So, how do YOU eat salt water taffy? Do you treat it like a bop-it toy and pull it, twist it, bop it.....and then pop it in your mouth? Maybe you like to treat it like play-dough and make something with it before you devour it. Or maybe you just let it dissolve in your mouth, just like our new friend and savor every last second of it while drool seeps from the corners of your mouth because of the delicious goodness that is our taffy. We recommend all of the above. There really is no wrong way to eat a piece of taffy. But we give super props to anyone that can keep it in their mouth without eating it for longer than it takes to chew it. Man, I just can't. One down and the next wrapper is already open! That's how WE roll around here!

How you eat salt water taffy is as unique as you!..... We recommend by the piece, by the pound or by the boat load of goodness that comes in our 5 lb. bag! Now, go get your taffy on! Giddy up!

How To: Complete Guide to Eating Salt Water Taffy (3)

How To: Complete Guide to Eating Salt Water Taffy (2024)

FAQs

How are you supposed to eat salt water taffy? ›

So Jed replied to our answer seeker, "How do YOU eat salt water taffy?" The guys response was, "I think you chew it and leave it in your mouth to dissolve, which could take up to 30 minutes.

How many calories are in 3 pieces of salt water taffy? ›

Salt water taffy (3 piece) contains 25g total carbs, 25g net carbs, 1.9g fat, 0g protein, and 110 calories.

What are the main ingredients in salt water taffy? ›

Saltwater taffy ingredients are fairly simple. The candy is made from sugar, cornstarch, corn syrup, glycerine, butter, water, and salt. Other saltwater taffy ingredients can include food coloring and natural or artificial flavorings, especially fruit flavors.

How many pieces of taffy is a serving? ›

Nutritional Facts
Serving size 4 pieces (28g)
Servings per container
Amount per serving Calories110
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 2g3%
19 more rows

Should you refrigerate taffy? ›

Store in a sealed plastic bag at room temperature for the longest shelf life, which can be up to 3 months before the consistency begins to change. Some like to freeze their taffy to preserve its peak flavor for longer, though don't forget to let it thaw completely at room temperature before trying to take a bite!

Is salt water taffy supposed to be hard? ›

If our taffy feels hard, it is most likely because it is cold; try holding the taffy snugly in the palm of your hand for a few moments, the warmth should soften it right up!

What is the difference between taffy and salt water taffy? ›

Regular Taffy. Since salt water taffy gained its moniker following that offhanded comment after the flooding in Atlantic City, there is really no difference between salt water taffy and regular taffy. There was little or no salt added to the candy over 100 years ago or now.

How many pieces of salt water taffy per pound? ›

However, to provide an estimate, there tends to be approximately 65-70 taffy kisses in one pound, and 45-50 taffy sticks in one pound.

Is taffy just sugar? ›

Ingredients. Salt water taffy is composed of sugar, cornstarch, corn syrup, glycerine, water, butter, salt, natural and/or artificial flavor, and food color.

What is the shelf life of saltwater taffy? ›

Taffy is a candy with a high content of sugar, corn syrup, and other ingredients, generally free of preservatives. That means the shelf life of your saltwater taffy is about a week long. After seven days, store bought and homemade salt water taffy starts to harden and becomes difficult to eat.

Why is my taffy not hardening? ›

The simple answer is that there is too much moisture in your candy. One or more factors could be contributing to this problem. In hard candy making, it is important to cook all the water out of the sugar/corn syrup/water mixture.

What is the most popular flavor of taffy? ›

Most Popular Flavors of Taffy
  • Fruit Punch – This fruity colorful piece of taffy has earned its spot at number one. ...
  • Banana – This bright yellow piece of taffy is loved by many. ...
  • Vanilla – This white piece of taffy was the first flavor of taffy made here at Zeno's.
Feb 1, 2024

How many calories are in 10 pieces of salt water taffy? ›

There are 198 calories in 10 pieces of Taffy.

How many calories are in 5 pieces of salt water taffy? ›

James Candy
Nutrition Facts
For a Serving Size of 5 pieces (42g)
How many calories are in Salt Water Taffy? Amount of calories in Salt Water Taffy: Calories 150Calories from Fat 22.5 (15%)
% Daily Value *
How much fat is in Salt Water Taffy? Amount of fat in Salt Water Taffy: Total Fat 2.5g-
15 more rows

Why do you pull salt water taffy? ›

The purpose of pulling the taffy is to add air in to the candy. This allows for millions of air bubbles to form which is how a clear batch of cooked taffy all of a sudden begins to turn bright white. The added air into the product also adds volume, and turns the candy into a much larger piece.

Is salt water taffy supposed to taste salty? ›

Salt water taffy is a tasty treat that's right at home in shops all along coastlines everywhere. If you've ever had a mouthful of seawater, though, you probably know that salt water taffy is sweet and doesn't taste anything like seawater.

What's the deal with salt water taffy? ›

The sweet is said to have received its name after a boardwalk candy shop flooded with water from the Atlantic Ocean in 1883, soaking all the taffy in salty seawater. Reportedly, the shop owner joked with a customer that all he had was salt water taffy, and the name stuck.

Is salt water taffy healthy? ›

Taffy is a sweet treat that can be found at carnivals and boardwalks. However, it is essential to note that a seven-piece serving of saltwater taffy contains 23 grams of sugar. This amount is more than the recommended daily sugar intake for both men and women. Taffy is a soft, chewy candy that is slightly fatty.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Last Updated:

Views: 6766

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Birthday: 1993-07-01

Address: Suite 763 6272 Lang Bypass, New Xochitlport, VT 72704-3308

Phone: +22014484519944

Job: Banking Officer

Hobby: Sailing, Gaming, Basketball, Calligraphy, Mycology, Astronomy, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Rev. Leonie Wyman, I am a colorful, tasty, splendid, fair, witty, gorgeous, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.