Katherine of Aragon (2024)

Why did Henry VIII marry Katherine of Aragon? He loved her – and Spanish Katherine’s powerful family also provided useful allies to the English throne. Katherine was first married to Henry’s older brother, Arthur, who died soon afterwards. With their prudent father’s blessing, Henry chose to marry his brother’s widow in 1509 to continue the Spanish alliance (and to hang on to her dowry).

Katherine produced six children, but only a daughter (the future Mary I) survived. As the years went by, Henry became desperate for a male heir, finally attempting to divorce his Queen for a younger woman. He argued that their marriage had been unlawful; Katherine, a staunch Catholic, was having none of it. What happened next transformed English religion and politics for ever.

A powerful alliance

Katherine was the daughter of the powerful couple Queen Isabella of Castile and King Ferdinand of Aragon, whose own marriage had united Spain. Having King Ferdinand as an ally against the French was extremely useful for England.

Princess Katherine was well-educated and politically astute, and a good match for Henry. Although short in stature, she seems to have had a steely determination that later – some historians argue - bordered on a self-destructive stubbornness.

Portrait of Catherine of Aragon, early 1530s, Anglo-Flemish School, (16th century), © Philip Mould Ltd, London / Bridgeman

A once-happy couple

Henry married Katherine because he wanted to. Katherine, six years Henry’s senior, was considered beautiful, and shared a love of display and finery with her husband. She and Henry rode and hunted together, and he trusted her completely.

For many years they were a happy and devoted couple and a powerful political team. But the lack of a male heir was a critical issue, and as Katherine grew older, this was a problem that Henry felt needed to be solved. Katherine disagreed, and the tensions and differences fatally undermined the marriage.

Tragedy

Henry and Katherine lost at least five children together. Only Mary, born in 1516, survived beyond infancy. Henry was disappointed she wasn’t a boy, but still optimistic that he and Katherine would have more children.

Sadly for Katherine they did not. She may have miscarried again in the autumn of 1517. The following year she had yet another stillborn baby. This was her last pregnancy. Henry's hopes for a son were dashed.

As the years went by Henry became restless and increasingly desperate for a son.

Image: Queen Mary I, child of Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon, © National Portrait Gallery, London

Enter Anne Boleyn

When French-educated Anne Boleyn became Katherine’s lady-in-waiting in the early 1520s, the Queen’s days were numbered. Anne was glamorous and young, and captivated the King. As Roman Catholics, divorce was not an option, so Henry looked for another way out. He became obsessed with whether Katherine’s previous marriage to his brother Arthur had been consummated, which Katherine continued to deny.

The superstitious King became convinced that God was displeased that he had married his brother’s widow, punishing him by denying them a son. Henry made up his mind. Katherine had to go, and not even the Pope was going to prevent him getting rid of her.