Metatrader 4 vs Metatrader 5: The Forex Trading Platform Showdown (2024)

In the arena of online foreign exchange (forex) trading, Metatrader 4 (MT4) and Metatrader 5 (MT5) are undeniably the two heavyweights. Developed by MetaQuotes Software, both platforms have etched their names into the fabric of forex trading, providing traders with a host of analytical tools, graphical displays, and order execution capabilities. However, the persisting conundrum for most traders, particularly those just venturing into the world of forex trading, is the choice between MT4 and MT5. The aim of this article is to dissect the distinct features, capabilities, and performance of both platforms, to help guide your decision-making process.

Understanding Metatrader 4

Legacy and User Base

MT4 was released in 2005 and quickly rose to prominence as a favorite amongst retail forex traders. Its user-friendly interface, combined with powerful charting and analysis tools, makes it a popular choice even today. MT4’s vast and active user base is a testament to its longevity and durability in the fast-paced, evolving world of forex trading.

Trading and Analytical Tools

MT4 boasts over 30 inbuilt technical indicators and over 2000 free custom indicators, plus thousands of paid ones. Its charting system allows for nine different timeframes, providing ample flexibility for traders. Moreover, MT4’s Expert Advisors (EAs) allow for automated trading using algorithms, a favorite feature among many traders.

Delving into Metatrader 5

Next Generation Trading

As the successor to MetaTrader 4, MT5 was introduced in 2010 with the intention of providing not just forex trading, but also stocks, futures, and CFDs. MT5, being more advanced, boasts numerous enhancements including additional tools, more timeframes, and advanced market depth features.

Improved Tools and Features

MT5 offers 38 built-in indicators, 22 analytical tools, and 46 graphical objects, giving it an edge in terms of analytical power. In addition, it provides 21 timeframes, an increase from MT4’s nine. Also, MT5’s market depth feature provides insight into market liquidity, a crucial aspect that most forex traders consider.

Comparing Performance and Flexibility

Algorithmic Trading: EAs and Scripts

Both MT4 and MT5 support algorithmic trading through EAs, but MT5 has a more advanced built-in tester for EAs, providing more accurate results. Scripts, which are used for single execution tasks on both platforms, have more functions and capabilities in MT5.

Order Execution and Pending Orders

MT4 supports three types of execution: Instant, Request, and Market, while MT5 supports four: Instant, Request, Market, and Exchange. In addition, MT5 offers six types of pending orders, versus four offered by MT4.

Weighing Broker Support and Backward Compatibility

Broker Support

Due to its longstanding status, MT4 is supported by a large number of forex brokers. While more and more brokers are supporting MT5, the numbers still lean towards MT4, making it a more accessible choice.

Backward Compatibility

One of the main sticking points is the lack of backward compatibility in MT5. Traders cannot transfer and use their custom MT4 scripts and indicators in MT5. This, combined with the fact that many brokers still only support MT4, causes a degree of hesitancy among traders to transition to the newer platform.

Evaluating Learning Curve and User Interface

Learning Curve

While both platforms share a common developer and similarities in design, MT5’s enhanced functionality means it comes with a steeper learning curve compared to MT4. For new traders, MT4 might prove more accessible and easier to master initially.

User Interface

The user interfaces of MT4 and MT5 are quite similar, but MT5 presents a more streamlined appearance. While MT4’s design might seem slightly dated, its simplicity appeals to many traders who value functionality over aesthetic appeal.

Considering Financial Instruments and Market Access

Financial Instruments

Forex trading is the primary focus in MT4, but MT5 caters to a broader market, supporting stocks, futures, and commodity trading. This multi-asset platform feature of MT5 provides a more comprehensive trading environment.

Market Access

MT5 provides access to more markets and has an enhanced Market Depth feature, which gives traders a better overview of market prices and liquidity. This feature alone can be a decisive factor for traders who wish to have a more profound view of market dynamics. Each platform holds unique attributes catering to different trading styles, preferences, and requirements. MT4, with its user-friendly interface and vast broker support, remains an excellent choice for novice traders and those who wish to stick with forex trading. On the other hand, MT5, with its extended features, advanced tools, and multi-asset support, serves as a comprehensive trading platform for the versatile trader who wishes to explore beyond forex. Therefore, the choice between MT4 and MT5 should be determined by your individual trading needs and the range of assets you intend to trade.

Comments