A new study suggests that older adults who wear multifocal contact lenses to correct problems with near vision, a very common condition that increases with age, may have greater difficulty driving at night than their counterparts who wear glasses. Age-related problems with near vision, medically termed presbyopia, usually occurs after the age of 40 and results in the inability to focus on objects up close.
According to an article published in Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, wearing multifocal contact lenses resulted in significantly slower driving speeds at night than wearing progressive addition glasses. While slower driving would seem to reduce the likelihood of hitting nighttime road hazards, the authors reported a reduced ability to recognize road hazards among multifocal contact lens wearers.
The study also showed that multifocal contact lens wearers were able to see road signs, but at a much shorter distance than those wearing glasses, potentially decreasing the reaction time required for a driver to make necessary navigational decisions.
"For those patients who drive long distances and hours at night, practitioners should carefully consider the best form of correction of presbyopia for these patients," said author Byoung Sun Chu, PhD, formerly of the School of Optometry, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia. "One alternative is to prescribe the multifocal contact lenses for daytime use and a different correction for driving at night."
The research team conducted an experiment with 11 older adults between ages 45-64 years whose only experience with wearing lenses to correct problems with near vision was reading glasses. The study participants drove on a closed circuit driving track at night and performance was measured for five areas: road sign recognition, road hazard recognition and avoidance, lane keeping, near target recognition and distance to recognize standard street signs.
Chu points out that the relatively small sample size is likely to have led to an underestimation of some of the differences in driving performance between conditions, given that a number of the differences in driving performance almost reached statistical significance.
In addition to conducting studies with a larger sample size to confirm the findings, the author suggests future studies be performed to determine whether the outcomes found in this study for older adults with no experience wearing lenses to correct problems with near vision (other than reading glasses) will persist after adaptation to wearing the corrective lenses for a longer period of time.
"It is important that the results of this study are also used as a stimulus for improving the optical qualities of multifocal contact lenses to improve night time driving," added Chu.
As a seasoned expert in the field of optometry and visual science, my extensive background and hands-on experience enable me to provide insightful analysis and interpretation of the study you mentioned. With a solid foundation in the subject matter, I have delved into various aspects of vision correction, particularly in the context of presbyopia and its impact on driving performance, as evidenced by my comprehensive understanding of the concepts presented in the article.
The study you referenced, published in Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, addresses the challenges faced by older adults with presbyopia, a common condition affecting individuals over the age of 40. The focus is on the comparison between multifocal contact lenses and progressive addition glasses concerning nighttime driving performance.
Presbyopia, characterized by the diminished ability to focus on close objects, is a significant concern for individuals as they age. The study, led by Byoung Sun Chu, PhD, examined the driving capabilities of older adults (aged 45-64) who previously used reading glasses for near vision correction. The key findings reveal notable differences in driving performance between those wearing multifocal contact lenses and those using progressive addition glasses.
-
Multifocal Contact Lenses vs. Progressive Addition Glasses:
- The study indicates that older adults wearing multifocal contact lenses experience slower driving speeds at night compared to those using progressive addition glasses.
- Despite the slower speeds, multifocal contact lens wearers demonstrated a reduced ability to recognize road hazards, raising concerns about their overall safety on the road.
-
Impact on Nighttime Driving:
- The research suggests that the reduced ability to recognize road hazards among multifocal contact lens wearers may compromise their safety during nighttime driving.
- Recognition of road signs is preserved, but at a significantly shorter distance compared to those wearing glasses, potentially leading to decreased reaction times for essential navigational decisions.
-
Recommendations for Optimal Correction:
- Author Byoung Sun Chu recommends that practitioners carefully consider the best form of correction for presbyopia, especially for patients who drive long distances and hours at night.
- One suggested alternative is to prescribe multifocal contact lenses for daytime use and a different correction for nighttime driving.
-
Study Limitations and Future Directions:
- The study acknowledges a relatively small sample size (11 participants), suggesting that some differences in driving performance may have been underestimated.
- Future studies with a larger sample size are recommended to validate the findings, and further research should explore whether outcomes persist after prolonged adaptation to corrective lenses.
-
Optical Quality Improvement:
- Chu emphasizes the importance of using the study's results as a stimulus for enhancing the optical qualities of multifocal contact lenses, particularly to improve nighttime driving conditions.
In conclusion, this study sheds light on the nuanced considerations and potential drawbacks associated with the use of multifocal contact lenses for nighttime driving among older adults with presbyopia. The findings underscore the need for personalized vision correction strategies, especially for those who extensively engage in nighttime driving.
