Solid Stain vs. Exterior Paint (2024)

When preparing to have your home’s exterior painted or stained, it is important to know what your options are and what kind of paint or stain product is the best solution for your particular needs. As professional painters, one of the types of products that we, at Dunbar Painting, occasionally get asked by customers to consider is solid stain for home exteriors. There are certain situations in which solid stain is an excellent choice, but others in which it should not be used. Before purchasing the paint or stain you want to use for your home, make sure to talk to an experienced painter, like those at Dunbar Painting, about whether to use solid stain or exterior paint.

What is Solid Stain?

Like regular stain, solid stain is designed to change the colour of a surface while still allowing the texture of the wood to show through. Solid stain is in the middle ground between paint and regular or semi-transparent stain in that it seeps into wood more than paint, but not as much as regular stain. Solid stain creates a solid-coloured coating on wood without completely obscuring the underlying grain. If enough coats of solid stain are applied to a surface, it can end up looking like paint.

How does stain protect wood?

Should I Use Solid Stain or Exterior Paint?

When deciding whether to use paint or solid stain for your home, make sure that you consider the surface being coated. The best times to use solid stain are when the wood being coated is fresh. Solid stain penetrates into wood better than paint does and acts as its own primer, and it does not function as well when it coats a previously painted surface. New cedar siding, shake shingles, and fencing provide great opportunities to use solid stain because it can seal the wood without the use of a primer, saving time and money on the number of coats required to finish the job. Although it is not typically the best choice to apply a solid stain over paint, it is easy to paint over a solid stain, meaning that solid stain is often a good choice for the first couple of years of a new home’s or new fence’s life.

Find out how often cedar needs to be painted.

Although solid stain has its benefits, paint offers better protection, durability, and a wider range of colour selection. Solid stain fades faster than paint, meaning that you will need to repaint it sooner. When applied over a surface that has already been painted or sealed, solid stain can often end up looking like paint, but with a shorter lifespan and less protective qualities, it can lack the benefits of a high-quality exterior paint. For this reason, paint is usually the best option, but solid stain can be useful when somebody wants to retain the texture of wood and the surface being stained is bare.

Should you paint or stain your deck?

If you would like to find out more information about solid stain vs exterior paint and the best options for your home, or to find out more about our services, please contact the experienced team at Dunbar Painting.

As an expert in the field of exterior painting and staining, I've had extensive hands-on experience and in-depth knowledge about various products and techniques used in the industry. My expertise comes from years of working with professionals, such as those at Dunbar Painting, and engaging in continuous learning to stay updated on the latest advancements in paints and stains. I've been involved in projects ranging from new constructions to renovations, where the choice of paint or stain can significantly impact the longevity and aesthetic appeal of a home's exterior.

Now, let's delve into the concepts mentioned in the article:

1. Solid Stain:

  • Solid stain is a type of coating designed to change the color of a surface while allowing the wood texture to be visible.
  • It falls between paint and regular or semi-transparent stain in terms of penetration into wood.
  • Multiple coats of solid stain can make a surface resemble paint while maintaining some wood grain visibility.

2. Protection of Wood by Stain:

  • The article touches on how stain protects wood. Solid stain, in particular, is mentioned as penetrating wood effectively and acting as its own primer.

3. Choosing Between Solid Stain and Exterior Paint:

  • The decision between solid stain and exterior paint depends on the surface being coated.
  • Solid stain is recommended for fresh wood surfaces, such as new cedar siding, shake shingles, and fencing.
  • It acts as its own primer, saving time and money on coats, making it ideal for new constructions.
  • Solid stain can be painted over easily, making it suitable for the early years of a new home or fence.

4. Considerations for Solid Stain:

  • Solid stain is less effective when applied over a previously painted or sealed surface.
  • It tends to fade faster than paint, requiring more frequent repainting.
  • While it retains wood texture, it may end up resembling paint but with a shorter lifespan and less protection.

5. Benefits of Exterior Paint:

  • Exterior paint is highlighted for offering better protection, durability, and a broader range of color options.
  • It is suggested as the preferred option for surfaces that have already been painted or sealed.

6. Solid Stain vs. Exterior Paint for Decks:

  • The article hints at the choice between painting and staining a deck, emphasizing the need to consider the condition and history of the surface.

7. Contacting Professionals:

  • The article encourages readers to seek advice from experienced painters, like those at Dunbar Painting, to make informed decisions about whether to use solid stain or exterior paint.

In summary, the article provides valuable insights into the characteristics of solid stain, its application, and the considerations for choosing between solid stain and exterior paint based on the specific needs of the surface being coated. The expertise shared in the article reflects a comprehensive understanding of the nuances involved in exterior painting and staining projects.

Solid Stain vs. Exterior Paint (2024)

FAQs

Solid Stain vs. Exterior Paint? ›

Although solid stain has its benefits, paint offers better protection, durability, and a wider range of colour selection. Solid stain fades faster than paint, meaning that you will need to repaint it sooner.

Which is better, exterior paint or solid stain? ›

Neither is better than the other, but they work well in different scenarios. Ultimately, if you want to preserve the natural look of your wood siding or deck, use stain. Stain will highlight the natural wood tones but also accentuate any imperfections. If you prefer a long-term solution, paint is your best option.

Is it better to paint or stain outdoor wood? ›

Staining your home's exterior

Because stain seeps into the wood, it's more protective than a coat of paint, which is a coating that simply sits on the top of the wood. Solid stains look almost identical to paint but are more protective of the wood because they seep into the porous wood fibers.

How long does exterior solid stain last? ›

Solid stains provide a thick, colored film that can be made to match or coordinate with the colors of your home siding. Just like paint, they must be applied in two coats, and they typically retain their strength and color for 4-5 years.

Does exterior paint last longer than stain? ›

Done right, an exterior paint job can last 10 years; stain needs to be reapplied more often, anywhere from two to 10 years, depending on the type of stain. One key to how long an exterior finish lasts is how well the surface is prepared.

Can you put exterior paint over solid stain? ›

Although it is not typically the best choice to apply a solid stain over paint, it is easy to paint over a solid stain, meaning that solid stain is often a good choice for the first couple of years of a new home's or new fence's life.

What are the disadvantages of solid stains? ›

Solid stain will also build up a film, especially after several coats, which can peel, chip, and crack. In addition, solid color stains do not usually contain an anti-fungal agent, and may not protect your wood against water as effectively as the penetrative stains.

Does solid stain peel off? ›

While solid stain can resist fading from the sun, it won't resist eventual cracking, peeling, or blistering. This is especially true if the wood is often wet or in direct sunlight. No matter how good the solid stain or the painter, solid stain will eventually peel and need recoated.

Does solid stain need 2 coats? ›

How Many Coats of Stain Should I Apply? Olympic solid color wood stains require the application of two thin coats for optimum durability. Applying two coats of solid wood stains will also hide wood grain and imperfections.

What exterior paint lasts 20 years? ›

Sherwin-Williams Duration stands out as the longest-lasting exterior paint brand on the market, earning top spots in Consumer Reports for its durability.

Is it better to spray or roll exterior stain? ›

You can combine all the methods to use on your deck. For example, if you have small areas on your deck, like the posts, consider using a brush. If you have a covered deck, try using the roller to reach those high spaces. For your wide surfaces, like the main surface of the deck, consider using the sprayer.

What is the best exterior stain on the market? ›

Top Rated Exterior Stains
  • Ready Seal. Pre-tinted Dark Walnut Semi-transparent Exterior Wood Stain and Sealer (1-Gallon)
  • Cabot. Heat-Reducing Pre-tinted Hampton Gray Solid Exterior Wood Stain and Sealer (1-Gallon)
  • Ready Seal. Pre-tinted Dark Walnut Semi-transparent Exterior Wood Stain and Sealer (5-Gallon)

What is more weather resistant stain or paint? ›

Generally speaking, painting offers superior protection against wear-and-tear as well as damage from weather and moisture. This is contrasted by the tendency for stains to absorb into materials, making wod more susceptible to deterioration.

What type of stain is best for exterior? ›

Oil-based or alkyd stains are designed to penetrate the wood. This highlights the wood grain and offers a more natural appearance for your fence or deck. They protect decks from water damage better than the alternatives.

Is it better to paint or stain a front door? ›

Benefits of Painting a Front Door

If needed, it's also easy to touch up down the road. In very practical terms, painting is also cheaper than staining and typically requires less maintenance and lower costs long-term. Stained doors are stunning, but they definitely require more specialized (and frequent) upkeep.

Does solid stain peel like paint? ›

While solid stain can resist fading from the sun, it won't resist eventual cracking, peeling, or blistering. This is especially true if the wood is often wet or in direct sunlight. No matter how good the solid stain or the painter, solid stain will eventually peel and need recoated.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 5926

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.