This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (2024)

When was the last time you replaced your skillet? Can't remember? This is when to throw away your nonstick pan.

You’ve had it forever hanging above your stove, at the ready. Lately, it’s looking a little worse for the wear—so what’s the big deal?

Nonstick pans are covered using a chemical called Teflon. Teflon makes the pan easy to clean, and allows for cooking without using much butter or oil. The problem? Teflon breaks down and can be cause for concern. Before you toss your nonstick pan, look for these tell-tale signs that you should pick up a replacement.

Sign 1: The Pan Is Warped

Warping is not necessarily dangerous, but it can mean that your food quality won’t be its best. When a pan is warped, your cooking surface will be uneven and your food won’t cook uniformly. To ensure your food is all cooked at the same temperature—and safe for consumption—you may just want to play it safe and chuck the warped pans.

Sign 2: Dark Discoloration

Not all discoloration is bad—it’s caused by food build up over time. Some light discoloration isn’t a big deal, but once it’s dark it could mean the nonstick coating has been damaged. At that point, it’s time to replace the pan.

Sign 3: You See Significant Scratches

Scratches are definitely a deal-breaker—in older pans. Before 2013, pans were manufactured using Teflon that contained a hazardous man-made chemical called Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). PFOAs were proven to contain cancer-causing chemicals, and now Teflon is required to be manufactured without these dangerous compounds. If you see scratches, that means the nonstick Teflon surface has been compromised and the chemicals could be flaking off into your food. Not good! To be safe, once a pan is scratched it’s gotta go.

Nonstick Pans Do Not Last Forever

A good rule of thumb is to replace them approximately every five years. Look at your pans frequently. When they start to appear warped, discolored or scratched, be sure to stop using them. If you’re looking for replacement pans, we have great affordable options in our Taste of Home collection.

Can You Repair Your Nonstick Pan?

You can! You can try a nonstick cookware repair spray—though watch for scratches through the clear spray.Cleaning your nonstick pan with nonabrasive scrubbers and cleaners will help extend their life. When cooking up a creamy, fluffy omelet in your nonstick pan, use utensils like silicone or soft wood that won’t scratch. Finally, store your pans without stacking things on top of them that could scratch the surface.

Next up: What about a cast-iron pan? We’ve got the scoop on when to replace those, too.

Easy Dinners You Can Make in a Skillet

1 / 50

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (1)

Skillet Shepherd’s PieThis is the best shepherd's pie recipe I've ever tasted. It's very quick to make, and I usually have most—if not all—of the ingredients already on hand. It's one of my favoriteone-skillet meals!—Tirzah Sandt, San Diego, CaliforniaGo to Recipe

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (2)

Southwestern Beef and Rice SkilletI like to serve this kicked-up skillet dish with warm flour tortillas and a side of guacamole. If you like things a little spicier, add more jalapeno and enjoy the heat! —Pat Hockett, Ocala, Florida

Chicken Biscuit SkilletMy mother always made this one-dish meal while we were growing up. Now I make it for my own husband and kids. I use the small-size biscuits because they brown up so nicely on top. I also add mushrooms to this recipe sometimes because my family loves 'em. —Keri Boffeli, Monticello, Iowa

Still hungry? Try one of our other savory chicken skillet recipes.

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (4)

Sausage Pierogi SkilletI made this simple pierogies and sausage recipe one night when I hadn’t planned anything for dinner. It’s convenient because it uses items I usually have on hand. Plus, there’s hardly any cleanup! —Susan Held, Cooksville, Maryland

Weeknight Skillet Spinach PieI love sneaking extra veggies into my kids’ dinners, especially with this skillet spinach pie recipe. With a flaky crust and extra cheese, the kids never know they’re eating a vitamin-rich dish and I’m not hovering over an oven for hours. Put the spinach and phyllo sheets in the refrigerator the night before or early in the morning for thawing. —Kristyne McDougle, Lorain, Ohio

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (6)

Vegetarian Farro SkilletFarro is a type of wheat that was popular in ancient Rome. A good source of fiber, it includes more protein than most grains, making it a smart choice for meatless meals like this vegetarian farro skillet dish. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (7)

Autumn Lamb SkilletI have found that even those who do not prefer lamb will enjoy this recipe. It is especially delicious on a chilly night! —Arlene Aughey, Saddle Brook, New Jersey

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (8)

Barley Beef SkilletEven my 3-year-old loves this family-favorite beef barley skillet. It's very filling, inexpensive and packed with veggies. It's also really good spiced up with chili powder, cayenne or a dash of Tabasco. —Kit Tunstall, Boise, Idaho

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (9)

Quick Moroccan Shrimp SkilletWhen my niece was attending West Point, she was sent to Morocco for five months. I threw her a going-away party complete with Moroccan decorations, costumes and cuisine, including this saucy shrimp dish. Whenever I make it now, I think of her and smile. —Barbara Lento, Houston, Pennsylvania

Hash Brown Pork SkilletFor this pork hash recipe, we added potatoes and veggies to leftover tenderloin. It's an easy, creamy weeknight supper in minutes! —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Serve this meal with one of our favorite skillet sides.

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (11)

One-Skillet PastaThis recipe was given to me 25 years ago and remains a family favorite. It's a tasty twist on traditional spaghetti, and making a one-skillet pasta saves time on prep and cleanup, too. —Susan Spence, Lawrenceville, Virginia

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (12)

Sausage Potato SkilletGrowing up, I would eat this sausage and potato skillet recipe almost every day. I could never get enough of my favorite meal! —Amelia Bordas, Springfield, Virginia

Easy Sausage and Vegetable SkilletThis is an old recipe that has been passed down in our family through my sister-in-law. When I was a child, she did most of the cooking in our house, and this was my favorite meal. The variety of vegetables makes this an attractive dish, and the cooking time is minimal. —Ruby Williams, Bogalusa, Louisiana

These easy skillet mealscan be prepped in just 15 minutes!

Skillet Chicken StewIt's been 20 years now since I adapted this from a recipe for beef stew. We like it so much that, in all that time, I have never changed any ingredients or amounts - unless it was to double them! Our home's on a river, and my husband, our three boys and I enjoy camping and boating. — Valerie Jordan, Kingmont, West Virginia

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (15)

Santa Fe SkilletAs a mother who works full-time, I’m always looking for quick, easy, one-skillet meals to prepare. This is a timeless recipe. —Lorie VanHorn, Waddell, Arizona

Low on groceries? Try our favorite 4-ingredient skillet recipes.

Skillet Pork Chops with Apples & OnionSimple recipes that land on the table fast are lifesavers. I serve skillet pork chops with veggies and, when my husband lobbies, cornbread stuffing. —Tracey Karst, Ponderay, Idaho

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (17)

Beefy Tortellini SkilletThis tortellini dish is a one-skillet-wonder the family craves. From browning beef to cooking the pasta and melting the cheese, everything happens in one pan. You can add basil or chives for a touch of freshness. —Juli Meyers, Hinesville, Georgia

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (18)

Chili SkilletLike most farmers, my husband loves a good hearty chili. With all the vegetables, cheese and meat in it, this dish makes a super supper—and it comes together in one skillet on top of the stove. I serve it frequently in fall and winter. —Katherine Brown, Fredericktown, Ohio

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (19)

Chicken Burrito SkilletWe love Mexican night at our house, and I love to re-create dishes from our favorite restaurants. This burrito-inspired dish is ready for the table in almost no time! —Krista Marshall, Fort Wayne, Indiana

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (20)

Peasant SkilletI prepare this supper frequently throughout the year, substituting whatever vegetables are in season. No matter how often I make it, I'm always asked for the recipe. —Lisbeth Whitehead, Watertown, South Dakota

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (21)

Skillet TacosThis fast and healthy alternative to traditional tacos has a delicious southwestern flair. The fact that is comes together in just 30 minutes makes it even more irresistible. —Maria Gobel, Greenfield, Wisconsin

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (22)

Easy Beef Taco SkilletBusy day? Save time and money with this one-dish meal the whole family will love. It calls for handy convenience products, so it can be on the table in minutes. —Kelly Roder, Fairfax, Virginia

Chicken Rice SkilletPleasant seasonings and plenty of vegetables highlight this traditional chicken and rice pairing. Leftovers are great reheated in the microwave. —Jan Balata, Kilkenny, Minnesota

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (24)

Sausage & Vegetable Skillet DinnerI threw this sausage recipe together one night to use up produce before going out of town. Who knew it was going to be such a hit! Now it’s a recipe I turn to whenever time is tight. —Elizabeth Kelley, Chicago, Illinois

One-Skillet Chicken Fajita PastaYou can have this quick, easy fajita pasta on the table in no time. We love the kicked-up Southwestern flavor, and I like being able to make the whole meal in my cast-iron skillet. I sometimes garnish it with crushed corn chips. —Joan Hallford, North Richland Hills, Texas

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (26)

Creamy Skillet Noodles with PeasI’ve made this creamy noodle side for years. Since kids and adults go for it, I keep the ingredients on hand at all times. —Anita Groff, Perkiomenville, Pennsylvania

Maple Sausage SkilletMaple syrup adds sweetness to this yummy stir-fry. I sometimes add a little broccoli, too, for a change of pace. Add a green salad and a crusty loaf of bread for a complete meal in minutes. —Dottie Tarlton, Malvern, Arkansas

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (28)

Beef & Pepper SkilletI love Mexican-inspired food. I also enjoy experimenting with recipes like this one and making them healthier—and downright good! —Jenny Dubinsky, Inwood, West Virginia

One-Skillet Pork Chop SupperMy husband, Clark, and I reserve this recipe for Sundays after the grandkids have gone home and we're too tired to prepare a big meal. It's comforting and quick. —Kathy Thompson, Port Orange, Florida

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (30)

Pierogi Beef SkilletHearty and thick with beef, veggies and potatoes, this is a complete meal in one. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Mexi-Mac SkilletThis is the yummiest, quickest recipe I have. There’s no need to precook the macaroni. Everything comes together in one smart skillet. —Maurane Ramsey, Fort Wayne, Indiana

Cajun Shrimp SkilletThere’s plenty of sauce with these shrimp—I always have some bread on the side to soak it up. Make the dish your own by using your favorite amber beer or flavorful broth. —Mark Oppe, North Pole, Alaska

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (33)

Confetti Kielbasa SkilletHere's one of my husband's favorite dishes. When it's in season, substitute fresh corn for frozen. Add a dash of cayenne pepper if you like a little heat. —Sheila Gomez, Shawnee, Kansas

Sausage and Vegetable SkilletThis hearty stovetop entree has been a family favorite for years. The variety of vegetables makes this dish attractive. Cooking time is minimal. —Ruby Williams, Bogalusa, Louisiana

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (35)

Hearty Skillet SupperWhen the weather starts turning cooler, I start to hear requests for this dish. The light soy, onion and garlic flavors blend nicely with fresh carrots and potatoes in this budget-minded recipe. —Pat Jensen, Cottonwood, Minnesota

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (36)

Grecian Pasta & Chicken SkilletWe love a homemade meal at the end of the day. But the prep involved? Not so much. My Greek-inspired pasta is lemony, herby and, thankfully, easy. —Roxanne Chan, Albany, California

Tasty Turkey SkilletI like using boxed rice and pasta mixes to jump-start quick meals. This colorful dish is simple to cook on the stovetop using fried rice mix, tender turkey and convenient frozen vegetables. —Betty Kleberger, Florissant, Missouri

Skillet Zucchini and SausageI lived on the Oregon coast for 20 years and had plenty of guests dropping by. I often turned to this quick and easy dish, serving it up with skillet cornbread or garlic bread. Judging by the requests for the recipe, everyone loved it! —LaBelle Doster, Vancouver, Washington

Breakfast Pizza SkilletI found the recipe for this hearty stovetop dish several years ago and changed it to fit our tastes. When I served it at a Christmas brunch, it was an instant hit. —Marilyn Hash, Enumclaw, Washington

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (40)

Feta Shrimp SkilletMy husband and I tried a dish similar to this on our honeymoon in Greece. I re-created the flavors in this recipe when we got home. When I make it now, it brings back wonderful memories. —Sonali Ruder, New York, New York

Skillet Ham & RiceHam, rice and mushrooms make a tasty combination in this homey stovetop dish. It goes from start to finish in just 25 minutes. —Susan Zivec, Regina, Saskatchewan

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (42)

Baked Cheddar Eggs & PotatoesI love making breakfast recipes with eggs for dinner, especially this combo with potatoes and cheese that's started in a skillet on the stovetop and then popped into the oven to bake. —Nadine Merheb, Tucson, Arizona

Turkey Biscuit StewThis chunky stew makes a hearty supper, especially in the fall and winter. It'salso a great way to use extra turkey during the holidays. —Lori Schlecht, Wimbledon, North Dakota

Spanish Noodles and Ground BeefBacon adds flavor to this comforting stovetop supper my mom frequently made when we were growing up. Now I prepare it for my family. —Kelli Jones, Peris, California.

Quick Italian Veggie SkilletWhen you don’t know what to serve, Italian flavors are a good starting point. We combine cannellini and garbanzo beans for this snappy rice dish. —Sonya Labbe, West Hollywood, California

Honey Chicken Stir-FryI'm a new mom, and my schedule is very dependent upon our young son, so I like meals that can be ready in as little time as possible. This all-in-one chicken stir fry recipe with a hint of sweetness from honey is a big time-saver. —Caroline Sperry, Allentown, Michigan

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (47)

Cajun Beef & RiceCajun rice from a restaurant or box can have a lot of sodium and fat. Here’s a hearty, healthy way to trim it down. —Raquel Haggard, Edmond, Oklahoma

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (48)

Weeknight Pasta SquigglesThis zesty pasta dish is ideal for busy weeknights. It contains just a few ingredients, is easy to prep, and tastes so comforting when the weather turns cool. A salad on the side makes this healthy pasta recipe a meal. —Stacey Brown, Spring, Texas

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (49)

Hamburger CasseroleThis hamburger casserole recipe is such a hit it's traveled all over the country! My mother originated the recipe in Pennsylvania, I brought it to Texas when I married, I'm still making it in California, and my daughter treats her friends to this oldie in Colorado. It's hearty, yet simple to prepare. —Helen Carmichall, Santee, California

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (50)

Cashew Chicken with GingerThere are lots of recipes for cashew chicken, but my family thinks this one stands alone. We love the flavor from the fresh ginger and the crunch of the cashews. Another plus is it's easy to prepare. —Oma Rollison, El Cajon, California

This When You Need to Replace Your Nonstick Pans (2024)

FAQs

How do you replace non-stick cookware? ›

What About Nonstick Alternatives?
  1. Ceramic Skillets: Touted as the “green” alternative to nonstick, ceramic skillets are made without PFAS. ...
  2. Carbon-Steel Skillets: Traditionally used in many professional kitchens, carbon-steel skillets can be just as nonstick as nonstick and without the questionable chemicals.
Oct 1, 2023

What is the best pan to replace a non-stick pan? ›

Carbon steel pans used to require time and layers of seasoning to get slick, but more pre-seasoned pans are available now, and good ones are great substitutes for nonstick pans. Carbon-steel pans are similar to cast iron pans, in that they're made from a combination of carbon and iron.

What should we use instead of non-stick cookware? ›

Both cast iron and iron cookware enable even heating, which helps to preserve the nutrients in the food. They are, in fact, ideal for preparing traditional cuisines and keeping meals hot for longer periods of time.

Should I throw away old nonstick pans? ›

Peeling, Flaking, and Chipping

A non stick coating that's peeling, chipped, flaking, or otherwise damaged is a sure sign that your pan should be replaced. Once the pan's coating starts to come off, it will only continue to do so, contributing to the loss of its non stick quality.

Are non stick pans still unhealthy? ›

Health agencies have raised concerns about the compound PFOA, which was previously used to make Teflon. However, Teflon has been PFOA-free since 2013. Today's nonstick and Teflon cookware is considered safe for everyday home cooking, as long as temperatures do not exceed 500°F (260°C).

When to replace pans? ›

For a home cook, a decent set of cookware should last between five and ten years, depending on the frequency of cooking. "The best type of material to use in general is stainless steel, with the exception of using non-stick for omelets," explains Scott Clarke, a chef and owner of Blue Monkey Catering.

What is the No 1 non stick pan? ›

Tramontina Professional fry pan

Tramontina's 10-inch skillet takes the top spot for the best budget nonstick fry pan. You can find cheaper pans, but none of them match Tramontina's excellent combination of nonstick surfaces, even heating and a comfy handle.

Why I don't use non stick pans? ›

Teflon is produced from chemicals that are part of an enormous family of chemicals known as perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroakyl substances, or PFAS, and research has linked exposure to them to many health conditions, including certain cancers, reproductive issues, and high cholesterol.

Can you still use a burnt non stick pan? ›

If you've tried both methods of cleaning and the burnt food or residue still remains stuck to the surface of your pan, it may be time to replace it. Once the non stick coating of the pan has started to break down, it will only continue to do so, making it easier and easier for food to stick to its surface.

What is the safest non stick material for cookware? ›

If you're looking for predominantly nonstick cookware, make sure to read the labels — nonstick ceramic is a fantastic option for toxin-free cookware that is slick enough to cook even the stickiest foods. The safest options shouldn't contain any PFAs and should be PFOA-free.

What is the lifespan of a non stick pan? ›

While most non-stick pans can last up to three years (read the manufacturer's instructions) if used and taken care of properly, poor-quality non-stick pans can start feeling sticky in under 6 months.

Is it safe to use scratched nonstick pans? ›

You should avoid using any scratched or dented nonstick pan to avoid exposure to potentially toxic chemicals. “It can be very difficult for consumers to understand which pans have 'forever chemical' coatings,” says Pelch.

How do I know when I need new pans? ›

If the pan rocks, it has likely rounded or warped. This rounding can cause cooking hot spots because the pan can no longer retain full contact with a heat source and food may burn. Weak or loose joints on a pan can allow liquid to leak out while cooking. Carefully examine all handles and rivets.

Can you burn off non stick pans? ›

There are two ways non stick pans can get burnt: dry heating and overheating. Dry heating occurs when you expose your pan to heat for extended periods of time with nothing in it. To avoid dry heating, always add cooking fat or other ingredients to your pan before turning the heat on.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Clemencia Bogisich Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5740

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Clemencia Bogisich Ret

Birthday: 2001-07-17

Address: Suite 794 53887 Geri Spring, West Cristentown, KY 54855

Phone: +5934435460663

Job: Central Hospitality Director

Hobby: Yoga, Electronics, Rafting, Lockpicking, Inline skating, Puzzles, scrapbook

Introduction: My name is Clemencia Bogisich Ret, I am a super, outstanding, graceful, friendly, vast, comfortable, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.