Courtesy: Patrick J. Donmoyer
Pennsylvania Dutch hex signs are an example of cultural heritage in Albany Township, thought to have the most decorated barns in Pennsylvania. Once viewed as evidence of superstition, hex signs are now widely viewed as decorative.
Dr. Henry W. Shoemaker, chief of the folklore division of the Pennsylvania Historical & Museum Commission, answered the question 59 years ago.
Albany Township, in the northeast corner of Berks County, he told the Associated Press, had the most numerous and most elaborately designed hex signs in Pennsylvania.
Shoemaker's declaration was reported in the Reading Eagle on July 24, 1954.
A founder of the Pennsylvania Folklore Society, Shoemaker argued that the hex signs on barns in Albany and other parts of Berks suggested a belief in superstition.
"Don't let anyone kid you, those hex signs on Pennsylvania Dutch barns are not just there for decoration," Shoemaker said. "The old folks may tell you they don't believe in the old superstitions, but deep down in their hearts they do."
Shoemaker's assertions have been challenged by researchers, including Patrick J.Donmoyer of the Pennsylvania German Cultural Heritage Center at Kutztown University.
In "Hex Signs: Myth and Meaning in Pennsylvania Dutch Barn Stars," Donmoyer argues that hex signs were not intended to protect barns from witchcraft.
Donmoyer also believes that the preserve of barns with hex signs in neighboring Greenwich Township equals, if not exceeds, those in Albany.
"H.W. Shoemaker was a political appointee whose statements have been largely discredited," Donmoyer said.
In 1954, Shoemaker acknowledged hex signs were being copied and sold as decorations.
He insisted, however, their connection with witchcraft, spells and hexing could not be doubted.
Shoemaker claimed to have observed hex symbols carved into the beams of log barns built by the first wave of immigrants from Germany, Switzerland and France who settled in Pennsylvania. Later, when boards replaced logs as siding, hex signs were painted on barns.
"There was no idea of decoration in those early days," Shoemaker contended.
He said the points on star-shaped hex signs represent needles on which an evil spirit entering a barn would be caught.
A black hand made of metal and attached to a barn door was to warn witches from entering.
Netherlands Dutch used the spelling of "hechs," which was changed to "hex" by Germans.
"In German, 'die hexe' means 'the witch,' " Shoemaker said.
By the mid-1950s, the descendants of the early Pennsylvania Dutch settlers had pretty much abandoned superstition, he conceded.
"In these days, the symbols can't even keep away the thieves," said Shoemaker, whose hex sign-adorned Clinton County barn had been broken into several times.
"Superstition has much less to do with it than formerly," he said. "Still, everyone wants to keep his old symbols - I wouldn't let mine go."
Ron Devlin's History Book is a weekly feature highlighting people, places and topics from Berks County's past. Is there something that you're curious about? Pose the question to Ron Devlin at 610-371-5030 or rdevlin@readingeagle.com.