Do Fat People Stay Warmer in Cold Weather Than Thin People? | The Weather Channel (2024)

By Allie Goolrick

January 04, 2014

There may be a reason that Santa, who spends most of his time toiling away at his freezing North Pole workshop or traversing the globe in an open-air sled, is a little on the rotund side. A bowl full of jelly may actually help to defend people against cold weather — at least to a certain extent.

It’s not the most politically correct of questions to ponder to be sure, but Popular Science recently shed some light onto whether fat people stay warmer in the cold than thin people, and the answer is both yes and no.

According to Popular Science, studies done on both cold-water swimmers and hospital patients have shown that people with a higher Body Mass Index (BMI) are less susceptible to hypothermia because fat insulates the body’s core.

(MORE: Do You Live in the Fattest State)

That’s not surprising, considering that fat certainly plays an important part of thermal regulation in animals. Whales have a layer of blubber that is vital to insulating them against cold water, while camels, which live in hot climates, hold all of their fat in their humps to avoid all-over insulation, reports Discovery Magazine.

In humans, thermoregulation gets a bit more complicated.

Because of complex signaling in the brain in response to cold weather, people with a higher BMI may in fact have the sense of feeling colder.

Here’s how it all works: When the outside temperature drops, our brains trigger our bodies to respond by interpreting two signals, internal body temperature and the temperature on the surface of the skin. According to Scientific American, when blasted with a winter chill, our blood vessels constrict, limiting our heat loss through the skin, and we start to shiver, which warms us up.

Advertisem*nt

But in people with a higher BMI, subcutaneous fat effectively insulates the body’s core, while the skin cools. According to Catherine O’Brien, a research physiologist with the U.S. Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine, a cooler skin temperature may make obese people feel colder in response.

(MORE: 50 States' Biggest Snow Days)

Of course, subcutaneous fat isn’t the only factor that affects humans’ temperature. If you are relatively fit and seem to "run hot," there’s an explanation for that: Muscle tissue generates heat, offering a different protection from the cold. If you’re relatively petite, not only does a low BMI heighten your response to cold, but so does your overall surface area. According to O’Brien, smaller people lose heat more quickly.

The combination of lower muscle mass and higher surface area in women provides some much-needed insight about the age-old stereotype that the female population is always cold (so next time the lady in your life asks for your jacket, don’t hesitate to hand it over).

But overall, which is better for handling cold weather, being slightly on the hefty side or thinner?

“We have a joke around here that the person who’s best-suited for cold is fit and fat,” O’Brien told PopSci.

MORE ON WEATHER.COM: New York City Polar Bear Swim

Do Fat People Stay Warmer in Cold Weather Than Thin People? | The Weather Channel (2)

Do Fat People Stay Warmer in Cold Weather Than Thin People? | The Weather Channel (2024)

FAQs

Do Fat People Stay Warmer in Cold Weather Than Thin People? | The Weather Channel? ›

Smaller, thinner, people have a large surface area relative to their body mass compared with bigger, more thickset people. This means that they lose heat and feel the cold more easily than those who are chubbier. It's particularly important to remember this when you're out in cold weather with small children.

Do fat people stay warmer in cold weather? ›

According to Popular Science, studies done on both cold-water swimmers and hospital patients have shown that people with a higher Body Mass Index (BMI) are less susceptible to hypothermia because fat insulates the body's core.

Are skinny people more sensitive to cold weather? ›

Some people (often very thin women) do not tolerate cold temperatures because they have very little body fat to help keep them warm.

Are you warmer with more body fat? ›

Fatness was linked to lower heat loss, lower heat production, higher core temperature, lower heat debt, and higher tissue insulation [3].

Are people skinnier in warmer climates? ›

The Bergmann's Rule and Allen's Rule suggest that populations living in colder climates tend to have larger body masses and shorter limbs to minimize heat loss, while those in warmer climates have slimmer bodies and longer limbs to facilitate heat dissipation.

What does cold weather do to fat? ›

Research has confirmed that being outdoors in the cold can transform white fat into calorie-burning brown fat.

Does fat insulate your body? ›

Benefits of Adipose Tissue

Insulation: Adipose tissue helps to insulate your body. This heat insulation keeps your body warm when you are exposed to cold temperatures. 5. Protection: Adipose tissue cushions and protects your organs, bones, and other tissues from damage.

Who feels more cold, thin, or fat? ›

Thin people's subcutaneous layer lacks adipose tissue, but fat people's subcutaneous layer contains adipose tissue, which functions as an insulator and keeps the body warm. As a result, thin people feel colder than fat people.

Do you get colder if you are skinnier? ›

Muscle activity generates heat, and fat acts as insulation. If you have lost significant weight recently or have always been thin, you might be more sensitive to colder temperatures. Skipping meals. Some people get cold when they miss meals or consume too few calories.

Are skinny people more likely to get sick? ›

If a person does not get enough energy from their diet to maintain a healthy body weight, they may also not be getting enough nutrients to fight off infections. As a result, a person may get sick more frequently, and common illnesses, such as a cold, can last longer than they usually would.

Does belly fat keep you warm? ›

The biological process of metabolism, fueled by eating fat, or any other type of food for that matter, may make you feel warmer. However, simply consuming fat or having more fat on your body hasn't been shown to improve insulation in cold weather.

Can being overweight make you hot all the time? ›

The more obese you are, the less skin surface you have for each pound of body weight. The result: less cooling power.

Will I be warmer if I gain weight? ›

Mark Brumm, M.D., Family Medicine in Mayo Clinic Health System – Franciscan Healthcare says, “There is some evidence that a small amount of subcutaneous (between skin and muscle) fat may reduce the amount of heat you lose, but it is not enough to keep you warmer.

Are fat people more resilient to cold? ›

Humans with obesity cool less rapidly and have to elevate their metabolism less significantly than lean individuals when immersed in water. Although obesity provides an advantage in cold conditions it conversely impedes heat loss and makes obese people susceptible to heat stress more than lean individuals.

Are people skinnier in the summer? ›

Heat can reduce appetite

As a result, you may feel less hungry in hot weather. Additionally, it has been observed that food digestion slows down in hotter temperatures, which can make you feel fuller for longer. This is good news if you struggle with overeating and weight control.

What keeps you warmer, muscle or fat? ›

A person with a significant amount of lean body mass (particularly muscle) has an advantage in the cold. Muscle generates a lot of heat, provides thermal insulation and contributes to a high rate of metabolism at rest.

Does being overweight increase body temperature? ›

Overall, our results suggest that the increase body area of obese subjects does not influence significantly their temperature.

Does fat help regulate body temperature? ›

Brown fat breaks down blood sugar (glucose) and fat molecules to create heat and help maintain body temperature. Cold temperatures activate brown fat, which leads to various metabolic changes in the body. Most of our fat, however, is white fat, which stores extra energy.

Do people in colder climates weigh more? ›

The swing from summer to fall and soon, winter, can make some people vulnerable to gaining weight, experts say. The colder months can lead to people getting less physical activity and instead staying inside with high-sugar comfort foods.

Does losing weight make you less hot? ›

This is normal. The hormonal changes can affect your body temperature. Also, people who have high blood pressure due to being overweight tend to feel warmer than they would with a normal blood pressure. When their blood pressure lowers as a result of their change in eating habits and weight loss they may feel colder.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6033

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.