Food Coloring for Baking 101: Fundamentals, Tips & Tricks (2024)

We’ve all ended up with cake batter a few shades too dark once upon a time, or perfectly colored but thinned out icing, because we added one drop too much or used the wrong style of food coloring. All these colorfullittle bottles and jars can be confusing if you’re new to this, but we’re here to help you and tell you all you need to know about food coloring. So let’s talk about colors!

First Things First…

There are 7 types of food coloring that are all suitable to be used with different recipes or mixtures and that will give different color intensities. We will first discuss these various styles and how/when to use them.

Liquid Food Coloring.

Food Coloring for Baking 101: Fundamentals, Tips & Tricks (1)

Typical liquid food coloring that can be found in most supermarket or grocery stores.

Liquid coloring is made using synthetic coloringand a water base. It is watery and as such the colors are not very concentrated. It is a good choice if you wish to achieve pastel colors, but you are after a stronger or darker color you would need to add a significant amount, which will thin out your mixture. Liquid food coloring is best used with other liquid medium such as syrup, water, chocolate, etc.

*Chefmaster's Candy Colors for fat-based products (such as candy melts or chocolates) are in liquid form, andareoften referredto as Liquid Candy Colors by most bakers.

Level: Beginner

Difficulty: 1

Best for: Pastel colors

Use with: Icing, batter, dough

Liqua-Gel

Food Coloring for Baking 101: Fundamentals, Tips & Tricks (2)

Chefmaster® Liqua-Gel 12 Color Kit

Liqua-Gel is also water based but contains glycerine and corn syrup, which makes it a semi-thick gel and concentrated form of food coloring. If it’s the first time you use Liqua-Gel, it is always best to start by adding one drop at a time, mixing it well and then adding another drop if needed. This way you will avoid ending up with a darker than desired color. This is the type of coloring that you can use with practically any recipe (except chocolate), as it’s not likely to affect the consistency of your mixture, but it’s also not as thick as Gel Paste and therefore easier to use.

Chefmaster Liqua-Gel® is very popular due to its versatileuses and applications. You can practically use Liqua-Gel for most recipe, except for fat-based product such as chocolate.

Level: Beginner to Intermediate

Difficulty: 2

Best for: Strong vibrant or darker colors

Use with: Icing, fondant, gum paste, batter, cake frosting

Gel Food Coloring

Gel or gel paste food coloring is much thicker than Liqua-Gel and the colors are even more concentrated and more vibrant. However it is more tricky to use as it’s very easy to add a bit too much coloring. In fact the best way to add it to your mix is by collecting a teeny tiny amount using a toothpick, incorporating it into your mix, letting it rest for 10-15 mins and then repeating if needed. Gel colors become deeper with time, that is why it’s important to let the mixture rest and see how it changes before adding more color. Because of its consistency, it is ideal for coloring large batches of icing or dough at a time.

Level: Intermediate to Advanced

Difficulty: 4

Best for: Strong vibrant or darker colors

Use with: Large batches of batter or icing

Powder Food Coloring

Powder food coloring is a completely dry form of food dye with no liquid. It is perfect for mixes that are sensitive to the amount of added liquid such as chocolate or macarons. It is important to know that it does not mix with water, so it must be mixed with a few drops of clear alcohol, or if you’re incorporating it into the batter add a few drops of alcohol into the mixture. It can also be used dry to brush directly onto food as decoration. Due to its dry consistency, it is not very easy to incorporate into thick batter, and adding too much can dry out a mix. Allow the mixture to sit 5-10 mins after incorporating the dye in order to let the color fully develop.

Level: Intermediate

Difficulty: 3

Best for: Darker colors

Use with: Crystal sugar, chocolates, meringues, macarons

Natural Food Coloring

Food Coloring for Baking 101: Fundamentals, Tips & Tricks (3)

Chefmaster® Natural Food Colors. These are all plant-based food coloring.

Natural food coloringare made using dyes commonly found in nature, such as chlorophyll which gives plants their green color, or turmeric which is a plant commonly found in India and used for yellow coloring. This is the best choice of coloring for anyone with allergies and for health conscious people. Due to the relatively low heat resistance of the natural ingredients, it is best used with low/no heat desserts and toppings.

Natural Food Coloring are most commonly found in powder form. Most powder natural food coloring will fade within 24 hours when they are exposed to sunlight. Chefmaster's Natural Food Coloringisformulated to have better stability and will hold its colors much longer than other coloring on the market.

Level: Beginner to Intermediate

Difficulty: 2

Best for: Subtle, earthy colors

Use with: Low heat/no heat desserts and toppings

Oil-Based Food Coloring

Chefmaster's Candy Colors are formulated liquid food coloring that bind to oil-based products such as chocolate, candy melts & any fat-based/oil-based products.This type of food coloring is specialized to work withfat-based recipes where adding water would affect the mixture.

*Never use regular food coloring with chocolate, because the water content will "seize" & ruin your chocolate.

Level: Beginner to Intermediate

Difficulty: 2

Best for: Strong vibrant or darker colors

Use with: Chocolate, hard candy, icing

Airbrush Food Colors

A simple airbrush application by Chefmaster's Customer.

Airbrush food coloring is similar to Liqua-Gel in terms of ingredients but has a different viscosity. It is designed to be thinner specifically to be used with an airbrush compressor machine. This method is perfect for creating more artistic effects on fondant, dry icing, cookies or cakes using different colors. Just remember to clean your airbrush gun after each use to ensure the colors don’t mix.

Level: Intermediate to Advanced

Difficulty: 4

Best for: Strong vibrant or darker colors

Use with: Fondant, dry icing, cookies

But that’s not all!

It isn’t enough just to know the different styles of food coloring and the techniques of how to apply them, there are other factors that affect the final color you will end up with, even if you are following a specific color recipe.

Ingredients

The original color of your mixture will not always be white due to the presence of butter and/or eggs, which would make it more of a light yellow, think buttercream or cake batter. This means that if you add blue coloring it might end up more on the slightly green side, because blue mixed with yellow turns green. To solve this start by adding some white coloring in order to turn your mix white, and then proceed with adding the desired color.

Acidic ingredients such as lemon juice, vinegar or cream of tartar can also affect your final color, making brown colors in particular look slightly greenish, while violet might appear blue. It’s best to leave these ingredients out of recipes if you can.

Finally, if you’re trying to achieve a really dark color such as black or a very dark brown, it is best to start with a darker base such as chocolate buttercream or cake batter, this way you will need less food coloring.

Light

It is always best to use natural light when coloring. Artificial light, especially yellow, will change the way you see colors and you might end up with a different result to what you were hoping for. But while it is great to have natural light during the decoration process, once you’re done make sure you store your creation (and any left over icing) away from it, as the contact with natural light will cause colors to fade over time.

Resting time

When coloringicing or fondant, it is best to let it rest for 1-2 hours, as the colordevelops with time. For Buttercream and Fondant, colorswill deepen over time as they dry, so it’s better to stop at a shade or two lighter than needed. For Royal icing, colors will lighten as it dries, so it’s better to make it a shade or two darker than needed.

Patience

As a general rule, if you don’t know exactly how much food coloring you will need, start by adding your dye one drop at a time, mixing it well, letting it rest and then repeat until you reach the desired color. It is never a good idea to rush and add multiple drops at a time.

And if you want to create your own color, make sure you keep track of the number of drops used for each colorso you can recreate it again!

*Did you enjoy the article above? Leave a comment below to let us know :)

Related Articles

5 Quick & Easy Halloween Treats

Top 6 Popular Icing Recipes

Tips & Guides to Natural Food Coloring

Happy Reading!

Food Coloring for Baking 101: Fundamentals, Tips & Tricks (2024)

FAQs

Do you add food coloring before or after baking? ›

Stir coloring into batter for baked goods.

You should add the dye to the wet ingredients so you don't accidentally overmix the batter which would make the food tough. The color of some baked goods might change as they bake, so batter that looks really bright may end up being a shade paler after it cooks.

How do you use food coloring in baking? ›

There are many ways to use it: add a pinch of the powder to your dry mixture or combine it with a few drops of clear alcohol for a paint-like consistency. You can even dust it onto foods to create a gentle finish. Powdered dye is best to use in recipes that are sensitive to any added liquid, like chocolate or macarons.

What food coloring do professional bakers use? ›

Wilton colours have often been quite iconic in the baking world for really good quality and strong colours – and I really love the basic set that you can buy!

Does food coloring mix better with hot or cold water? ›

Thermal Energy is the total energy of the particles in an object. When placed into water, food coloring will begin to mix with the water. The food coloring will mix the fastest in the hot water because the molecules are moving fast due to their increased thermal energy.

Does food coloring affect the ingredients in baking? ›

The Chelsweetscreator notes that “adding food coloring can sometimes cause people to over mix batter as they work to distribute the color, and this can cause batter or dough to toughen up and lead to large air pockets in the baked product.” To avoid this baking folly, White recommends incorporating the coloring into ...

How do you add food coloring to batter? ›

Rub a small amount of color on a toothpick or a small drop if using a liquid color. Remember it doesn't take a lot to get a nice color, so just start with a touch at first. Blend the color into your batter until well combined. Pour in your greased prepared pan and bake as usual.

How do you list food coloring in ingredients? ›

On a product label, the ingredients are listed in order of predominance, with the ingredients used in the greatest amount first, followed in descending order by those in smaller amounts. The label must list the names of any FDA-certified color additives (e.g., FD&C Blue No. 1 or the abbreviated name, Blue 1).

Can you use too much food coloring? ›

Consuming too much food dye containing contaminants could pose a health risk. However, with the exception of Red 3, there is currently no convincing evidence that artificial food dyes cause cancer. Nevertheless, note that most of the studies evaluating the safety of food dyes were performed decades ago.

What is the best food coloring to color cake batter? ›

Gel paste dye is very effective in dyeing a large amount of batter (like cake batters) and produces dark, saturated colors.

What colors are best for a baking business? ›

For cakes, colors with excellent heat stability should be used to sustain extended bake times. These can include Naturbrown® apple, class I caramels, turmeric, Emulsitech® beta-carotene, annatto, and carmine for a range of browns, reds, oranges, and yellows – the most common colors for baked goods.

What is the formula for food coloring? ›

Tartrazine | C16H9N4Na3O9S2 | CID 164825 - PubChem.

Is gel food coloring better than liquid? ›

Unlike liquid food colours, gel food colours bring brilliance and clarity of colour without the addition of a lot of unnecessary liquid. Only a few drops of gel colour will give you a the same, or better result than a teaspoon of liquid colour.

Is gel food coloring better for cookies? ›

Gel food coloring is great to use in frostings or icings for bright colors, red velvet cupcakes, and candy. It is not good for using in dying cookie doughs because it is so concentrated, it is hard to blend.

What is the golden rule in baking? ›

"My golden rule for baking is make it cold and bake it hot," she said.

What are 3 common baking mistakes? ›

Common Baking Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
  • Baking at the wrong temperature. ...
  • Not measuring ingredients. ...
  • Checking on your items too frequently. ...
  • Your ingredients are at the wrong temperature. ...
  • Your dough isn't rising. ...
  • Nothing is baking evenly. ...
  • Your dough or batter is too tough.

What are the don'ts in baking? ›

Baking Measuring Do's and Don'ts
  • DO get yourself a set of proper measuring cups and spoons. ...
  • DON'T use liquid measuring cups with dry ingredients. ...
  • DO read and follow directions carefully. ...
  • DON'T use your measuring cup to scoop out flour. ...
  • DO pack brown sugar into measuring cups and spoons.

How do you dissolve food coloring? ›

Vinegar is one of the ingredients that helps to remove food coloring from fabrics as well as skin. You can combine vinegar with baking soda, laundry detergent, or liquid dishwashing liquid for an extra boost to remove food coloring.

What happens when you drop food coloring in water? ›

In hot water, the food coloring diffuses (spreads out) through the water quickly. In cold water, the food coloring diffuses (spreads out) through the water slowly. The hot water causes the food coloring to diffuse faster. At higher temperatures, particles move faster.

What do you observe after adding the food coloring? ›

Observence after adding the food coloring

A visible tasty food is more likely to get the attraction of the eater. When a certain food colour is added or say food colouring is done the food item on which it is done turns up into to the colour that we have added which can or cannot be achieved by simple cooking.

What are the disadvantages of food coloring? ›

Synthetic food color dyes can destroy the nutrients in the food because of their chemical composition. They can also cause skin irritation and eczema, a type of skin rash, etc. Artificial food colors can also cause intestinal upset and breathing problems.

What are 3 negative effects that have been linked to artificial food coloring? ›

Potential side effects may include:
  • Hyperactivity, including ADHD.
  • Behavioral changes like irritability and depression.
  • Allergic reaction.
  • Hives and asthma.
  • Sneezing.
  • Watery eyes.
  • Skin irritation.
  • Migraines.
Mar 8, 2023

What adds color flavor and texture to baked foods? ›

Milk is used in baked products to improve texture and mouthfeel. The protein in milk also gives a soft crumb structure in cakes, and contributes to the moisture, colour and flavour of a baked product.

How much food coloring to add to cake batter? ›

As a general rule, if you don't know exactly how much food coloring you will need, start by adding your dye one drop at a time, mixing it well, letting it rest and then repeat until you reach the desired color. It is never a good idea to rush and add multiple drops at a time.

Is it fine to put food coloring in cake batter? ›

Liquid Coloring

It is thin in consistency (like water). In turn, many bakeries avoid using it because it can thin out a cake batter or frosting. As long as you're using it in small amounts, you shouldn't have any problems.

How do you mix flour and food coloring? ›

Mix the Flour with Food Coloring

Add the flour to a clear bowl and mix it using your hands or a whisk. (You can wear gloves to avoid making a mess.) Then, start adding drops of food coloring to the flour. The more you use, the more intense your color powder will look.

What is the safest food coloring? ›

Nine synthetic dyes are approved to use in food by the FDA, but Red 40, Yellow 5, and Yellow 6 are the ones you'll see on labels the most. Natural food colors are mostly derived from plants including vegetables and fruit, such as beet juice (red or pink) and turmeric (yellow).

What are the 5 main food groups coloring? ›

How MyPlate Works. MyPlate has sections for vegetables, fruits, grains, and protein foods, as well as a "cup" on the side for dairy. Color-coded sections — green for veggies, red for fruits, orange for grains, purple for protein, and blue for dairy — show at a glance how much of these foods to eat.

Which food dyes to avoid? ›

Food Dyes. Commonly used food dyes, such as Yellow 5, Yellow 6, and Red 40, pose risks including behavioral problems and hyperactivity in some children. Some dyes also pose a risk of cancer (like Red 3) and allergic reactions (like Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Red 40, Blue 1).

Why should we avoid food coloring? ›

Sure, artificial food colorings make foods look brighter and more appealing, but at what cost? Consumer watchdog CSPI says food dyes can cause everything from hyperactivity and allergic reactions to cancer, and is calling for the government to ban three of the most common dyes.

Why is Red 40 banned in Europe? ›

Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5 food dyes

They have been theorized to exacerbate attentional problems in children, leading EU regulators to mandate that product makers say dyes could cause 'an adverse effect on activity and attention in children.

How many drops of food coloring should I use? ›

some food coloring tips: Always start with ONE drop and add more as needed. While some colors take a lot of drops, you can always add more, you can't take it away (if you do go too far, add more frosting to lighten).

Does food coloring affect taste of cake? ›

The first reason food coloring might affect the taste of your product is the quantity that is being used and added to your icing or batter. More often than not, this happens when you are using liquid food coloring in order to get a dark or strong color such as coloring your icing red.

What food coloring is best for cookie dough? ›

Food Gel Colors-I prefer AmeriColor and Wilton but you can use what you are comfortable with. Just make sure not to use a liquid color like you buy at the grocery stores. It will mess with the consistency of your dough.

What is the colour code for bakery? ›

#5C3317 (Bakers Brown) HTML Color Code.

What are some fun facts about food coloring? ›

Americans are consuming five times as much food dye today as they did in 1955. Artificial colors Red 40, Yellow 5, and Yellow 6 are the most widely used food dyes. Americans are consuming five times as much food dye today as they did in 1955.

What is food coloring number 3? ›

Red No. 3 dye, also known as erythrosine, is a synthetic dye derived from petroleum, and it's used in food and drinks to give them a bright cherry-red color.

What is red dye 40 called in food? ›

What is red dye 40? Red dye 40 — also known as Allura Red AC, red 40, and red No. 40 — is an artificial coloring that's added to processed foods, medications, and cosmetics. In fact, a 2016 research article in Clinical Pediatrics suggests it's the most commonly used artificial food coloring in grocery items.

What is the best food coloring for buttercream? ›

To color your buttercream frosting, you're going to need food-grade dyes. I recommend gel colors over traditional food coloring, and there are two types of colors I primarily use: the Wilton Color Right Color System and AmeriColor.

What food coloring is used in cake? ›

Gel food coloring or liquid-gel food coloring is perfect for baking and cake decorating. Highly concentrated and vibrant, gel food dye offers a consistent color tone without changing the flavor or texture of the cake, frosting, cookie, fondant, or other product.

How many drops of gel food coloring to use? ›

Gel colors are very saturated so start with 1-2 drops at a time to achieve your desired color. This will help avoid ending up with a darker shade than desired. With most of our liquid gels, desired color can be achieved in 3-4 drops.

What is the best food coloring for sugar cookie icing? ›

The best type of food coloring to use is gel paste or liquid-gel. My favorites are Wilton Color Right black, Chefmaster Black Diamond, and Chefmaster Coal Black. I also like to mix in a little powdered food coloring, which makes the black darker without adding more liquid to the icing.

Does food coloring change color after baking? ›

Once they're mixed with your batter or dough or baked in the oven, the color can change drastically.

What order do you put ingredients in baking? ›

The general rule of baking, whether it be cookie dough, cake mix or pancake batter, is as follows: dry ingredients should be combined together thoroughly in one bowl BEFORE adding liquids. Liquid ingredients should ALWAYS be mixed separately before they've been added to the dry ingredients.

Does food coloring darken when baked? ›

For Buttercream and Fondant, colors will deepen over time as they dry, so it's better to stop at a shade or two lighter than needed. For Royal icing, colors will lighten as it dries, so it's better to make it a shade or two darker than needed.

Does food coloring affect baking? ›

The Chelsweetscreator notes that “adding food coloring can sometimes cause people to over mix batter as they work to distribute the color, and this can cause batter or dough to toughen up and lead to large air pockets in the baked product.” To avoid this baking folly, White recommends incorporating the coloring into ...

How do you add food coloring to cake batter? ›

Rub a small amount of color on a toothpick or a small drop if using a liquid color. Remember it doesn't take a lot to get a nice color, so just start with a touch at first. Blend the color into your batter until well combined. Pour in your greased prepared pan and bake as usual.

What is the best food coloring for cake batter? ›

Gel paste dye is very effective in dyeing a large amount of batter (like cake batters) and produces dark, saturated colors.

What is the most important rule in baking? ›

1 Get Your Flour Power on

This is the most important tip when it comes to knowing how to bake cookies. You MUST measure the flour correctly. Adding too much flour will make your cookies tough and dry. In fact, you should reduce the flour by 1/4 cup!

What are the three most important ingredients in baking? ›

5 Most Essential Baking Ingredients
  1. Flour. Due to its versatility in baking—it can be used to make everything from cookies to pancakes to muffins—all-purpose flour is appropriately termed. ...
  2. Leaveners. ...
  3. Sugar. ...
  4. Salt. ...
  5. Dairy.
Jul 25, 2022

What two colors make pink with food coloring? ›

Red and white mixed together make pink. The amount of each color you add affects the shade of pink you end up with. So more white will give you a lighter pink, whereas more red will give you a darker pink. That means that pink is actually a tint, not a pure color.

Why isn't my red velvet red? ›

The trick to using our Red Velvet Color when baking cakes and cupcakes is to lower the pH. Some ways to do this is by substituting baking powder in place of baking soda, using a natural non-alkalized cocoa powder, adding more white vinegar or buttermilk to your red velvet recipe, to achieve a bright red color.

Which baking ingredient adds flavor color and helps baked goods to caramelize? ›

Baking soda also helps with browning and flavor. Because it is alkaline, it encourages the Maillard reaction, or chemical process responsible for creating that golden color and caramelized flavor that make everything taste better.

What colour is best for baking? ›

For cakes, colors with excellent heat stability should be used to sustain extended bake times. These can include Naturbrown® apple, class I caramels, turmeric, Emulsitech® beta-carotene, annatto, and carmine for a range of browns, reds, oranges, and yellows – the most common colors for baked goods.

What problems can food coloring cause? ›

Potential side effects may include:
  • Hyperactivity, including ADHD.
  • Behavioral changes like irritability and depression.
  • Allergic reaction.
  • Hives and asthma.
  • Sneezing.
  • Watery eyes.
  • Skin irritation.
  • Migraines.
Mar 8, 2023

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edmund Hettinger DC

Last Updated:

Views: 5866

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edmund Hettinger DC

Birthday: 1994-08-17

Address: 2033 Gerhold Pine, Port Jocelyn, VA 12101-5654

Phone: +8524399971620

Job: Central Manufacturing Supervisor

Hobby: Jogging, Metalworking, Tai chi, Shopping, Puzzles, Rock climbing, Crocheting

Introduction: My name is Edmund Hettinger DC, I am a adventurous, colorful, gifted, determined, precious, open, colorful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.