Fresh vs. Frozen Peaches: When to Use Them (2024)

Peach season is short, but good news: It's possible to substitute frozen or canned peaches for fresh ones. Use our guidelines to decide when you can make the swap.

It’s hard to beat a fresh-off-the-tree peach. When timed correctly, these peaches are tender, juicy and full-flavored. Unfortunately, an underripe peach presents the exact opposite experience. Grocery store peaches are pale and lifeless in the winter, presenting you with a tasteless, unnecessarily crispy bite.

Luckily, you have options if you want to make your favorite peach recipes when the fruit isn’t in season. Alternatively, if you have a go-to peach dessertor savory recipe that calls for canned peaches, it’s possible to make it with fresh or frozen peaches. While each type of peach is best suited for certain recipes, it’s easy to make substitutions if you understand the difference between the three.

When to Use Fresh Peaches

Depending on where you live, fresh peaches are in season between May and late September. They’re ideal for any recipe that calls for fresh fruit, especially when the fruit is enjoyed raw. The texture of a fresh peach is firmer and less mushy compared to frozen or canned peaches, so they’re the way to go for grilled peach or fruit salad recipes. Baked goods with peaches have a more vibrant color and robust texture compared to the same recipe made with preserved peaches.

Most fresh peach recipes call for peeling, slicing and pitting the fruit before cutting it into halves or slices. This does add to the prep time, but peeling peaches is truly easy when you know how. If you’re substituting fresh peaches for canned or frozen, plan on three medium peaches, 2-1/4 cups chopped or 3 cups sliced peaches for every can or pound in the recipe.

What to Make with Fresh Peaches

When to Use Frozen Peaches

Frozen peaches are uncooked—just like fresh peaches—so they’re a perfect substitute for fresh produce when it’s out of season. They’re particularly great for smoothies, but you can use frozen peaches in any baked recipe as well. Some cooks prefer to work with frozen peaches (even during peach season) because they’re already peeled and pitted, so they require significantly less prep time.

To substitute frozen peaches for fresh peaches, plan on using one pound for every three peaches called for in the recipe. Most baked recipes can be made directly with frozen peaches, so you don’t have to plan ahead and thaw them. For uncooked recipes like salsa or parfaits, thaw the peaches overnight in the refrigerator. Resist the urge to speed up the thawing time in the microwave, which can lead to mushy peaches. Drain the excess liquid and use the thawed peaches as if they were fresh.

What to Make with Frozen Peaches

When to Use Canned Peaches

If peaches aren’t in season and you don’t have any frozen peaches on hand, you can use canned peaches for most baked recipes. Keep in mind that canned peaches are cooked (even if they’re raw packed), so they’ll be softer and more tender compared to the texture of a fresh or frozen peach. Most canned peaches are sliced, but they’re sometimes packed halved or diced.

Peaches are generally canned in 16-ounce (1-pound) cans. You’ll want to use one can for every three peaches in the recipe. There are several varieties of canned fruit, so read the label before heading to the checkout line. Peaches in heavy syrup contain water, corn syrup and sugar, whereas light syrup is made from water and sugar only. You can also find peaches canned in juice (a fruit juice concentrate mixed with water) and peaches packed in water, which contain the lowest sugar content.

When making substitutions, choose the best canned peach to go with your recipe. For example, if your recipe calls for fresh peaches and has sugar as an ingredient, the recipe would probably turn out too sweet with peaches in heavy syrup. You’ll either want to use sugar-free peaches packed in water, or you can reduce the recipe’s sugar content when using a syrup-packed peach.

What to Make with Canned Peaches

Using Fresh vs. Canned vs. Frozen Peaches

How many fresh peaches equal a can of peaches?

Peaches are generally canned in 16-ounce (1-pound) cans. You’ll want to use three peaches for every can called for in the recipe.

How many frozen peach slices equal a fresh peach?

Every three peaches make a pound of frozen peaches. So, if your recipe calls for a specific number of peach slices, you’ll want to turn to the scale. About 1/3 pound (or 5.3 ounces) of peach slices will equal one fresh peach.

Do you need to thaw frozen peaches before using them?

Frozen peaches don’t need to be thawed before adding them to baked dishes because the oven’s heat will gently defrost them as the recipe cooks. You may want to add extra thickener to absorb the excess liquid, though, or let the recipe bake for an extra 5 minutes to cook off the extra moisture. If you’re worried about excess liquid, place the frozen peaches in a colander and let them sit at room temperature for 15 to 20 minutes before adding them to your recipe.

Do you have to drain the liquid from canned or frozen peaches?

Canned and frozen peaches have more liquid than fresh peaches, so it’s important to drain the liquid before substituting them in fresh peach recipes. After thawing frozen peaches, toss them in a colander and let them drain for a minute before adding them to the recipe. For canned peaches, open the can a quarter of the way and drain the liquid before opening the can all the way.

Popular Videos

Fresh vs. Frozen Peaches: When to Use Them (2024)

FAQs

Fresh vs. Frozen Peaches: When to Use Them? ›

The texture of a fresh peach is firmer and less mushy compared to frozen or canned peaches, so they're the way to go for grilled peach or fruit salad recipes. Baked goods with peaches have a more vibrant color and robust texture compared to the same recipe made with preserved peaches.

Do peaches get mushy when frozen? ›

Freezing the fruit on a sheet pan before tossing them in a freezer bag keeps them from freezing into one big peach rock, which makes them way easier to use when you're ready! If done properly, frozen peaches will last up to 6 months in the freezer! They won't be mushy when you go to use them, either. Perfect!

How long can you use frozen peaches? ›

When frozen solid, the packages can be placed closer together. Use frozen peaches within 8 to 10 months.

Are frozen or canned peaches better for cobbler? ›

The baked cobbler may have some extra juice in the filling. It will still be so delicious! What is this? Frozen Peaches: The peach filling will be firmer as frozen peaches do not cook down as much as fresh, even after thawing and pre-baking the filling.

Are frozen peaches better than canned peaches? ›

Fresh is always better than frozen, canned or freeze-dried. A pea picked straight from the garden, a tomato off the vine, a fruit pulled from the tree or a fish fresh from the water are always preferable to their counterparts in cans, bags or freezer-proof boxes.

Are peaches good after freezing? ›

Peaches freeze beautifully, and they retain their color and flavor well. Frozen peaches work wonderfully in smoothies, crisps and crumbles, oatmeal, and even jam!

Does freezing peaches change the texture? ›

Freezing peaches is a great way to preserve this fruit, especially since it doesn't change the texture of the fruit like canning does. This makes them easy to pop out of the freezer and use immediately in a peach dessert or peach smoothie.

Why do frozen peaches taste different? ›

With frozen peaches, I know what I'm getting every time. Freezing and thawing also breaks down the fruit's cells, making them taste more juicy — even if they aren't as sweet as those song-worthy peaches.

How do you thaw frozen peaches without it being mushy? ›

Frozen fruit in the package can be thawed in the refrigerator, under running water, or in a microwave oven if thawed immediately before use. Turn the package several times for more even thawing.

How do you freeze peaches so they don't get mushy? ›

Flash Freeze Peaches
  1. Wash, peel, and remove pits from peaches.
  2. Slice peaches and line them on a baking sheet. Use parchment paper or foil on the baking sheet to make it easier to remove. ...
  3. Place baking sheet in the freezer until peaches are firm—usually three hours.
  4. Remove and place peaches in an airtight container.
Sep 12, 2022

How do you use frozen peaches? ›

Frozen peaches can be made into ice cream or cooked into a peach pie. You can also use them to make peach cobbler, which is a freeform dessert with a peach base and buttery biscuit topping.

Is frozen or fresh fruit better for baking? ›

Frozen fruit should work fine in anything baked or cooked. Keep in mind that some recipes may require additional thickener to balance the extra juice. Rinse frozen fruit to prevent colors from bleeding. Thaw frozen fruit first if what you're making has a short baking or cooking time.

Why is my peach cobbler too gooey? ›

If your cobbler is too runny, it could be because the fruit was too juicy or you didn't let it cool completely. To thicken it up, cornstarch or arrowroot can be added, stirring continuously so that the thickener is completely incorporated.

Can canned peaches last 100 years? ›

Most shelf-stable foods are safe indefinitely. In fact, canned goods will last for years, as long as the can itself is in good condition (no rust, dents, or swelling).

Are peaches good for blood pressure? ›

Peaches are a good source of potassium, which your body uses to regulate your heart rate and blood pressure. Foods high in potassium can help lower your blood pressure by allowing the body to get rid of excess sodium and relaxing tension in the walls of your blood vessels.

Are canned peaches in heavy syrup better than juice? ›

Due to calorie count and overall nutrition value, water-packed canned fruit is the healthiest choice. The heavy and light syrups are of little nutritional value other than calories and are very high in sugar. The fruit packed in juice contains significantly less added sugar than syrup-packed canned fruit.

Why should you not refrigerate peaches? ›

Storing Ripe Peaches

The cool temperature slows down ripening and prevents the peaches from quickly spoiling. It's worth noting, however, that extended time in the fridge will dehydrate the fruit, making the texture less appealing.

Do I have to use lemon juice when freezing peaches? ›

Slice each half into 4-8 wedges and place in a bowl. Toss the juice of 1 lemon and a ½ teaspoon of sugar for every 8-10 peaches added. The lemon juice will help prevent browning and the sugar will release juices from the peaches, helping prevent air pockets when freezing.

Is it better to peel peaches before freezing? ›

Freezing Peaches

For best results, you'll want to peel and slice your peaches prior to freezing. Eliminating any air from the bag will help keep freezer burn from forming. Slicing the peaches and tossing with lemon to prevent browning and a touch of sugar to bring out the juices will help aid in this process.

Why put peaches in ice water? ›

Immediately immerse the peaches in an ice water bath. Let soak until cool to the touch. Placing the peaches into an ice-cold bowl of water helps to stop the cooking process. This also speeds up the amount of time until you can safely touch the fruit to peel it.

Why did my peaches turn brown in the freezer? ›

But if you are slicing and freezing peaches or canning them, it is nearly impossible to prevent them from turning brown. The browning process kicks because when you cut a peach, a group of enzymes called polyphenol oxidases (PPOs) are activated.

Should peaches be frozen whole or sliced? ›

Peaches can even be wrapped and frozen whole. However, a peach that is skinned, sliced and dry packed has the most versatility. When not frozen into a solid bulk, a few can be taken at a time to spruce up that smoothie, garnish a co*cktail or sweeten a cup of yogurt.

How do you fix frozen peaches? ›

If you need your peaches to thaw quickly you can use a water bath. Simply add the frozen peaches to a sealed bag and submerge the bag in cool water. Check the peaches and change the water every so often until the peaches have defrosted.

Does frozen fruit taste the same as fresh? ›

Frozen fruit is often softer and sweeter than fresh fruit. This is because the water in the fruit expands when it's frozen, making the cells burst, resulting in the release of the natural sugars. Frozen fruit can also have a slightly different flavor than fresh fruit.

Are mushy peaches OK? ›

Peaches do not have a long shelf life; they bruise easily, turning them into rancid, soft, and mushy fruits that are no longer enjoyable. Also, a super soft and mushy peach will soon become a moldy, rotten fruit.

Why are my peaches mushy? ›

This is caused by changes to the cell wall of the fruit during the ripening process. As peaches continue ripening after harvest, this problem has been shown to be correlated with the postharvest handling practices.

How do you freeze peaches in a ziplock bag? ›

After the cut peaches are firm and frozen, place them in a large gallon-sized ziploc bag. Be sure to remove as much air as possible from around the frozen peach slices before zipping it tight. Add the date on the bag before placing it in the freezer. Frozen peaches will last for 6-12 months.

How do you use frozen fruit as fresh? ›

Yummy Baked Goods – Frozen fruit can easily be substituted for fresh fruit in most quick bread recipes, such as muffins. Blueberries are popular but don't forget about raspberries, cherries or mixed berries. Simple Dessert – An easy dessert or addition to a meal can simply be frozen fruit that is slightly thawed.

What are the benefits of eating frozen peaches? ›

Scientists think these antioxidants may help protect you from cancer, heart disease, and dementia, and boost your immune system. But we need more research to know for sure. Eat these juicy gems fresh or frozen. They have water and fiber, which fill you up without wrecking your diet.

When should you not use frozen fruit? ›

The US Department of Health recommends consuming frozen fruits like berries and melons within 10 to 18 months of purchase. Meanwhile, fruits like bananas should be consumed within 2-3 months, apples within 8 months, and kiwi shouldn't even be frozen.

Why is frozen better than fresh? ›

“The truth about fresh versus frozen is that both have the same nutrients, unless frozen produce has sauces or sugars added,” says Beal. If your favorite vegetable or fruit is out of season or is more affordable frozen, frozen is often the better choice.

Why is fresh fruit more expensive than frozen? ›

The yield on many fresh fruits and vegetables is less than 50% after trim and spoilage. That effectively doubles their market price. Add in the cost of labor to process and it's even more expensive.

What's the white stuff in peach cobbler? ›

It's peach callus tissue. And while it may seem unappetizing, there is good news! This strange white substance is perfectly safe.

What happens if you don't peel peaches for cobbler? ›

Leave those peaches unpeeled.

Keeping those beautiful skins on gives the cooked cobbler a gorgeous, deep peachy-pink hue and even more depth of flavor. Plus, unlike other cobbler or pie fruit with tougher skins, like apples, peach skins melt away into the cobbler filling.

Can you overcook peach cobbler? ›

Can You Overcook Cobbler? Yes, you can overcook cobbler. If you cook it for too long, the crust may become too hard and the fruit filling may become overly cooked and mushy. To prevent overcooking, make sure to check the cobbler frequently and remove it from the oven before the top becomes too dark or crunchy.

Why can't white peaches be canned? ›

The natural pH of some white-fleshed peaches or nectarines can exceed 4.6, making them a low-acid food for canning purposes. At this time there is no low-acid pressure process available for white-flesh peaches or nectarines, or research to support adding acid for safe boiling water or atmospheric steam canning.

Can you eat 40 year old canned food? ›

Can you eat “expired” canned food? Good news: Shelf-stable canned goods are safe more or less indefinitely, lasting up to five years or more according to the USDA.

Why did my canned peaches rise to top of jar? ›

Fruit Float is the term used when produce, usually fruit, separates and floats to the top of the jars. It is a common occurrence in home canning and an irritating one! We put a lot of work into our canning and want our jars of love to be perfect. Fruit float occurs because air is trapped in the cells of the fruit.

What is the number 1 fruit to lower blood pressure? ›

Berries: Strawberries and blueberries are rich in antioxidant compounds called anthocyanins. Research has linked anthocyanins to a reduction in blood pressure in people with hypertension.

Which fruit should not eat in high blood pressure? ›

*Note: Grapefruit and grapefruit juice can interact negatively with certain blood pressure medications. Consult a healthcare provider or dietitian about possible food-drug interactions before changing your diet. Overall, to improve your heart health, eat a low-sodium diet including lean meat and less added sugars.

What is normal blood pressure for a 70 year old? ›

Normal blood pressure for most adults is defined as a systolic pressure of less than 120 and a diastolic pressure of less than 80.

Do you have to add sugar when canning peaches? ›

Peaches can be canned without sugar, their natural acidity is high enough, but they will discolor and their flavor will deteriorate. However, if you opt to can them without any sugar they are perfectly safe to eat.

Is it OK to drink the juice from canned peaches? ›

Most people don't realize that the juice from canned fruit is perfectly safe to drink. In fact, it can be a great way to get your daily dose of fruit without all the sugar that comes from other fruit juices.

Do they add sugar to canned peaches? ›

Sugar Syrups

Peaches may be covered with your choice of sugar syrup, water, or apple or white grape juice. Sugar is not needed for safety in canning fruit; but in addition to adding flavor, sugar in the liquid helps to keep the texture of the fruit firm and preserve the color.

Why are my frozen peaches mushy? ›

Just like other perishable fruits, frozen peaches also tend to get mushy after their stint in the freezer. This is especially true when they are thawed improperly. If you plan to eat frozen peaches as is, then don't leave them to thaw on the counter as this way, they will get mushy and become inedible.

How do you freeze peaches so they aren't mushy? ›

Flash Freeze Peaches
  1. Wash, peel, and remove pits from peaches.
  2. Slice peaches and line them on a baking sheet. Use parchment paper or foil on the baking sheet to make it easier to remove. ...
  3. Place baking sheet in the freezer until peaches are firm—usually three hours.
  4. Remove and place peaches in an airtight container.
Sep 12, 2022

How do you defrost peaches without being mushy? ›

Slow thawing in the fridge is one of the best ways to preserve the texture and flavor of frozen fruit while preventing it from becoming mushy. This method involves placing the frozen fruit in a bowl or container and leaving it in the refrigerator to thaw slowly over time.

Is it OK to eat mushy peaches? ›

Are Mealy Peaches Safe to Eat? Yes. They are safe to eat, but they probably won't taste very good!

Is it okay to eat squishy peaches? ›

Peaches do not have a long shelf life; they bruise easily, turning them into rancid, soft, and mushy fruits that are no longer enjoyable. Also, a super soft and mushy peach will soon become a moldy, rotten fruit.

What is the texture of frozen peaches? ›

“Peaches, like most produce, will not have the same consistency after they have been frozen,” says Syers, who explains that freezing causes the water inside peach cells to form sharp ice crystals that puncture the cell walls, resulting in a less firm texture.

Should frozen fruit be thawed before baking? ›

Frozen fruit should work fine in anything baked or cooked. Keep in mind that some recipes may require additional thickener to balance the extra juice. Rinse frozen fruit to prevent colors from bleeding. Thaw frozen fruit first if what you're making has a short baking or cooking time.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 6084

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.