Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (2024)

Include this article in yourSkills Builder Journal. It could help you develop...Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (1)Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (2)

Whether you like her or not, it’s safe to say that Barbie has made a global impact. But is it always in a positive way? Is Barbie just a stereotype or is there something more to her? Does she show that you can be anything you want, or are there limits to her success? Writers’ Club members Elise and Jay talk about the way they see it…

Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (3)

Elise: Barbie is a good role model, here’s why:

Who would have thought that a plastic doll would be so controversial? And yet, Barbie’s large-scale franchise has recently been both commended for its celebration of the differences between women and criticised for cashing in on the feminist movement.
I would argue that, across decades of dolls, a few dozen movies and a TV series, Barbie has been a good role model for children, especially over the last few years. She’s taught girls everywhere to aim high and maximise their potential, with her huge catalogue of careers and adventures. She’s been a princess, a doctor, an entomologist and even a UNICEF ambassador, refusing to let traditional ideas of a woman’s role get in her way.

I was never one for dolls so the biggest interaction I had with her was repeatedly watching Life In The Dreamhouse, an animated series detailing the shenanigans of Barbie, her friends and her sisters. It was cheesy but entertaining, and it highlighted her problem-solving abilities and proactive personality rather than her looks. It also explored the comically complicated lives of the other characters, which came together to create a fan-favourite female-dominated show. It capitalised on the nostalgia of the old Barbie movies, and seemed to do a good job in presenting strong-minded women, like many of the movies in the franchise.

Barbie, as a brand, also does this in their adverts. The Imagine The Possibilities ad is a particularly memorable one. It features five young girls in professional settings showing off their intelligence, confidence and ability to lead; they take on the roles of a professor, a vet, a football coach, a tour guide and a businesswoman. I find it truly heart-warming to see feminine power being encouraged and celebrated from such a young age, and it’s good for children to see themselves represented in that way on TV.

Now for the actual dolls. When I was little, it was really important to my parents that I had dolls with different skin tones to reflect our multicultural society and break down some of those barriers that try to keep us apart. With Barbie’s extensive range of characters of different races, abilities and body types, it offers a great opportunity to teach children and share with them the importance of diversity.

Of course, we can criticise them for not doing this sooner, or for arguably only following public demand when it’s profitable to do so, but maybe it’s a case of better late than never. I think Barbie has a big influence on how we see ourselves growing up, so I’m glad they’re dispelling some of the dumb-blonde stereotypes and telling the world that successful women come in all shapes, sizes and skin tones.

Jay: Barbie isn’t a good role model, here’s why:

Barbie has long been used as a model for the ideal female lifestyle, promoting a cookie-cutter role of women - dictated by a patriarch - to young girls. When Barbie was first introduced in 1959, the doll’s appearance was based off of Bild Lilli, a German character doll that was created as a racy gag gift for older men that they could buy in tobacco shops. The design of the doll took off with children and thus became a children’s sensation.

I believe Barbie, as a role model for children, is toxic as it dictates that girls should look and act a certain way in order to be more successful. The introduction of Barbie’s more feminist friendly career choices may suggest a more open perspective, but also shows how these sorts of ‘dream big’ ideals are only available to the attractive and ‘picture perfect’ models.

Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (4)

Furthermore, in recent years Barbie has experienced new forms of media representation, such as the television series adaptations. These shows attempt to ensure that cultural diversity is shown throughout the Barbie brand, and does not pertain to a White American idealist view, however, not only is it degrading that any non-white character is reduced to a side character, most of Barbie’s racially ambiguous friends are stereotypes and can be offensive to the people they are supposed to represent. This does not provoke the righteous feminist outlook that many would like to receive from such a well-known figure.

The push for diversity accomplishes one thing: it shows that rich, white people are the centre of attention, the ‘norm’ and the most important characters. All regularly occurring characters in the series are largely well off, and white. The racially diverse characters are often shown as being less fortunate than Barbie, having to have roommates or having ‘culturally’ different living conditions that are then portrayed as ‘lower’ than Barbie.

Barbie as a feminist role model is inconceivable, as not only does the doll depict how women should look and act, the majority of Barbie dolls show no deterrence from their slim and sleek models, the brand having only released a variety of body types in 2016, after the Barbie doll had already become a globably monitized sensation, and presence as a female ideal. This is problematic as in recent years, the pressure to acknowledge that weight does not amount to beauty has been ever-present in the media, yet people still have these idealist models when growing up, which is arguably the most important time for developing our sense of moral perspective. Also, Barbie was originally created to satisfy the male gaze which contrasts today's fight for equality by insinuating a women’s purpose is to please men, which can only do more harm than good in the continuous fight for gender equality.

Therefore, in my personal opinion, Barbie had a chance to create positive change at the start of the twenty-first century, but, in failing to do so in an impactful way, it is now too late for them.

Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? (2024)

FAQs

Is Barbie A Good Role Model For Young People? ›

I would argue that, across decades of dolls, a few dozen movies and a TV series, Barbie has been a good role model for children, especially over the last few years. She's taught girls everywhere to aim high and maximise their potential, with her huge catalogue of careers and adventures.

Are Barbie dolls a good role model? ›

Barbie has multiple jobs.

Since young children draw inspiration from who they watch and surround themselves with, Barbie's encouragement to dream big has a significant impact on them. Barbie's impressive resume challenges the concealed hierarchy of careers established by many in society.

What age group is Barbie aimed at? ›

The age range for the original Barbie fashion dolls is for kids 3 and up. “We talk to parents and kids almost every day.

Is it normal for a 12 year old to play with Barbies? ›

As experts would tell you, there is no age limit for dolls. It may seem unusual in this day and age, but several 12-year-olds still play with dolls. And in a world where the internet is widespread, this may be a good thing.

Why is Barbie good for children? ›

Encourages imaginative play: Barbie-like dolls provide a blank canvas for kids to use their imaginations. They can act out different scenarios, create stories, and explore their creativity. This type of play helps children develop their imagination and creativity.

What is the impact of Barbie doll? ›

Unfortunately, many believe that Barbie caused what has become known as the Barbie Effect. The doll had an unnatural figure, relied on men rather than having her own occupation, and finally, her physical appearance rather than her intelligence was prioritized.

What do Barbie dolls represent? ›

Although Mattel has positioned Barbie as the ultimate American girl, the doll has never been manufactured in the United States, to avoid higher labour costs. Today the doll has come to symbolize consumer capitalism and is as much a global brand as Coca-Cola, with key markets in Europe, Latin America, and Asia.

At what age do girls stop playing with Barbie dolls? ›

Some kids may lose interest in dolls around the age of 5 or 6, while others may continue to play with them into their pre-teen years. There really isn't a "magic age" at which all children suddenly stop playing with dolls - it varies from child to child.

Can 14 year olds play with Barbie dolls? ›

Yes. One of the great joys when my daughter was little was that I, a man in my mid 30's, was able to join her is playing with blocks, trains, stuffed animals and all sorts of other toys I'd loved as a child. We're never too old to play with our favorite toys. Enjoy!

What are the criticisms of Barbie? ›

Criticism of Barbie

In the 1970s, alongside the feminist movement, critics slammed Barbie as a poor role model for girls because of her unrealistic body image. Additional criticism included that she was too materialistic and led girls to believe that only things like cars, money, and fashion were important.

Is it normal to play with Barbies at 15? ›

It's perfectly acceptable for an adult to play with toys. If your child enjoys playing with dolls then make sure she has a couple of nice dolls to play with, clothes to change them into, play diapers etc. Human beings like to play. It encourages the imagination and helps us learn about the world in a safe relaxed way.

Is it OK for boys to play with Barbies? ›

Is it ok for boys to play with dolls? Experts agree that doll play is as helpful for boys, as it is for girls as they too need to develop the same emotional skills as girls and often are deprived of that sort of emotional exploration.

What is the psychology of playing with dolls? ›

Playing with dolls encourages children to talk more about others' thoughts and emotions, a study has found. The research suggests that playing imaginary games with dolls could help children develop social skills, theory of mind and empathy.

What are the positive effects of Barbie? ›

When children create imaginary worlds and role play with dolls like Barbie, it prompts them to talk about thoughts about others' emotions and feelings. This can have positive long-lasting effects on children, building social and emotional processing social skills like empathy.

What are 3 facts about Barbie dolls? ›

The first Barbie doll was sold for $3.00. The first Barbie commercial aired during the Mickey Mouse Club in 1959. Barbie doll's signature color is Barbie Pink (PMS 219). Barbie stands 11.5 inches tall.

What is Barbie supposed to be about? ›

What's the plot of the Barbie movie? The film will center on a doll living in Barbieland, who's forced to leave due to her so-called imperfections—setting off on an adventure in the real world and discovering along the way that perfection can only truly be found within.

What is Barbie doll syndrome? ›

“Barbie doll syndrome” (or simply “Barbie syndrome”) is a type of body dysmorphic disorder, which has been described as the drive to attain impossible standards of physical appearance such as that of the Barbie doll.

Why Barbie is unique? ›

Her ability to evolve and grow with the times, while staying true to her spirit, is central to why Barbie is the number one fashion doll in the world. Above all it is Mattel's ability to see how times change that will allow Barbie to cling on for a few more years yet.

Why are Barbie's so popular? ›

Barbie has been seen on TV commercials since the early 1960's. With over 40 years of continuous television exposure you can't help but see the ads throughout your childhood and into adulthood. This exposure has led Barbie to being one of the most popular toys in history.

Is Barbie still popular? ›

In comparison to other toy franchises, specifically, dolls, Barbie has exhibited longevity. This could be due to Barbie's ability to adapt and respond to the needs of consumers. Brands such as Zara, Pretty Little Thing, River Island, New Look, Boohoo and BoohooMAN continue to launch Barbie clothing collections.

Why do girls play with dolls? ›

It gives children the opportunity to be empathic, emotional, and show caring and attention toward others.” Along with social-emotional benefits, playing with dolls can also promote skills that help prepare a child for preschool. Learn more about what children gain from this sweet, fun form of imaginative play.

Is 11 too old for American Girl doll? ›

Absolutely not!

I think you can never be too old for dolls, and never too old for a hobby you love!

How do Barbies affect body image? ›

Conclusions: These findings suggest that girls who begin playing with Barbies at a young age may be susceptible to developing a greater internalization of the thin ideal. It is important that girls and parents be aware that Barbies do not represent an ideal body to match.

Can boys play with girls toys? ›

It is OK! Kids like what they like. Plenty of little kids genuinely enjoy and are drawn to the toys designed for their gender. A study of infants showed that babies as young as 9 months old start to show a preference for gender-specific toys.

At what age should a child stop playing with stuffed animals? ›

Children have their own schedule for growing up and its much slower than some adults have the patience for. By 5-year-old most kids will no longer need a comfort object like a plushie or blanket everywhere they go.

What percentage of girls own a Barbie? ›

Even in demanding positions, though, Barbie retained her fashion sense. Factoyd: Ninety percent of American girls own at least one Barbie doll, and the average girl owns 10!

Why was pregnant Barbie banned? ›

The Happy Family product became the subject of controversy when some parents disliked the "pregnant" Midge toy because they believed that Midge was too young to have children.

What is the controversy with Mattel Barbie? ›

Criticism of Barbie's Body

As Barbie's popularity grew, so did criticism of her body shape. Many argued that Barbie's unrealistic proportions promoted unhealthy body ideals and perpetuated gender stereotypes.

Is it OK to play with toys at 15? ›

If a child still wants to play with toys as they move into adolescence, it is totally normal and to be celebrated! Unless a child's play is affecting or replacing real-life friendships, there is no need to worry.

What is the age range for a child? ›

Infants (1 month to 1 year) Children (1 year through 12 years) Adolescents (13 years through 17 years. They may also be referred to as teenagers depending on the context.)

How do you take care of a baby doll like a real baby? ›

First steps of caring for your doll
  1. Choose a name. Just like a real baby, a child's baby doll will need a name just right for them. ...
  2. Dress your doll. ...
  3. Introduce them to family and friends. ...
  4. Feed them. ...
  5. Change their nappy. ...
  6. Take your doll out for a walk. ...
  7. Get them ready for bed. ...
  8. Wipe the doll down.
Feb 4, 2022

Why does my boy like girl stuff? ›

The fact that your son enjoys playing with girls' things or has qualities we typically associate with girls, such as sensitivity and gentleness, is an indication that you've been open and supportive and that you've provided him with opportunities that go beyond typical "boys'" play.

What does it mean if a boy plays with Barbies? ›

Pollack stresses that a boy playing with dolls is "absolutely normal." And even if the boy would rather play with Barbie over GI Joe regularly, it's still normal. The distinction, says Pollack, is if the child says, "I don't like being a boy" or "I want to be a girl."

Why does my son like to play with Barbies? ›

Preferring toys and objects that are traditionally associated with a different gender does not necessarily have anything to do with gender identity or sexual orientation. Your son may be more sensitive and nurturing than his male peers. There are girls his age who prefer some of the more traditionally male toys.

What is the doll baby effect? ›

The Kewpie doll effect is a term used in developmental psychology derived from research in ethology to help explain how a child's physical features, such as lengthened forehead and rounded face, motivate the infant's caregiver to take care of them.

Do 12 year olds still play with dolls? ›

As experts would tell you, there is no age limit for dolls. It may seem unusual in this day and age, but several 12-year-olds still play with dolls. And in a world where the internet is widespread, this may be a good thing.

Why are some adults obsessed with dolls? ›

Dolls can look so lifelike that they can soothe your emotional needs. If you're feeling lonely or grieving, the presence of your doll collection can make you happy. Sometimes a collection of dolls helps you uncover and let loose emotions that need to be expressed.

What is Barbie doll personality? ›

Personality… optimistic, kind, and friendly. For all her beauty and talent, Barbie is shockingly down-to-earth. She considers everyone her friend, and if there's one thing Barbie is about, it's making sure her friends are happy.

What can Barbie do? ›

Medicine
  • Animal rescuer (2016) ...
  • Dentist (1997, 2003, 2010, 2015, 2019, 2023)
  • Doctor (1988, 1993, Spain-exclusive José Carreras Doctora Barbie 1995, 1996, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2019, 2020, 2021)
  • Eye doctor (2015, 2017)
  • Nurse (1961, re-issued 2009. ...
  • Paramedic (2021)

What is Barbie environmental impact? ›

OUR COMMITMENT TO THE ENVIRONMENT

Our goal is to reach 95% recycled or Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certified paper or wood fiber in our packaging by 2021 and by 2030 100% recycled, recyclable or bio-based plastic materials.

How many girls have Barbies? ›

The brand does $1 billion in sales across more than 150 countries annually, and 92% of American girls ages 3 to 12 have owned a Barbie, thanks in part to her affordable $10 price tag.

What is the rarest Barbie doll in the world? ›

Obviously, there have been several different iterations of Barbie over the many years the brand has been around. But one of the rarest actually came out in 2000 and it was the special edition Chicago Cubs Fan Barbie. This Barbie doll is now considered to be very, very rare with a price tag of at least $2,000.

Who was Barbie based on? ›

Barbie is a fashion doll manufactured by American toy company Mattel, Inc. and launched on March 9, 1959. American businesswoman Ruth Handler is credited with the creation of the doll using a German doll called Bild Lilli as her inspiration.

What is the lesson from Barbie? ›

For many of us, Barbie taught us how to tell stories. She was the reason we'd invite our friends over and simply “play imagination” for hours. Through the worlds we created with our friends, Barbie taught us how to share, how to be flexible, and how to dream about what was possible.

What is the main theme of Barbie Doll? ›

“Barbie Doll” teaches the reader of the dangers that exist in forcing people, especially women, into restrictive roles and ideals. With the use of diction, simile, irony, and tone, Marge Piercy exposes the destructive nature of impossible ideals and contradictory social expectations.

Why does Barbie always wear pink? ›

A bright shade of pink was chosen as Barbie's signature color mostly to attract young girls to the brand. When paired with a font that looks like a child's handwriting, their logo conveys a sense of fun, whimsy, and childhood.

What percent of girls play with Barbies? ›

Ninety percent of American girls ages three to 10 own at least one Barbie, according to the doll's maker, Mattel , and that's just the primary market. Barbie has inspired impassioned legions of adult collectors who dote on her various iterations and costumes.

Is calling a girl Barbie good? ›

Barbie, the toy many girls play with when they are young, is known for her unhumanlike body proportions and beauty. When someone calls you a barbie, they mean that you are beautiful and have an amazing body. Hope this helps! It means blonde, attractive (to men) and heterosexual.

What are the criticism of Barbie? ›

Criticism of Barbie's Body

Many argued that Barbie's unrealistic proportions promoted unhealthy body ideals and perpetuated gender stereotypes. In the 1990s, the “Barbie Liberation Organization” made headlines for switching the voice boxes on Barbie and G.I. Joe dolls, in an attempt to challenge gender stereotypes.

Is it normal for a 14 year old to play with Barbies? ›

A 14 year old is still a kid and dolls are delightful and harmless joy. Be proud of your daughters healthy choices of activities. perhaps introduce her to the idea of doll making as a hobby, or even a career. Custom dolls are hot these days!

Who is the most Barbie like girl in the world? ›

Valeria Valeryevna Lukyanova (Ukrainian: Вале́рія Вале́ріївна Лук'я́нова; Russian: Валерия Валерьевна Лукьянова; born 1985) is a Moldova-born Ukrainian model and entertainer of Russian origin famous for her resemblance to a Barbie doll. She currently lives in Mexico.

When a guy calls you a Barbie? ›

a person, especially a young woman, perceived as blandly attractive and vacuous.

Which girl is like Barbie? ›

Also known as the “Human Barbie Doll,” Ukrainian model Valeria Lukyanova looks like she's undergone numerous surgeries to construct her surreal appearance.

Why did Barbie girl get sued? ›

Mattel claimed the song violated the Barbie trademark and turned Barbie into a sex object, referring to her as a "Blonde Bimbo." They alleged the song had violated their copyrights and trademarks of Barbie, and that its lyrics had tarnished the reputation of their trademark and impinged on their marketing plan.

Is there a down syndrome Barbie? ›

Meet the first Barbie® doll with Down syndrome! Barbie® partnered with the National Down Syndrome Society to design a doll that celebrates this community.

What is the psychology of playing with Barbie dolls? ›

Playing with dolls encourages children to talk more about others' thoughts and emotions, a study has found. The research suggests that playing imaginary games with dolls could help children develop social skills, theory of mind and empathy.

What are 3 facts about Barbie? ›

The first Barbie doll was sold for $3.00. The first Barbie commercial aired during the Mickey Mouse Club in 1959. Barbie doll's signature color is Barbie Pink (PMS 219). Barbie stands 11.5 inches tall.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 6222

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.