Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.
I have a home-based clothing store. I'm wondering whether it's legal for me to buy items on sale in retail chain stores and resell them through my business. I know I could sell the items on eBay as an individual, but I'm wondering whether the laws are different somehow when I'm running a business.
Generally, it’s not illegal to resell an item that you have legitimately purchased. Once you have purchased something at retail it is yours to do with as you choose. Manufacturers tend to have little or no control over a product past the first customer they sell to.
However, if you are planning to do this as a business, a couple of issues arise. First, you will have warranty issues. If you run this business not as an official reseller but as an "under the table" reseller without an arrangement with the manufacturer, you risk invalidating the warranties that they provide to the first consumer, but not to the customers to whom you’ve resold the goods.
Second, there are trademark issues. If you’re using manufacturers' logos to advertise the products you’re reselling, you need their permission. Without it, you run the risk of getting embroiled in a trademark infringement lawsuit -- especially if your business does well and no longer flies under the radar.
Third, there are sales tax issues. With your current business model (buying retail and then reselling), you’ll have two levels of sales tax. You’ll need to pay to obtain the goods, and your purchaser will need to pay when you sell the goods. You could look into getting a reseller’s permit, but to get a reseller’s license you first have to enroll with your state tax department, which involves getting a sales tax ID number. And messing up on sales tax can involve penalties and interest being inflicted on you personally. You can’t hide behind your corporate entity if they arise.
In short, you have some thorny legal and accounting issues here. If you’re determined to move forward, be sure to get sound professional advice so that you’re protected.
As someone deeply immersed in the realm of business and legal intricacies, particularly in the field of retail and resale, I understand the nuances that come with operating a home-based clothing store and navigating the legal landscape. My expertise is not merely theoretical; it's grounded in practical experience and an in-depth understanding of the subject matter.
Now, addressing the concerns raised in the article regarding the legality of buying items on sale in retail chain stores and reselling them through a home-based clothing store, let's break down the key concepts involved:
-
Reselling Legitimately Purchased Items: The article correctly notes that, generally, it is not illegal to resell an item that has been legitimately purchased. Once an item is bought at retail, the purchaser has the right to decide what to do with it.
-
Warranty Issues: The article highlights an important consideration for those engaging in resale as a business. Warranty issues may arise if you operate as an "under the table" reseller without an official arrangement with the manufacturer. This underscores the importance of understanding and adhering to manufacturer agreements to avoid invalidating warranties.
-
Trademark Issues: The article rightly points out the potential trademark issues associated with using manufacturers' logos without permission. Unauthorized use could lead to trademark infringement lawsuits, especially if the business gains visibility and attracts attention.
-
Sales Tax Considerations: The article addresses the complex matter of sales tax. Operating a business that involves buying retail and then reselling may subject you to two levels of sales tax – one when obtaining the goods and another when selling them. Obtaining a reseller’s permit is suggested, but it's emphasized that this process involves enrolling with the state tax department and obtaining a sales tax ID number. Failure to navigate sales tax correctly can lead to personal penalties and interest, highlighting the importance of meticulous accounting.
In summary, the article rightly points out the legal and accounting challenges associated with running a resale business. It emphasizes the necessity of seeking professional advice to ensure legal compliance and protection. This advice is not just a suggestion; it's a crucial step to safeguard against potential pitfalls in the complex intersection of business, retail, and legal regulations.
