Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (2024)

Jump to Recipe

Rum Balls are a classic holiday treat. Boozy, chocolatey and rich, store these beauties in the refrigerator for several days for an even better flavor!

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (1)

Ohio is clearly a little confused in terms of the weather right now. It was sunny and almost 50 degrees today which is a little disappointing considering Christmas is in 4 days and last year we were expecting a huge winter storm around this time.

What can I say? I’m all for a white Christmas.

Despite the warm and sunny weather, we’re checking off items on our holiday baking list one by one.

I’ve got all the ingredients for peanut butter blossoms, snowball cookies, gingerbread cookies, saltine toffee, peanut brittle and of course, rum balls.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (2)

WHAT ARE RUM BALLS?

I was probably around 30 years old before I had a rum ball.

Can you believe it? These are such a holiday classic, yet somehow I just missed the boat for 30 years.

I’m glad that I finally figured out what all the fuss was about, though, because these babies are well worth making.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (3)

Rum balls are pretty similar to turtle cookie balls or peppermint oreo cookie balls — just…boozier.

Rum balls are bite-size homemade treats made with vanilla cookie crumbs, pecans, cocoa, confectioners’ sugar, and spiced rum.

These do taste like spiced rum, so keep that in mind. Although if rum isn’t your favorite, you could try making them with bourbon instead.

Don’t worry about getting drunk from rum balls. Because there is only 4 ounces of rum in the entire batch, you’d have to eat quite a few!

If booze isn’t your thing, you might try my no-bake cookies or my simple homemade truffles as easy no-bake holiday gifts.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (4)

HOW TO MAKE RUM BALLS

Rum balls are incredibly easy to make. They’re a great option if you need a treat to share but don’t want to turn on the oven!

Grab a very large bowl to mix everything in, as well as a silicone spatula or a sturdy wooden spoon.

You’re also going to need to crush up some vanilla wafers. You can use a food processor, or put the cookies into a ziptop bag, close it, and use a rolling pin to crush the cookies.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (5)

Pour the crushed vanilla wafers into the bowl and add the rest of the dry ingredients to have everything evenly dispersed.

Drizzle in the vanilla, corn syrup, and rum. Stir well to fully incorporate, making sure there are no dry bits.

To make sure they are wet enough, scoop up a bit of the mixture and squeeze it into a ball in your hands. If it stays in a ball shape, you’re ready to roll!

Add small amounts of crushed wafers or more rum as needed to get the perfect texture.

Use a cookie scoop to roll the mixture into 1-inch balls, then toss them in a shallow bowl filled with your favorite coating.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (6)

RUM BALL VARIATIONS

Wondering what you could roll your rum balls in?

You could use cocoa powder, powdered sugar (confectioners’ sugar), crushed nuts, sprinkles, shredded coconut, or whatever else strikes your fancy — any of them are delicious.

Remember that you can do a little bit of everything, too! This recipe makes about 20 large rum balls, so I think it’s fun to do several of a few different toppings.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (7)

If you roll them in powdered sugar, keep in mind that you may want to re-roll them just before serving, as the powdered sugar tends to absorb a bit while they rest in the refrigerator.

You can also change up the flavor of your rum balls by trying different rum flavors. Instead of spiced rum, try:

  • Dark rum
  • Coconut rum
  • White rum
  • Vanilla rum
  • Bourbon

Out of vanilla wafer cookies? No problem! Rum balls can be made with other kinds of crushed cookies too, like graham crackers or butter cookies.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (8)

STORAGE TIPS

Here’s the best thing about this recipe: They actually taste better when they’re made in advance AND they last forever in the refrigerator.

Ok, maybe not forever. But they will last for quite some time!

Much like fruitcake cookies, rum balls taste better when they’ve had a few days to sit and let the flavor develop.

Just pop them into an airtight container and stick them in the fridge for at least 2 days, and up to a couple of weeks.

You don’t need to store rum balls in the refrigerator as long as you keep them in a cool, dry place, but I find they have the best flavor and last the longest when kept cold.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (9)

I keep mine chilled, packed in a holiday tin lined with wax paper, so they’re ready to go in case unexpected company comes by.

Not sure when you might need your rum balls? Freeze them for longer storage! You can freeze rum balls for up to 2 months.

I recommend packing them with as little air as possible, so if you have a vacuum sealer that will work great.

You can also simply use a ziptop freezer bag and remove excess air before sealing. This will keep your rum balls fresh and delicious!

To thaw, simply remove them from the freezer and place in the refrigerator until they are soft enough to bite.

This is such a great make-ahead recipe for holiday parties, gift giving, or your own personal dessert stash.

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (10)
Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (11)

Yield: 20 large balls

Prep Time: 20 minutes

Total Time: 20 minutes

Rum Balls are a classic holiday treat. Boozy, chocolatey and rich, store these beauties in the refrigerator for several days for an even better flavor!

Ingredients

  • 3 cups crushed vanilla wafers
  • 3/4 cup confectioners' sugar
  • 1/4 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 1 1/2 cups finely chopped pecans
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 3 tablespoons light corn syrup
  • 1/2 cup spiced rum

Instructions

  1. In a large bowl, stir together the crushed vanilla wafers, 3/4 cup confectioners' sugar, cocoa, and nuts. Drizzle in vanilla, corn syrup and rum.
  2. Scoop scoop and shape into 1 inch balls or larger. I used about 4 teaspoons of the chocolate mixture per ball which equaled 2 level scoops from a small OXO cookie scoop.
  3. Roll Rum Balls in additional confectioners' sugar, cocoa, sprinkles or whatever strikes your fancy. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for several days to develop the flavor.

Notes

- If you chose to roll your Rum Balls in confectioners; sugar, you may need to recoat them before serving.
- I served my Rum Balls in mini cupcake liners that I picked up from Target.

Nutrition Information

Yield 20Serving Size 1 rum ball
Amount Per ServingCalories 155Total Fat 8gSaturated Fat 1gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 6gCholesterol 0mgSodium 50mgCarbohydrates 17gFiber 1gSugar 11gProtein 1g

Did you make this recipe?

Tag me on social! I want to see what you made! @jamiemba

Rum Balls Recipe: Perfect for the Holidays | My Baking Addiction (2024)

FAQs

How long will rum balls keep in the fridge? ›

Rum balls can be prepared ahead of time and stored in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2 weeks or in the freezer for up to 2 months.

Do rum balls have to be refrigerated? ›

Do rum balls need to be refrigerated? If stored in an airtight container in a cool, dry area, they do not need to be refrigerated. However, I highly recommend storing them in the fridge – they will hold together better, last longer, and taste so much better. They will stay fresh in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

What can I substitute for vanilla wafers in rum balls? ›

If you don't have vanilla wafers you can use one of these substitutes:
  • If you're using them as a cookie any small sugar or butter cookie will suffice.
  • OR - Replace vanilla (Nilla) wafers with shortbread cookies.
  • OR - For making a pie or dessert crust you can substitute graham cracker crumbs.

Can rum balls be frozen? ›

Store your rum balls in an airtight container in the fridge to prevent the rum from evaporating and to ensure they keep their shape. Rum balls freeze very well. To freeze, simply add to an airtight container and pop in the freezer until needed.

Does the alcohol cook out of rum balls? ›

Because rum balls are not baked, the alcohol in the rum does not cook out. But they are not overly boozy since there is a small amount in each ball.

Can I drink 5 year old rum? ›

Unopened liquor has an indefinite shelf life. Opened liquor lasts about a year or two before it goes bad, meaning it starts losing its color and flavor. Don't use a liquor for well drinks if you won't use the whole bottle within two years. It does not generally become toxic, though.

Why are my rum balls sticky? ›

Why are my rum balls sticky? You may have added too much liquid or had too little of the dry ingredients in your mixture. It's an easy fix, though; simply roll the balls again in powdered sugar or cocoa (or a mixture of both) to make them less sticky to the touch.

Do rum balls expire? ›

But they will last for quite some time! Much like fruitcake cookies, rum balls taste better when they've had a few days to sit and let the flavor develop. What is this? Just pop them into an airtight container and stick them in the fridge for at least 2 days, and up to a couple of weeks.

What can I substitute for rum in rum balls? ›

Rum Balls Ingredients

Remember though that a lot of the rum balls taste will come from the rum so make sure it is a rum you like! You can also substitute with other liqueurs - Grand Marnier, Baileys, Bourbon and Brandy are all popular alternatives.

What alcohol makes the best vanilla? ›

What Kind of Alcohol is Best for Making Vanilla Extract? You can use any alcohol as long as it is 80 proof. The best and most popular choices are vodka, bourbon, brandy, or rum. Vodka is the most versatile because it has a neutral flavor.

Why does my homemade vanilla tastes like alcohol? ›

I chopped the vanilla beans, but the extract only has a slight taste of vanilla. Editor: If your extract still tastes of alcohol, that shouldn't be of too much concern — especially given you're still on the short end of the steeping time. Wait a bit longer; give it at least another month before calling it.

What alcohol should I use for vanilla extract? ›

Use either. 80 proof Alcohol: Vanilla extract is most commonly made from vodka, but you can use bourbon, brandy, or rum instead. I usually use vodka, but the one bottle of bourbon vanilla I made 7 months ago is DIVINE. No need to splurge on expensive alcohol.

Why is it called a rum ball? ›

Rum balls are a truffle-like confectionery cake of cookie butter flavoured with chocolate and rum. They are roughly the size of a golf ball and often coated in chocolate sprinkles, desiccated coconut, or cocoa. As their name implies, these cookies contain rum.

What happens if you put rum in the freezer? ›

Can you keep rum in the freezer? The typical household freezer is set to minus 18 C (zero Fahrenheit). Pure rum shouldn't freeze until the temperature falls to minus 27 C (-17 F), so it is safe in your freezer. Rum liqueurs have a lower ABV and therefore freeze more easily.

Does putting rum in the freezer make it weaker? ›

There's no evidence that keeping liquor at freezer temperatures—even extremely cold freezer temperatures—has any lasting effect on the liquid in the bottle.

Does all the alcohol burn off a rum cake? ›

Does Rum Cake Contain Alcohol? Though there is rum in both the cake and sauce, a lot of it cooks off during the baking/heating process. That being said, the conventional saying that “all” of the alcohol cooks out during baking isn't completely true.

What happens if you leave rum in the heat? ›

Keep it cool

As temperatures rise, the alcohol begins to expand and can evaporate more quickly. While it won't hurt you healthwise to consume, storing in a warm place can cause the liquor to oxidize more quickly and change flavors over time.

How long do you cook rum to remove alcohol? ›

Answer: The conventional wisdom accepted by just about everyone in the food world is that all the alcohol you add to a dish evaporates or dissipates during cooking. It is wrong. In fact, you have to cook something for a good 3 hours to eradicate all traces of alcohol.

Does rum affect brain? ›

Alcohol makes it harder for the brain areas controlling balance, memory, speech, and judgment to do their jobs, resulting in a higher likelihood of injuries and other negative outcomes. Long-term heavy drinking causes alterations in the neurons, such as reductions in their size.

Can you drink 50 year old rum? ›

Spirits above 40-per-cent abv (80 proof) don't expire. Anything that's been distilled, such as gin, vodka, rum, tequila or whisky, stops aging once it's been bottled. Most brands are best enjoyed in the first year.

What are the side effects of rum? ›

High blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, liver disease, and digestive problems. Cancer of the breast, mouth, throat, esophagus, voice box, liver, colon, and rectum. Weakening of the immune system, increasing the chances of getting sick. Learning and memory problems, including dementia and poor school performance.

Can you wash sticky balls? ›

When you find that the stickiness of the sticky ball is not so good, it is because the surface of the sticky ball has absorbed too many impurities. Just clean the sticky ball with water, and it will be restored to its original state.

Can graham crackers be substituted for vanilla wafers in rum balls? ›

You can substitute graham crackers for vanilla wafers. Both will add a nice crispy texture and additional flavor. Roll these easy rum balls in powdered sugar, sprinkles, crushed vanilla wafers, cocoa powder, coconut flakes, or more crushed pecans. You can also leave them plain!

Do rum balls contain egg? ›

In bowl mix together walnuts, sweet chocolate, sugar and half the egg whites. Add enough rum to moisten mixture so it holds together to form dough. Shape mixture into 1" balls. Roll balls in remaining egg white, then in chocolate sprinkles.

Can you drink 40 year old rum? ›

Rum is one of the distilled spirits. It's a stable alcohol, and that means it can be stored for years and still stay fine. So no matter if it's a bottle that's sitting there for years waiting to be enjoyed, or one opened and waiting to be finished, the rum will likely be perfectly fine.

Can you drink 20 year old rum? ›

Rum is one of the distilled spirits. It has stable alcohol and strong spirits that means you can store it for many years and still be fine. No matter how long it's kept inside your cabinet, it will be perfectly fine.

Where do rum balls originated from? ›

Traditionally Danish Rum Balls are also known as Romkugler. Romkugler is found in every bakery in Denmark are very dense, have a rich chocolate taste and a twist of rum. Rum Balls were originally invented by the Danish bakers who were worried at the end of each day when they found unsold cakes at the counter.

Which rum is best for baking? ›

Bacardi Gold

The gold standard for sweet but dry white rum that works well in many applications including beverages and desserts such as baked goods, puddings, ice cream, and cakes. Bacardi Gold offers a very sweet, smooth rum that doesn't overpower the other flavors in your recipe.

What are the 3 three main type of rum? ›

The 3 Types of Rum and Why You Need Them
  • White Rum - Think co*cktails. Rum is made from sugar cane. ...
  • Dark Rum - If It's Aged, Try It Neat. Most likely you are already aware that spirits tend to darken in color with age. ...
  • Spiced Rum - Classic Cuba Libre.

What is the best mixture for rum? ›

7 Drinks That are Perfect Mixers for Rum
  • Rum & Tonic Water.
  • Rum, Lime Juice & a Twist of Lemon.
  • Rum & Ginger Ale.
  • Rum & Orange Juice.
  • Rum & Coconut Water.
  • Rum & Cranberry Juice.
  • Rum & Grapefruit Juice.
28 Jun 2022

What is the best vanilla in the world? ›

Madagascar vanilla is known as the best vanilla and what you would think of when you imagine a vanilla bean. It has a heavenly aroma and a rich, creamy vanilla taste. Madagascar vanilla also goes by the name Bourbon vanilla, but it does not have bourbon essentially.

How many times can you reuse vanilla beans to make extract? ›

Beans you've already used in a batch of extract can be reused in the next batch. When I siphoned off the vanilla extract from my 18 month batch, almost all of those beans went right back into the jar for the next batch. I simply added a few new beans to punch up the flavour.

What alcohol is Mexican vanilla made from? ›

Vodka and Mexican vanilla beans are the two key ingredients I use to make this homemade Mexican Vanilla Extract. Mexican vanilla is a rich marriage of sweet and woody notes with deep, spicy character. Its clove and nutmeg-like qualities provide a flavorful culinary twist to all of your favorite recipes.

Should I be shaking my homemade vanilla? ›

Shake it up.

Every few days give your bottles of vanilla extract a good shake. Since both the vanilla bean pods and their seeds tend to sink to the bottom of the bottle, shaking moves the infused alcohol around, allowing for better and faster extraction.

Can vanilla beans mold in alcohol? ›

Finally, at-home extract makers may may notice white fatty-matter appearing on their beans after submersing them in alcohol. It can have the initial appearance of mold, but when you look closely you will see that it is actually the fatty vanillin oils being extracted. They will break down over time.

Does baking remove alcohol from vanilla extract? ›

Before you worry about getting a buzz from your baked goods, nearly all of the alcohol from extracts evaporates in the cooking process.

Is vodka or rum better for vanilla extract? ›

Vodka produces a cleaner and lighter vanilla extract; bourbon produces a heavier, more complex and moodier, if you will, type of extract. Dark rum, light rum, spiced rum, or brandy will all effect the taste of the final extract compared to vodka, which imparts almost none.

How do you get the alcohol taste out of vanilla extract? ›

It's simple. Just add sugar. For 1 pint of extract, add up to a tablespoon of cane sugar; for a quart, add 2 tablespoons. This will soften the harsh smell of alcohol and initiate the aging process.

How many vanilla beans does it take to make a gallon of extract? ›

According to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), to be labelled pure single-fold vanilla extract the liquid must contain 13.35 ounces of natural vanilla beans in every gallon of alcohol. Commercial double-fold pure vanilla extract contains 23 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon of alcohol.

How long can you keep rum punch in the fridge? ›

When you add hard liquors to fruit juice, they work as preservatives, preventing juices from spoiling. Rum punch can “survive” for 2 weeks or even more.

Can Rumballs go off? ›

No. Rum cannot go bad. Rum stops to age once it is placed into a bottle.

How long can you keep peanut butter balls in the refrigerator? ›

How long do peanut butter balls last in the fridge? Place buckeye balls in an air tight container with parchment paper between the layers in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

Does rum spoil after 10 years? ›

Rum is a very stable spirit and if unopened it will retain its quality and flavour. Once opened, rum can be stored for years without going bad, unless you keep it in an unsealed bottle next to a radiator or in direct sunlight.

Is Bacardi a real rum? ›

Bacardí Rum is made with the special combination of molasses from sugarcane, yeast and water.

Do you keep rum in fridge or freezer? ›

Spirits like whiskey, rum, gin, vodka, etc. don't need to be refrigerated because the high alcohol content preserves their integrity. And most liqueurs also have a satisfactorily high alcohol content, as well as sugar that also helps to keep the flavors preserved.

Can you get drunk on bourbon balls? ›

Can eating bourbon balls make you drunk? While bourbon balls certainly contain enough alcohol to taste that it's there, the likelihood of getting drunk off of them is very minimal. Only 1/4 cup of bourbon is used, which is then dispersed among 2-3 cups of other ingredients and then divided into 24 different candies.

Why peanut butter should not be refrigerated? ›

Thanks to stabilizers, such as palm oil, that are found in processed versions of peanut butter, the product has a long shelf life; this means you do not need to refrigerate it, says Dr.

Is expired peanut butter still good? ›

Unopened peanut butter can last for months or even years after the “best by” date, depending on how much preservatives it contains. What is this? Opened peanut butter, if stored in the fridge, can stay fine to use for at least a few months past the date on the package.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5959

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.