We Asked 7 Bartenders: What’s the Most Overrated Bourbon? (2024)

Bourbon drinkers might see themselves in one of three camps. There are the unicorn hunters, always on the lookout for rare and special bottles. There are those who opt for the old faithful, widely available bourbons they’ve been sipping for years. And finally, there are those who enjoy exploring lesser-known names not yet embraced by the wider whiskey community. In each of these groups, there’s a seemingly endless selection of bottles to choose from, with a range of prices, mash bills, and flavor profiles.

Of all these bottles — the cheap and the expensive; the popular and the obscure — there are some that constantly disappoint the pros with high price tags, low availability, or so-so tastes.

We asked seven bartenders to share their opinions on the most overrated bourbons on the market today. From the underwhelming bottles they personally won’t drink to the ones they caution their customers against buying, here are the bourbons top bartenders are calling overrated.

Don't Miss A Drop

Get the latest in beer, wine, and co*cktail culture sent straight to your inbox.

The Most Overrated Bourbons According to Bartenders:

Pappy Van Winkle
Blanton’s
Jefferson’s Ocean

“Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 23 Year is a prime example of a product that has gained popularity due to its scarcity. Compared to other higher-aged bourbons, it’s lost its complexity to the overpowering woodiness. Plus, it usually retails for over $5,000. If you’re going to splurge on a bourbon over 20 years, I’d recommend Michter’s 25 Year Old Single Barrel. It’s still way out of my price range, but at least I can justify the price tag.” —Ben Yabrow, lead bartender, Double Chicken Please, NYC

“Pappy Van Winkle. I don’t think it’s well made, and people overhype it because of its availability.” —Thandi Walton, head of beverage, Thompson Buckhead, Atlanta

“Without a doubt, any of the Pappy Van Winkle whiskeys. I’ve tried all of them, and although they’re good, they definitely shouldn’t be fetching thousands of dollars on the secondary market. MGP has some much better-tasting bourbons out there under a variety of labels, in my opinion.” —Daniel Keaveney, bartender, @lasvegas.bartender, Las Vegas

“The most overrated bourbon has to be Blanton’s. I know it’s an easy target, but in a year of supply chain issues, no one needs another hard-to-get bottle that costs way too much. There are an abundance of high-quality single barrel bourbons on the market, such as Evan Williams Single Barrel or Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel. And if you’re into collecting the horses? I recommend collecting something actually cool, like Pokémon cards.” —Brian Bolton, lead bartender, The Town Company, Kansas City, Mo.

“Personally, I find Blanton’s to be quite overrated when it comes to bourbon. I drink, select, and sell whiskey for a living, so while their bottle design is great, the actual whiskey isn’t quite worth the price point compared to other delicious high-rye bourbons on the market with higher rye content. As examples, Chattanooga Whiskey Co., Leiper’s Fork, Tumblin’ Dice, and Woodinville all produce great whiskies for bourbon lovers that enjoy more rye in their mash.” —Dee J. Reid,
founder, Deestilled; managing partner, Seelbach’s, Washington, D.C.

“The most overrated are the ones that pay for press, artificially limit their supply to drive up demand, and claim a legacy longer than most of us have been alive. Transparency is key when determining quality drams. The whiskey alone should speak for itself.” —Josh Alden, beverage director, Reserve 101, Houston

“Saying a bourbon is the ‘most overrated’ doesn’t seem fair, yet as a bartender, it is a necessary evil because so many of our guests base their opinions on our reviews. Jefferson’s Bourbon has dedicated many years to making good whiskey. The first and 13th releases are my personal favorites, full of sharp wood characteristics with subtle hints of a salty finish inside a beautiful dark amber color. Yet, almost all other releases I have tried are mute in comparison, and those subtle notes of salt have disappeared. The main reason I choose Jefferson’s Ocean as an overrated bourbon is because it has become so popular that many guests will ask for it in an Old Fashioned or a Manhattan. When it’s mixed into a co*cktail, it loses all the characteristics that made it special in the first place. Drink this bourbon neat or on ice. Otherwise, try Jefferson’s Reserve for a great co*cktail.” —Zachary Helton, bartender, Amendment 18 co*cktail Club, Franklin, Tenn.

Published: March 7, 2022

We Asked 7 Bartenders: What’s the Most Overrated Bourbon? (2024)

FAQs

Is Angels Envy overrated? ›

Just to be clear – we are NOT saying these whiskeys are bad – we are saying they are overrated. Store Owners love to tout Angel's Envy as a top shelf bourbon – especially to more inexperienced drinkers. However, the bourbon is just too sweet for many people's liking.

Tell Me More ›

How many years is Elmer T Lee aged? ›

Lee's single barrel Bourbon is bottled from an individual ageing barrel, not from the blend of many. It has no age statement, but it is assumed the average age is 9-14 years. Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel Bourbon has won Gold at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition in 2013, and countless others over the years.

Learn More ›

Which Weller is like Pappy? ›

Weller Special Reserve Bourbon

Why We Like It: The best Pappy Van Winkle alternative is the Weller line, particularly the Special Reserve Bourbon. Each bottle shares the same recipe, proof [2], and specifications of barrels, according to Fred Minnick and Freddie Johnson.

Show Me More ›

Is A Blanton rare? ›

There are fewer than six known bottles of Blanton's Sterling Silver in the world right now (there were only 100 ever made), and one is the vault at Buffalo Trace Distillery. The bottle was gifted to Japanese retailers in 1991.

See Details ›

Is Angel's Envy top shelf bourbon? ›

Yes. Angel's Envy is a top-shelf bourbon; it is not your regular expression. It also costs higher than traditional bourbons, justified by its top-quality character.

Get More Info ›

Is Angels Envy real bourbon? ›

Today's bourbon review isn't actually a bourbon, the Angel's Envy Bourbon Whiskey is a whiskey specialty because bourbon can't touch anything but new charred oak. Which is also why on their site it's billed as Angel's Envy Whiskey.

Know More ›

What age is Blanton's? ›

Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon is typically aged for 6 to 8 years. It is aged in Warehouse H at Buffalo Trace, which is the only metal-cladded warehouse at Buffalo Trace and was commissioned for construction by one of the distillery's early leaders, Albert B.

Find Out More ›

How many years is Jack Daniels aged? ›

Aged at least four years in new, charred American oak barrels which the distillery makes itself. Old No. 7 (sometimes referred to as Black Label or just Jack) is made from a mash bill of 80% corn, 12% barley, and 8% rye.

Keep Reading ›

How old is Stagg Jr? ›

Stagg (which is 15 years old) label.

Learn More Now ›

What is the poor man's Pappy Van Winkle? ›

“Poor Man's Pappy” is a 2:3 blend of Weller 12 yr + Old Weller Antique 107. For a ready to to drink blend of Poor Man's Pappy, pour 2 parts (40%) Weller 12 year and 3 parts (60%) Old Weller Antique 107 into a glass.

Find Out More ›

What is the closest bourbon to Weller? ›

Rebel Yell 10 Year Single Barrel and Weller 12 Similarities:

Taste: Both are light and fruity with a bit of creaminess.
Mashbill: Both are wheated bourbons.
Price: Both bourbons will be priced well above the $100 mark.
Age: While Weller is older, Rebel Yell clocks in at 10 years, making it a similarly mature bourbon.

Jan 9, 2023

Is Weller as good as Pappy? ›

Blame this on whiskey geeks who discovered that Weller is basically Pappy (made at Buffalo Trace using the same mash bill), but aged for different amounts of time and in different warehouses. This makes Weller probably the closest thing to Pappy you can find, and for that reason it has become another cult whiskey.

Is Angel's Envy wheated or rye? ›

Angel's Envy is a brand of rye whiskey. It is produced by the Angel's Envy Distillery in Louisville, Kentucky (now owned by the Louisville Distilling Company, a subsidiary of Bacardi Limited).