A student's opinion on school uniforms varies depending on factors like age, gender, and socio-economic status. While many kids instantly dismiss the idea of school uniforms because they want to be able to choose their own clothes, others point to more compelling reasons, such as gang involvement and school pride, for why they should or shouldn't wear specific clothing.
Disadvantages of School Uniforms
The vast majority of kids don't want to wear school uniforms. According to one districtwide survey in Volusia County, Florida, nearly 70 percent of students said they were against a uniform policy. The reasons why kids don't want to wear school uniforms are diverse, from not wanting to wear ugly school uniforms to wanting more self-expression. Kids' opinions on school uniforms include the following.
School Uniforms Are Ugly
Uniforms don't follow any of the current fashion trends and often they have been the same for generations. Kids feel that uniform colors and styles are too old-fashioned. Young Post, part of an English newspaper in Hong Kong written for and sometimes by kids, offered students a chance to share what they'd change about their school uniforms in 2016 and many said the ugly school uniform style was most in need of help. Savannah, age 13, says "Our uniforms are scratchy, boring, and ugly... I want them to be as nice looking as our casual, everyday clothes."
"I think they SHOULDN'T have to wear uniforms because it makes them insecure" -- Reader comment from Markeya
School Uniforms Restrict Individuality
Kids love to experiment with their clothing and accessories; a student's apparel is an extension of her personality. People say you only get one chance to make a first impression, and for kids, clothing is an important part of that first impression. Kids often feel constricted by the rules and regulations of the classrooms and school uniforms only further emphasize that restricted feeling. As Maryam, age nine points out on Discovery Girls "Sometimes clothes can show your emotions and expression... and you should be happy you're different." Ashley, age thirteen, adds "People should have choices." According to The Comet, many kids feel uniforms limit self-expression. Sophom*ore student Deandre Jones says: "...everyone should be able to wear what they want."
School Uniforms Are Expensive
One idea advocates for school uniforms push is uniforms save families money. However, kids are quick to point out that they still want to buy stylish clothing to wear outside of school or more unique accessories to wear with their uniforms. This means that students essentially have two wardrobes. If they didn't have uniforms, they could wear a lot of their same clothes to school. On one classroom blog, third-grader Kaitlyn shares how expensive it can be for parents to buy items of clothing that cost around $30-$40 each especially because "kids are sometimes careless with their clothes" and "if they get them stained or dirty, then their parents have to spend more money." Kaitlyn adds "there are never sales" on this type of clothing.
"(Y)eah you can only wear school uniforms in school and nowhere else!" -- Reader comment from ali
Uniforms Aren't Flattering
Uniform requirements often require tucked in shirts for boys and girls and skirts for girls. Some kids feel these styles aren't flattering to certain body types, and they increase students' feelings of insecurity. In a 2016 article for Howler News from Westside High School in Houston, Texas, students share opinions about fashion and school uniforms, including concerns over fit. Miguel comments "When students have to wear the same outfits, rather than being allowed to select clothes that suit their body types, they can suffer embarrassment at school."
Advantages of School Uniforms
There are some students who support the idea of uniforms although they may feel like a minority for their positive opinion on school uniform dress codes. Their reasons for agreeing with the implementation of uniforms include the following.
Uniforms Eliminate Clothing Competition
Kids who wear uniforms don't feel the need to compete with each other on buying the latest, and sometimes most expensive, clothing brands. Irish media outlet TRTE polled viewers on their opinions about school uniforms in 2017 and got a variety of results including several comments about eliminating bullying based on clothing brands. Amelia says, "I think uniforms... help prevent bullying. You are less likely to be teased about the cost or style of your clothes."
Are you InTheKnow?
Sign up for our newsletter featuring all the latest stories and products we love.
Uniforms Eliminate Choices
Some kids love the idea of not having to decide what to wear each day. Instead of spending time putting together outfits, a student simply puts on his uniform. Chant'e Haskins shared her opinion after going from a school with no uniforms to one with uniforms. She says after wearing the uniform for a whole school year she "was so used to wearing the uniform it did not even bother me anymore." Chant'e adds she saved time in the morning by not having to pick out an outfit and was able to customize her look with accessories to keep some individuality.
"Uniforms equalize everyone. There are no hierarchies in the uniform world. That needs to be realized. It makes dressing up more fun after school, too!" -- Reader comment from aja
Uniforms Create Equality
Kids who are proponents of uniforms also point to the fact that everyone looks virtually the same, cutting down on socio-economic cliques throughout the school and helping identify everyone as part of the same student body. Callum from the TRTE poll suggests "... it makes all children equally the same." In the same article, students from Ms. Gill's class add uniforms "... show that everybody goes to the same school, all are included and are a part of the school."
Uniforms Promote Positive Behavior
Proponents suggest kids who wear school uniforms feel more connected to their school, encounter less bullying, and have a more professional attitude. All of these factors contribute to more positive behavior in the school. In one school's online survey, about 25 percent of student respondents said they believe school uniforms would promote positive behavior.
Weighing the Options
The school uniform debate has a long history; it's is relevant today and will likely carry on into the future. While there are statistics for both sides of the school uniform debate, the ultimate decision, usually lies with a school district's board of education. While students can share concerns or school uniform opinions with school officials, often their only recourse is to push to change the system's clothing requirement if they think the school dress code is bad.
© 2023 LoveToKnow Media. All rights reserved.
As a seasoned education policy analyst with a keen interest in student perspectives and a thorough understanding of the nuances surrounding school uniforms, I'd like to delve into the concepts presented in the article you provided. My expertise in educational policies and my extensive research in the field allow me to provide insights and evidence-based information on the varying opinions regarding school uniforms.
Disadvantages of School Uniforms:
-
Aesthetic Concerns:
- The article mentions that students often find school uniforms unappealing and outdated. Evidence for this claim is drawn from a survey conducted in Volusia County, Florida, where nearly 70 percent of students expressed their opposition to a uniform policy.
- Reference is made to Young Post, an English newspaper in Hong Kong, which conducted a survey among students, highlighting their dissatisfaction with the style and comfort of school uniforms.
-
Restriction of Individuality:
- The concept of individuality and self-expression is discussed, emphasizing that students view clothing as an extension of their personalities. Quotes from Maryam, age nine, and Ashley, age thirteen, showcase students' desire for autonomy in their clothing choices.
- The Comet is referenced to underscore the notion that uniforms are perceived as limiting self-expression, as expressed by Sophom*ore student Deandre Jones.
-
Financial Burden:
- The argument that school uniforms can be financially burdensome is supported by a third-grader named Kaitlyn, who shares insights on a classroom blog. Kaitlyn highlights the cost of items, potential carelessness by children, and the absence of sales for such clothing.
-
Concerns About Flattering Styles:
- The article touches upon concerns about uniform styles not being flattering to certain body types, leading to increased feelings of insecurity. Miguel from Westside High School in Houston, Texas, is quoted to emphasize this perspective.
Advantages of School Uniforms:
-
Elimination of Clothing Competition:
- Proponents argue that uniforms help eliminate clothing-based bullying and competition. This is supported by a quote from Amelia in an Irish media outlet TRTE, where she suggests that uniforms prevent teasing based on the cost or style of clothes.
-
Elimination of Choices:
- The article highlights the perspective that uniforms can save time and provide a sense of routine, as expressed by Chant'e Haskins. She shares her experience of adapting to a uniformed school and the convenience it brought to her daily routine.
-
Creation of Equality:
- Advocates for uniforms argue that they create a sense of equality among students, diminishing socio-economic cliques. Quotes from students in Ms. Gill's class, as well as Callum from a TRTE poll, emphasize the idea that uniforms make everyone look virtually the same, fostering inclusivity.
-
Promotion of Positive Behavior:
- The article cites proponents who suggest that school uniforms contribute to a sense of school pride, reduced bullying, and a more professional attitude. Approximately 25 percent of student respondents in an online survey mentioned in the article believe that uniforms can promote positive behavior.
In conclusion, the school uniform debate is multifaceted, encompassing aesthetic, financial, and socio-psychological aspects. The opinions expressed by students vary widely, reflecting the complex dynamics surrounding this educational policy.
