Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (2024)

Blog

Written By

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (1)

Ice cream sundaes are an American tradition, but the name will leave you scratching your head. To start, it's ice cream sundae, not ice cream Sunday. Traditional sundaes consist of vanilla ice cream topped with syrup, whipped cream, and a cherry served in a tulip-shaped glass or bowl. Sundaes are delicious and a favorite ice cream option for those stopping by an old-time ice cream shop, but the history of the ice cream sundae is unknown. However, most stories can agree on two main points: why the sundae was created and why the spelling is not the same as the day of the week.

The Origin of Ice Cream Sundaes

According to the origin stories, ice cream sundaes are the result of Blue Laws. You may blame Blue Laws for why you mustwatchmid-Sunday football gameswithout a cold one, but the law that led to sundaes doesn’t involve alcohol. In the late 1800s, there was another Blue Law on the books in some states that made it illegal to sell soda on Sundays. Why this was considered sinful is anyone’s guess.

This ban was a big problem for anyone who enjoyed ice cream floats. Pharmacies had to find another way to convince people to buy ice cream on Sundays, so they replaced the soda with chocolate sauce.

As for why the concoction is called “sundae” instead of “Sunday” in honor of its origins, it was either to make it more obvious that you could buy the ice cream on any day of the week or so it would be less offensive to devout people pharmacists were trying to appeal to. To add even more confusion, the sundae may even get its name from ice cream left over from Sunday that was sold on another day!

Many Claim to be the Creator of the Ice Cream Sundae

Though several cities claim to be the proud originators of theice cream sundae we can’t say who is the real home of the sundae.Sowho are the contenders for the creation of the sundae? Here are the three likely creators:

Two Rivers, Wisconsin, claims that on a Sunday in 1881, pharmacist Edward Berners replaced the soda on an order for an ice cream soda to be compliant with the Blue Law. (He relied on a technicality and added chocolate soda syrup, not the final soda product, on the order.) He was quickly met with requests from customers for this ice cream and syrup treat. If this story is true, the sundae gets its name from Berners originally only selling the option on Sundays before adding it to the permanent menu.

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (3)

Ithaca, New York, has a similar story. On a spring Sunday in 1892, a minister asked Chester C. Platt for vanilla ice cream. Platt topped the ice cream with cherries and cherry syrup. The minister was a fan of the additions and suggested that the ice cream should be named for the day that it was created. Platt agreed, later changing the spelling so it didn't offend anyone. It’s unclear if he was being proactive or had offended leaders of a local church with the name. Regardless, he expanded his syrup offerings as the treat became a local hit.

And then there’s the sundae origin story of Plainfield, Illinois, which also claims to be the home of the ice cream sundae. A pharmacist named Charles Sonntag created the treat, naming it the "sonntag" after himself. Sonntag means Sunday in German, and so the name was translated to Sunday, and later spelled as “sundae”.

Sundaes Make Fundays Any Day

Though we can’t pinpoint where the first sundae was made, the creation is still popular over a century after fans first tasted the ice cream combination. The next time you sit down to cool off with the treat, share some sundae tidbits between each spoonful.

Related Posts

Featured

Animal Care Practices in the Dairy Barn

Animal care in the dairy barn is an important aspect of dairy farming across the Southeast. Comfortable cows produce more milk, so not only is good animal care the right thing to do, but cow care also makes financial sense for the dairy farm family to keep on farming.

Virtual Farm Tour of Tri-Spring Jerseys: Connecting Dairy Farming With the Classroom

Join us for a virtual farm tour on June 7th at 12 PM CST to Tri Springs Jersey Farm in Henry County, Tennessee, to highlight resources and lesson plans available to STEM educators.

Let’s Celebrate the Alabama Dairy Industry

In honor of National Dairy Month this June, we will be looking at the impact of dairy in each state within The Dairy Alliance’s eight-state region: Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia.

First up is Alabama!

Previous Previous How Workaholics Can Take a Break Next Next Aaah! It’s Ice Cream Month!

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (7)

We are global advocates for dairy as an essential ingredient to life.

Log in to our portal

Dairy Farming for Consumers

Visit Our Dairy Farms

Overview

Meet Our DairyFarmers

Virtual Field Trip

Virtual Farm Tours

Group Dairy Farm Tours

Meet Our Dairy Cows

Milk Agricultural Safety

Sustainability and the Dairy Industry

Overview

Dairy Farmer Resources

National Dairy Month

Checkoff at Work

Dairy Recipes

All Recipes

Dairy Drinks

Desserts

Kid-Friendly

Lactose Free

Salads and Sides

Dairy in Schools

Overview

Moo Brew

Milk Dispensers

Nutrient Rich Smoothies

High School Sports Nutrition Resources

Strive for 35

School MIlk Supply Toolkit

Current Dairy Resources

World School Milk Day

Contact Youth Wellness Team

Dairy Nutrition

Overview

Health Benefits

Bone Health

Lactose Intolerance

Milk Impersonators

Functional Foods

Nutrition Toolkits

Resources

Blog

Newsroom

Farmers Map

School Staff Map

Site Map

About Us

Our Story

The Alliance Team

FAQ

Careers

Contact Us

Official Sweepstakes Rules

Privacy Policy

© 2024 The Dairy Alliance | Website Design by Winn-Brown & Co

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (8)

Discover the World of Dairy Farming With The Dairy Alliance

Making Every Drop Count ↗

For Consumers

Overview

Visit Our Dairy Farms

Meet Our Dairy Farmers

Virtual Field Trip

Virtual Farm Tours

Group Dairy Farm Tours

Meet Our Dairy Cows

Milk Agricultural Safety

Sustainability and the Dairy Industry

For Farmers

Overview

Checkoff at Work

Dairy Farmer Resources

National Dairy Month

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (9)

Looking for School Recipes?

Visit our Dairy in Schools section ↗

Dairy Recipes

All Recipes

Dairy Drinks

Desserts

Lunch and Dinners

Kid-Friendly

Lactose Free

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (10)

Dairy in Schools

We partner with schools to expand opportunities for students to make healthy food choices.

Contact Our Youth Wellness Team

K-12

Overview

Moo Brew

Milk Dispensers

Nutrient Rich Smoothies

High School Sports Nutrition Resources

Strive for 35

School Milk Supply Toolkit

Current Dairy Resources

World School Milk Day

Colleges & Universities (coming soon)

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (11)

Make It Count With Milk

Download PDF ↗

Dairy Nutrition

Overview

Health Benefits of Dairy Products

Bone Health

Lactose Intolerance

Milk Impersonators

Functional Foods

Nutrition Toolkits

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (12)

It’s Balanced Nutrition By Milk ↗

Explore Our Resources

Blog

Newsroom

School Staff Map

Professional Resources

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (13)

Making Milk Cool ↗

About Us

Our Story

Careers

The Dairy Alliance Team

Contact Us

FAQs

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? (2024)

FAQs

Why is it an Ice Cream Sundae, not Ice Cream Sunday? ›

As for why the concoction is called “sundae” instead of “Sunday” in honor of its origins, it was either to make it more obvious that you could buy the ice cream on any day of the week or so it would be less offensive to devout people pharmacists were trying to appeal to.

Why is ice cream sundae spelled differently? ›

A local belief is that a Plainfield druggist named Mr. Sonntag created the dish "after the urgings of patrons to serve something different." He named it the "sonntag" after himself, and since Sonntag is the German word for Sunday, the name was translated to Sunday, and later was spelled sundae.

Is it ice cream sundae or sundae? ›

To avoid offending those devoutly religious, the treat received an official title of “ice cream sundae.” The misspelling of Sunday was purposeful to assure religious leaders that the treat was not named after the Sabbath.

What is the origin of the ice cream sundae? ›

Several cities claim to have invented the ice cream sundae. These places include: New Orleans, Louisiana; Ithaca, New York; Two Rivers, Wisconsin; and Evanston, Illinois. The original sundae, which can be traced back to the late 1800s, consisted of a small bowl of ice cream with chocolate syrup.

Why were ice cream sodas banned on Sundays? ›

Some religious groups were against what they called “sucking sodas” and felt that this activity should be banned on the Sabbath. This ban on Sunday soda sales was a big problem for anyone that enjoyed root beer floats or other ice cream sodas.

Why is sundae spelt with an AE? ›

As for why the concoction is called “sundae” instead of “Sunday” in honor of its origins, it was either to make it more obvious that you could buy the ice cream on any day of the week or so it would be less offensive to devout people pharmacists were trying to appeal to.

Why is ice cream not hyphenated? ›

But we don't need the hyphenation table in this case; as we have seen, “ice cream” is an established open compound (or a permanent compound, according to CMOS 7.82). And according to a Google Ngram query, the unhyphenated version is significantly more common in published books.

How do you spell Sunday like ice cream sundae? ›

The correct spelling is “ice cream sundae.” Yes, it is likely related to a day of the week, but it should not be spelled that way (anymore). An “ice cream Sunday” might be a lovely Sunday (as in the day of the week) when one gets a special ice cream treat, but it's not the name of that treat.

Is McDonald's sundae ice cream? ›

Our classic Hot Fudge Sundae is made with creamy vanilla soft serve and smothered in chocolatey hot fudge topping. It's a perfectly sweet addition to any of your favorite McDonald's items. There are 330 calories in a McDonald's Hot Fudge Sundae. *Mobile Order & Pay at participating McDonald's.

What is a French sundae? ›

A classic French sundae is the Chocolat Liegeois made with chocolate ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate sauce.

What is a fun fact about ice cream sundaes? ›

Historians suggest that the ice cream sundae originated as a workaround for the Blue Laws that prohibited the sale of ice cream sodas on Sundays. No matter where the Sundae originated, we think it was a good invention. And we serve some of the best around!

Is a banana split a sundae? ›

Who Invented the Banana Split? A 23-year-old pharmacist apprentice named David Evans Strickler is credited with inventing the banana triple ice cream sundae in 1904.

What was the biggest ice cream sundae in history? ›

The largest ice cream sundae was one weighing 24.91 tonnes (54,917 lb) made by Palm Dairies Ltd under the supervision of Mike Rogiani in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada on 24 July 1988.

In which US state was it once illegal to serve ice cream on cherry pie? ›

For some reason, there's a law in Kansas that makes it illegal to eat cherry pie with a scoop of ice cream on top. Nobody seems to be sure what prompted this law, but luckily its not enforced.

Which soft drinks are banned? ›

Several Indian states have already banned the sale of co*ke and Pepsi at schools and colleges after scientists found they were contaminated by pesticides. Kerala is the first Indian state to ban producing or selling the drinks; its neighbour Karnataka has banned them from schools, colleges and hospitals.

Did Wisconsin invent the ice cream sundae? ›

Soda fountain owner, Ed Berners of Two Rivers, Wisconsin is reputed to have invented the first ice cream sundae in 1881. Berners's customer George Hallauer requested that Berners serve him a dish of ice cream topped with the syrup used for sodas.

Why are some ice creams not called ice cream? ›

According to the USDA, "ice cream shall contain at least 1.6 pounds of total solids to the gallon, weigh not less than 4.5 pounds to the gallon, and contain not less than 20 percent total milk solids, constituted of not less than 10 percent milkfat." Overall, this translates to milkfat weight being the biggest factor ...

What is the difference between Sunday and sundae? ›

How Do You Spell Sunday? If you're talking about the day of the week, it's S-u-n-d-a-y, and if you're talking about the chilly desert, it's s-u-n-d-a-e.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 6156

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.