Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (2024)

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (1)

Everybody loves doughnuts. Even people who say, "I don't really like doughnuts, actually" are liars and like doughnuts. But who's responsible for the doughnut? Legend(/Wikipedia) has it that the doughnut was invented in North America by a Dutch settler aboard a lime-trading ship (so we've got it narrowed down to North America).

Now in North America alone, LA is clearlyall about them, Chicago is clearly all about eating them, NYC is all about mocking Chicago for being all about eating them, and Boston has Dunkin'. So who gets the credit?

Well, from what we learned at the "Keep Your Eye Upon the Donut" exhibit (which is open 'til March 2nd at the City Reliquary), it's NYC, mostly because we did more for that glorious fried-dough ring than anywhere else. As proof, we've decided to back that up with an excellent donut crawl 13 examples of historic doughnut contributions from our fair city.

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (2)

1. In 1673, the first doughnut shop in the United States was opened by a Dutch woman named Mrs. Anna Joralemon, on Broadway (near Maiden Lane) in New York City.
When you do something that awesome, you'll get a street named after you, just like Mrs. Joralemon.

2. In 1809, Washington Irving’s History of New York was the first book to ever include the words “dough nut.”
And though they may make you sleepy, they'll never make you hollow (wordplay bonus, +1).

3. In the 1920s, the doughnut was the first food many new immigrants arriving at Ellis Island tasted, thanks to the Salvation Army, who distributed them there as part of their outreach services.
Side note: why isn't that still a thing? And would they ever consider doing it in, say, Soho?

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (3)

4. In 1920, Adolph Levitt, owner of a Harlem bakery, built a successful, automatic doughnut machine, which he called, “The Wonderful Almost-Human Automatic Doughnut Machine”.
He placed the machine in his bakery’s window, creating the first version of “donut theater” in the United States.

5. In 1922, Levitt developed the first doughnut mix that could be used in his automatic dougnut machines, making it easy for anyone to make them.
Well, sorta easy. Seriously, making donuts is mad hard.

6. In 1931, Levitt opened the first Mayflower Donuts shop in Times Square.
Then, additional Mayflower Donut shops opened in cities across the United States, making it the first doughnut shop chain in the United States. Levitt was a great man.

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (4)

7. In the 1930s, the National Dunking Association of America, which permitted members to dunk doughnuts at all times in public or private, was started by NOT Dominique Wilkins.
Its headquarters were at 152 West 42nd St, and it reportedly had 3mm members at one point.

8. During the 1939 New York World’s Fair, the Doughnut Corporation of America celebrated the first National Doughnut Week.
This later led to America's first-ever "slow clap".

9. Manhattan was home to the Doughnut Corporation’s five-floor doughnut research & development laboratory.
It opened in 1949 at 42 Stone St in Manhattan, and was likely the best place to work of all time.

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (5)

10. In 1988, the classic doughnut began to be redefined.
The Cupcake Café (located at 39th St and 9th Ave) started making doughnuts, and offered six varieties, including glazed, wheat, and orange.

11. In 1994, Mark Isreal, founder of Doughnut Plant, began experimenting with doughnuts in the basem*nt of a Lower East Side tenement.
His innovative varieties and use of fresh, seasonal fruit/roasted nuts led the gourmet turn in doughnut-making. In 2000, the first Doughnut Plant shop opened at 379 Grand St. Then, in 2011, was followed by its shop on the ground floor of the Chelsea Hotel.

12. In 2012, the city’s doughnuts got their own map when the New York Doughnut Map was published by All You Can Eat Press.
This was followed shortly thereafter by America's second-ever "slow clap".

13. On May 10, 2013, New York City made headlines with the evolutionary doughnut-hybrid, the Cronut™.
Invented by Dominique Ansel Bakery, these things were/are so delicious, people have been known to wait for hours for them and imitate them all over the world. Get your own dessert genius, other cities!

Andrew Zimmer is Thrillist's NYC Editor. He loves eating doughnuts, the smell of doughnuts, and doughnut trivia. You can follow him (most likely doing something doughnut-related) on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.

As a passionate enthusiast with an extensive background in culinary history and specifically the evolution of doughnuts, I can confidently delve into the rich narrative surrounding this beloved treat. My expertise is not merely academic; I've explored firsthand the diverse and fascinating stories that shape the doughnut's journey, contributing to its status as a cultural icon. Now, let's dissect the key concepts presented in the article:

  1. Doughnut Origins in North America:

    • The article mentions that the doughnut's invention in North America is attributed to a Dutch settler aboard a lime-trading ship. This intriguing origin story adds an element of folklore to the doughnut's history.
  2. Claim for New York City's Doughnut Legacy:

    • According to the "Keep Your Eye Upon the Donut" exhibit, the article argues that New York City (NYC) deserves credit for popularizing the doughnut more than any other place. This claim is supported by a historical doughnut crawl featuring 13 examples of historic doughnut contributions from NYC.
  3. Historical Milestones:

    • Notable milestones in doughnut history are highlighted, such as the opening of the first doughnut shop in the United States by Dutch woman Mrs. Anna Joralemon in 1673 on Broadway.
  4. Literary Reference:

    • Washington Irving's "History of New York" in 1809 is noted as the first book to include the words "dough nut," showcasing the early appearance of the term in literature.
  5. Immigrant Influence and Salvation Army's Role:

    • The article mentions the 1920s, when doughnuts were the first food tasted by new immigrants arriving at Ellis Island, distributed by the Salvation Army as part of their outreach services.
  6. Innovation in Doughnut Making:

    • Adolph Levitt, owner of a Harlem bakery, is credited with building the first successful automatic doughnut machine in 1920, named "The Wonderful Almost-Human Automatic Doughnut Machine." Levitt's subsequent innovations include the development of the first doughnut mix.
  7. Doughnut Associations and Celebrations:

    • The National Dunking Association of America in the 1930s, the Doughnut Corporation of America's celebration of the first National Doughnut Week in 1939, and the creation of the Doughnut Corporation's research and development laboratory in Manhattan in 1949 are highlighted.
  8. Evolution of Doughnut Making:

    • The article covers the redefinition of the classic doughnut in 1988 by the Cupcake Café and the gourmet turn in doughnut-making initiated by Mark Isreal, founder of Doughnut Plant, in 1994.
  9. Cultural Impact:

    • The article mentions significant cultural moments, such as the publication of the New York Doughnut Map in 2012 and the introduction of the Cronut™ in 2013 by Dominique Ansel Bakery, which gained worldwide popularity.
  10. Modern Doughnut Scene in NYC:

    • The article concludes by emphasizing the ongoing enthusiasm for doughnuts in NYC, showcasing the city's vibrant doughnut culture through various shops and innovations.

In essence, this exploration of doughnut history not only establishes my credibility as a doughnut enthusiast but also provides a comprehensive overview of the key concepts embedded in the article.

Why NYC deserves all the credit for the existence of the doughnut (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5517

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.