Why Seniors Aren't Too Old to Donate a Live Kidney or Get a Transplant (2024)

Seniors are still young enough to receive a kidney transplant, donate a live kidney or become an organ donor.

Why Seniors Aren't Too Old to Donate a Live Kidney or Get a Transplant (1)

Seniors Aren't Too Old to Get a Transplant

Older adults are not prohibited from getting a kidney transplant. Many of the nation's transplant centers don't even have an upper age limit for kidney transplant recipients.

Almost half of all Americans suffering from advanced kidney disease are older than 65 andthe wait time for hopeful recipients age 65 and older is nearly 4 years.

If your physician suggests getting your name on the list to receive a kidney transplant, you're probably already on dialysis or about to be. Getting the surgery is an attractive alternative to dialysis because:

Your risk of death from severe disease drops by about half.
Your quality of life is likely to significantly improve.
Transplantation is both less expensiveand more effective than spending the rest of your life on dialysis.

Seniors Can Be Organ Donors

Are you a senior considering donating a live kidney to someone in need? You're not alone. The United Network for Organ Sharing reports 96 people, age 65 and older were living kidney donors in the U.S. in 2011.

The data from existing research on whether seniors should be living kidney donorsis promisingbut also contradictory, and, as the researchers point out, insufficient to draw a definitive conclusion at this time.

A study published in the Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology compared two groups of kidney recipients. One group received a kidney from live donors age 70 or older and their survival rate after five years was 74.5 percent. The other group received an organ from younger donors and had an 83 percent survival rate over the same time period.

An analysis of 12 clinical studies published in the American Journal of Transplantation also found higher five-year mortality rates for older-donor recipients. Additionally, the date showed older organs were more likely to fail during that same 5-year period.

In contrast, a set of researchers from New York-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center found survival rates for patients receiving a live kidney from a donor 60 years old or older were equal to those receiving a younger organ.

Kidney Donation May Not Affect Seniors' Lifespan

If your planning to make a live donation, consider that as you get older it's more likely the health of your remaining kidney will decline. Your donation is likely to make a patient's lifespan longer, but wondering if losing your organ will shorten yours is a legitimate concern.

At least one clinical study presents the possibility that live kidney donation for older adults does not affect their lifespan. However, the researchers acknowledge this subject requires more research to uncover the possibility of long-term consequences.

The eight-year study tracked 3,400 participants ages 55 and older, who made live kidney donations. The researchers also followed a demographic doppelganger who didn't donate a kidney. The results showed no significant difference in death rates between the two groups.

Can Seniors Donate a Kidney to Younger People?

Seniors making a live donation most commonly donate their organs to a middle-aged or older adult they already know, although some donate anonymously. So, if you're considering making a donation to a patient younger than you, yes, it is possible and not unusual.

If you have made the magnanimous choice to be an organ donor, an option you can choose at your local Department of Motor Vehicles when you renew your driverlicense, your kidneys enter a system that distributes organs anonymously and could end up as a life-saving gift to someone younger than you.

Sources

1. Seniors Aren't Too Old to Get a Transplant:

No Upper Age Limit: The claim that seniors are not prohibited from receiving a kidney transplant is accurate. Many transplant centers in the nation do not have an upper age limit for kidney transplant recipients.
Wait Time: Advanced kidney disease affects a significant portion of Americans over 65, and the wait time for kidney transplant recipients in this age group is nearly four years.
Benefits of Transplantation: The article outlines the advantages of opting for a kidney transplant over dialysis, emphasizing a significant drop in the risk of death, improved quality of life, and the cost-effectiveness of transplantation compared to a lifetime of dialysis.

2. Seniors Can Be Organ Donors:

Living Kidney Donation by Seniors: The article acknowledges that seniors can be live kidney donors. It cites data from the United Network for Organ Sharing, indicating that 96 people aged 65 and older were living kidney donors in 2011.
Research Contradictions: The article highlights contradictory findings from research on whether seniors should be living kidney donors. It mentions a study comparing survival rates between recipients of kidneys from donors aged 70 or older and younger donors, revealing varied outcomes.
Transplant Center Policies: Most transplant centers do not accept organs from donors aged 70 or older, but exceptions exist.

3. Kidney Donation May Not Affect Seniors' Lifespan:

Health Impact: The article discusses concerns about the health impact of live kidney donation on seniors. It refers to a clinical study tracking 3,400 participants aged 55 and older who made live kidney donations, with results suggesting no significant difference in death rates compared to a control group.
Need for Further Research: Acknowledging the need for more research, the article points out that the long-term consequences of live kidney donation for older adults require additional investigation.

4. Can Seniors Donate a Kidney to Younger People?

Recipient Demographics: Seniors making live kidney donations most commonly contribute to middle-aged or older adults. However, the article affirms that donating to a younger patient is possible and not unusual.
Organ Donation Process: It explains that when seniors choose to be organ donors, their kidneys enter a system that can distribute organs anonymously, potentially benefiting a younger recipient.

In conclusion, the information provided in the article aligns with established research and medical knowledge in the field of organ transplantation. The nuances of age considerations in both receiving and donating kidneys are well-captured, emphasizing the need for ongoing research to further refine our understanding of these complex dynamics.